The FCC voted to begin
drafting rules yesterday that would require ISPs to treat all web
traffic the same. The proposed rules would prevent ISPs from blocking
or slowing the bandwidth available to high demand traffic like
streaming video or other applications that can strain networks. The
proposed rules would allow ISPs to block illegal material like child
pornography and spam.
Republican Senator John McCain has
introduced legislation that would block the FCCs proposal for
regulating the neutrality of the Internet. The AFP reports
that McCain said, "the Internet Freedom Act of 2009 [will keep
the internet] free from government control and regulation."
chairman Julius Genachowski said, "reasonable and enforceable
rules of the road [are needed] to preserve a free and open internet."
Genachowski points out that these rules are needed because of "some
significant situations where broadband providers have degraded the
data streams of popular lawful services and blocked consumer access
to lawful applications."
Naturally, companies that make
their money from the internet are supporting
the FCC's proposal. These companies include Amazon, eBay,
Facebook, Google, Twitter, and several other internet firms. McCain
calls the FCC's proposal "onerous federal regulation" and
calls the proposed rules a "government takeover" of the
ComptuerWorld also reports that McCain does
not support including wireless broadband providers in the net
neutrality rules saying, "[The wireless industry] exploded over
the past 20 years due to limited government regulation."
said of his Internet Freedom Act of 2009, "Today I'm pleased to
introduce the Internet Freedom Act of 2009 that will keep the
Internet free from government control and regulation. It will allow
for continued innovation that will in turn create more high-paying
jobs for the millions of Americans who are out of work or seeking new
employment. Keeping businesses free from oppressive regulations is
the best stimulus for the current economy."
quote: "Keeping businesses free from oppressive regulations is the best stimulus for the current economy."
quote: so again, how is that just the Dems fault?
quote: Whining about 1 trillion in stimulus when Bush 2 ran up 5 trills in f'ing debt.
quote: I don't think McCain understands that REGULATING the internet in any physical form is constitutionally unacceptable.
quote: I'd love to see that nonsense of allowing ISP's to hold monopoly regions and open everywhere to whatever ISP wants to move in and provide services for those communities
quote: The problem is that there are many people out there that do not have a choice in their provider (myself included) and canceling the service means no internet whatsoever.
quote: And what about keeping users free from oppressive ISP restrictions?
quote: So how exactly are you being "oppressed"? You admitt yourself that there are two companies providing broadband access in your area. That doesn't sound like "oppression" to me pick the one that you like the best and if the other cleans up thier act switch back.
quote: Then a third company will pop up...yes you might have to live a couple of years with some poor service from the current providers, but in a true free market, when enough people complain or get tired of it a third party will present itself as an alternative to existing service.
quote: Keep in mind the reason you only have two now is due to some Govt intervention 30-40 years ago, that is making it almost impossible for people to start up another service provider.
quote: The Internet is so necessary that people will take what ISPs give them as long as they can afford it.
quote: To your point, neither my wife nor I could effectively perform our current jobs without high speed Internet service at home.
quote: It (The internet) will allow for continued innovation that will in turn create more high-paying jobs for the millions of Americans who are out of work or seeking new employment.
quote: Until I am proven wrong, I firmly believe McCain is out to feed the trolls. Honestly, the internet granted a sense of self-empowerment to any individual who has access to it, but I have yet to find MILLIONS of people who has a high-paying job on it. ;)
quote: Until I am proven wrong, I firmly believe McCain is out to feed the trolls.
quote: Honestly, the internet granted a sense of self-empowerment to any individual who has access to it, but I have yet to find MILLIONS of people who has a high-paying job on it. ;)
quote: Pretty much any non help desk level person with a technical job is make quite a bit more than the average American.
quote: Sure, PC / Windows type support might pay $8 - $10 for level 1, $12 - $14 for a senior type.
quote: But call support for an enterprise level system, and you're talking to someone who makes $60K - $80K.
quote: I've been following Senator McCain on Twitter for months
quote: Does McCain even know what the "internet" is? Last time I heard, he barely started twittering...
quote: The proposed rules would allow ISPs to block illegal material like child pornography and spam.
quote: calls the proposed rules a "government takeover" of the internet.
quote: The CAN-SPAM Act of 2003 was signed into law on December 16, 2003 by President George W. Bush.
quote: By the time the first federal child pornography law took effect in February, 1978
quote: The proposed rules include an exception to allow ISPs to continue to block illegal material like child pornography and spam.