ThePirateBay.org leader Gottfrid Svartholm Warg, speaking to
Swedish newspaper The Local, told recording
industry lawyers to “go screw
themselves” in response to the IFPI’s Monday demands for
$2.5 million in compensatory damages.
The damage figure comes as part of the latest round in the
ongoing legal saga surrounding The Pirate Bay and its leadership, which
includes Svartholm, as well as co-founder Peter “Brokep” Sunde and administrators
Fredrik Neij, among others. The four were indicted late last January on conspiracy
charges, for the site’s role in facilitating piracy for 24 music albums,
nine films, and four computer games.
Svartholm says he and his colleagues laughed at the claimed
amount of damages, which he thinks were calculated by multiplying the number of
the number of properties in the indictment times the number of times they were
downloaded. This is wildly unrealistic, says Svartholm, because most
downloaders would not have paid full price for an album in the first place.
According to Swedish IFPI chapter head Lars Gustaffson, the
$2.5 million claim is “based on the albums which the prosecutor has included in
his indictment. The injury to the record companies, the artists, and the
copyright holders caused by The Pirate Bay’s illegal activity is many times
“As usual, we’re not too concerned,” said Svartholm. “[The
IFPI’s] numbers are pure fantasy.”
Despite continually finding itself under fire for digital piracy,
The Pirate Bay has seen an increasing amount of use as a legitimate channel for
artists and producers looking to experiment with legal BitTorrent distribution:
Trent Reznor famously
uploaded part of his Creative Commons-licensed Ghosts I-IV to The Pirate Bay earlier this month – earning
back $1.6 million in the first week – and The League of Noble Peers likely earned
back all its production costs after experimenting with a novel donation
model for its freely-available Steal This
quote: Copyright infrighment is as illegal as anywhere else
quote: what they are convicted of is enabling copyright infringement
quote: I'm pretty sure record execs unfairly profit far more than regular people running torrent sites.
quote: You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
quote: Roswall says that the four should be made to pay at least $188,000, which the indictment says is the minimum profit that The Pirate Bay made from its activities. If convicted, they could face up to two years in prison.
quote: by Staples on April 2, 2008 at 1:53 AM I am sure there will be a huge group of geeks who will get really excited because after all, these guys are heros. But for people like me who think these guys are a bunch of nobodys, I could care less if these guys all go to prison for the rest of their lives. People complain about Apple fanboys so much but whenever an anti pirate article is posted here, a different group of fanboys come out of the woodworks and these guys are much more annoying than any Apple fanboy.
quote: These "nobodys" created an excellent website with more than two million registered users. Why don't you try doing that seeing you think of yourself so highly. Yeah and I suppose anyone who uses a computer and supports the pirate bay is a bunch of "geeks and fanboys".
quote: Next to nobody uses Pirate Bay
quote: And you must admit, staying around that long as TPB and being up and running again in 3 days after the raid, "fighting" such big lobbies deserves a certain degree of "respect". Despite the fact if its legal or not.
quote:… ThePirateBay is not copyright infringing? It's just another Google, except for torrents.
quote:They don't host illegal files they are a non discriminatory bulletin board basically.
quote: Since when is Torrent itself illegal?