backtop


Print 24 comment(s) - last by nemrod.. on Nov 28 at 2:53 AM


ASUS Eee PC 4G  (Source: Notebook Review)
1.8GB "source" download doesn't have complete sources, and warranty-voiding RAM upgrades may be unenforceable

The ASUS Eee PC has been getting all manner of attention from various sites around the Internet, but recently an Eee owner has taken ASUS to task over potential violations of the GPL and of the long-standing Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. Programmer Cliff Biffle recently bought himself a Galaxy Black Eee PC as a birthday gift, but in attempting to play with the underlying Xandros Linux operating system, found a few major roadblocks in the form of proprietary hardware and software.

Biffle decided to disassemble the software -- which is permitted under the GPL -- and found that the asus_acpi kernel module was modified from the Linux 2.6.21.4 version. While the modification itself is permitted, in order to comply with the regulations of the GPL, ASUS has not published its modified sources, retained prior module attribution (name, version, and author) and has apparently stripped all references to "asus_acpi."

When attempting to obtain the modified sources from the ASUS website, Biffle found that the 1.8GB zipped "source" file on the ASUS page contained only some kernel headers, and a collection of .deb (Debian package) files -- some of which were not even present on the installed Xandros Linux operating system.

This is not the first time that ASUS has been in violation of the GPL -- in 2004, the company's WL-500g wireless router, which contained a Linux kernel and netfilter/iptables, was distributed without source available.

While some companies might be quick to dismiss a GPL violation as inconsequential, the recent filing of a civil suit by the Software Freedom Law Center against two companies, Xterasys Corporation and High-Gain Antennas LLC, might set precedent for stiffer financial penalties.

Unfortunately for ASUS, bad news doesn't stop there. In addition to the possibility of trouble with the GPL, the warranty sticker over the access door to the single SODIMM slot on the Eee PC may be a violation of the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act -- specifically the section dealing with warranty tie-ins. A snippet from the ASUS warranty information is provided (emphasis DailyTech):

The warranty only covers failures or malfunctions occurred during the warranty period and in normal use conditions as will as for any material or workmanship defect. The warranty will not apply if: (a) the product has been tampered, repaired, or modified by non-authorized personnel; ... (c) the warranty seals have been broken or altered; ...

By comparing this excerpt with the example provided by the Federal Trade Commission of an "unacceptable tie-in" it's easy to see where the parallels are drawn. Eee PC modders may have a safety net to fall back on if they've installed an aftermarket memory upgrade or Mini-PCIe card after all.



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

RE: Thanks for saving me $350
By wordsworm on 11/23/2007 11:09:25 PM , Rating: 2
I'm actually not thinking of using it as a real server, just to learn the ropes. Whatever route I go, I need something ultra small and portable. When I move, I use the airplane. So, my worldly possessions must fit within about 40kg of belongings. I thought about going WAMP, but I just don't like the idea of fiddling around with the windows machine.

I wasn't thinking of actually running a server, just learning how to run it. I think the objection to using a loptop is in the extended use, isn't it? Anyways, I have noticed that there are some very small computers being made these days through Via. Cappucino has some interesting computers... so, as you might say, that might be the better choice for me anyways.


RE: Thanks for saving me $350
By Torched on 11/24/2007 3:05:59 PM , Rating: 2
You could try one of the ARK PCs from Advantech. http://www.eplatformpro.com/US/ARK-1370/ARK-1370/s...
http://www.eplatformpro.com/US/Celeron-M-Series/Ce...
Both are just hardware with no power supply or OS, but this makes them configurable. The first one is VESA mountable.
A number of other vendors sell cheap embedded systems that are similar. See Aaeon, Acrosser, Kontron, Lippert, etc.


"Young lady, in this house we obey the laws of thermodynamics!" -- Homer Simpson











botimage
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki