"Legally in the state I live in, I could have kept all 5. The transaction was completed, and I paid for what I ordered. Morally however I just couldn't justify it," writes the member AgentEntropy. "Of course I'd rather have kept the 4 extras than the $50, but who wouldn't?"
quote: However, my idea of treating them right is requesting more than $50 to get their $1600 back on the mistake. Offerring 1/32 of the value as a reward is borderline offensive and would almost imply they don't really care if they get it back ( not to mention it literally barely covers the time of re-sealing the box, getting the new shipping sticker in the mail and shipping it back out ).
quote: I agree with this guy. Newegg has always treated me right, so I'd treat the right too.