backtop


Print 24 comment(s) - last by ppardee.. on Mar 18 at 3:16 PM

Lawyers move quickly to try to prevent Bitcoin "king" from destroying documents

Well it's come to this Bitcoin robber baron Mark Marie "MagicalTux" Robert Karpelès has had his assets in the U.S. frozen by Judge Gary Feinerman, a U.S. federal judge sitting on the bench at the U.S. District Court for the District of Northern Illinois.

For now the freeze only applies to Mr. Karpelès American assets, which were also the subject of a Monday U.S. Chapter 15 bankruptcy by the law firm of Baker McKenzie.  In the filing Mt. Gox -- once the world's top Bitcoin exchange -- reasserts its claim that it has no idea where all the customer Bitcoins went, saying it only has ¥3.84B ($38.7M USD) in assets (including net worth of its bitcoins versus ¥6.5B ($63.9M USD) in liabilities.

Mr. Karpelès owns a trademark granting exclusive rights to use the term "bitcoin" commercially in Europe.  According to reports he was also fond of employees referring to him as the "king of Bitcoin".  Monday's filing states:

MtGox suspended all trading after internal investigations discovered a loss of 744,408 bitcoins presumably by the method of theft.

MtGox Chapter 15 Filing by ronfm



It's worth noting the legalese here -- the filing doesn't say how soon after discovering the "loss" that trading was halted.  Evidence suggests that Mr. Karpelès knew of the "missing" coins as of Oct. 2013, when the last trade went through.  The wording of the filing makes it sound as if it was filed immediatedly, but if you read carefully it could happen days or even months after the discovery.

Nor does the release say the Bitcoins were surely stolen.  It says they "presumably" were stolen -- they could be sitting in Mr. Karpelès own personal wallet and the state wouldn't technically be a lie.

Tibanne
A federal court refused to grant bankruptcy protections to Mr. Karpelès' Tibanne KK.

The bankruptcy filing was a relatively blatant move to try to block the pending customer class action lawsuit filed by Graham Greene of Chicago, who claims to have lost $25,000 USD worth of Bitcoins when the exchange declared its (supposed) insolvency.

But the grant of Chapter 15 status, won't be officially recognized until April 1, giving Mr. Graham's attorney's ample time to work:

Approval of Mt Gox's Chap. 15 Bankruptcy by steven_musil



On Wednesday one of Mr. Graham's lawyers -- Christopher Dore of the Edelson law firm filed an emergency request for freezing the assets of Mt. Gox KK, Tibanne KK, and Mr. Karpelès himself (who owns 88 percent of Mt. Gox and all of Tibanne).

The Judge told the plaintiff's lawyer that he could not freeze the assets of Mt. Gox as it had filed for Chapter 15 protection.  But it said he could freeze the assets of Mr. Karpelès and Tibanne KK -- the parent company of Mt. Gox, named after Mr. Karpelès' cat.

Mr. Dore, Esq. was pleased with this development stating to ArsTechnica:

Our view is that these companies are alter egos of each other, including Karpeles. He is those companies and they are him, so we should be able to get a lot of information about what has happened.  We will be issuing written discovery in the next day or two to all of those entities and to Mr. Karpeles himself, and we will be issuing deposition.

In addition to the temporary restraining order, the judge granted expedited discovery, which allows Mr. Graham's legal team nearly instant access to Mr. Karpelès company and personal accounts and data, to minimize the window for him to cover up potential crimes.  Mr. Dore, Esq. states:

[The need for expedited discovery] is more [due to] the urgency of the facts and circumstances of this case.  There is an enormous amount of money and bitcoin missing. There is a lot of speculation that there has been money moving out of MtGox accounts, and frankly, we have alleged fraud in this case. When that was raised in court this morning the representatives of MtGox KK did not dispute that fact. We may add additional defendants, possibly including [MtGox’s] bank.

Meanwhile pressure is mounting on Judge Harlin Hale in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas.  In the Dallas, Texas courtroom earlier this week Steven Woodrow, Esq. a lawyer with Edelson's Denver law office, put forth an official claim of fraud for the first time in court, stating:

This case involves a massive fraud.  They claim incredibly that they will preserve assets and protect assets by entrusting the servers and other property to Mr. Karpeles. Respectfully, your honor, that is the definition of the fox guarding the henhouse.

That argument in part, convinced the Texas judge to only grant preliminary protections to MtGox KK, not its alter-egos.  And in turn that means that it will likely have little chance to destroy documents, raising the likelihood that the truth regarding Mr. Karpelès will emerge.

So while he he gets to live the good life, though, at his luxury apartment in Japan...

La Tour
La Tour Aobadai -- luxury Tokyo high rise -- is Mr. Karpelès home for now.
[Image Source: RealEstate-Japan]

...eating delicacies....

Karpeles
Have a beer -- it's on the customers!
[Image Source: Mark Karpelès on Flickr; Fair Use clause TITLE 17 > CHAPTER 1 > § 107]

Karpeles eating
Where are the Bitcoins?  Maybe he ate them.
[Image Source: Mark Karpelès on Flickr; Fair Use clause TITLE 17 > CHAPTER 1 > § 107]

Those happy days may soon be at an end, as he will be forced to either reveal the truth, or face felony fraud charges for obstructed civil proceedings.

Sources: ArsTechnica, Reuters



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

RE: Ridiculous...
By CaedenV on 3/13/2014 4:26:54 PM , Rating: 2
You do realize that bitcoin does not equate to MtGOX right? MtGOX is burning in flames (and rightly so), but bitcoin still has a long life ahead of itself as a currency.

MtGOX is just like a bank, they hold your money and offer ways of performing transactions... but if the bank mismanages funds then the bank goes down along with all accounts attached to it. But it is just one bank that is the problem, not the currency that the bank happens to be using.


RE: Ridiculous...
By extide on 3/13/2014 5:35:56 PM , Rating: 2
This is true and this could happen to any bank, and any currency. It really has nothing to do with bitcoins.

Seems like EricMartello has a personal vendetta against bitcoins. Maybe he lost a bunch of money like a newb or doesn't understand how it all works and this is his way of making himself feel better. Sad.


RE: Ridiculous...
By Schrag4 on 3/14/2014 12:26:24 AM , Rating: 2
quote:
This is true and this could happen to any bank, and any currency. It really has nothing to do with bitcoins.


Respectfully disagree

http://www.fdic.gov/deposit/


RE: Ridiculous...
By EricMartello on 3/14/2014 3:54:22 PM , Rating: 2
quote:
This is true and this could happen to any bank, and any currency. It really has nothing to do with bitcoins.


Sh1tcoins are the currency of DERP, and there is an unlimited supply of derp so following the basic economic principle of supply and demand, an unlimited supply can meet any demand which renders the value to zero.

As I've said before, a real currency like the US dollar is issued by an authoritative entity (the US government), has a legal basis for its face value, has a national economy that backs up said value, is guaranteed by the US government.

What do sh1tcoins offer? They are a fake currency issued by anyone who runs the sh1tcoin mining program, they are backed by whiney internet-addicted beta males who like anime, have no legal basis for anything, have no face value, have no economy back them and are guaranteed by nobody.

Keep on beliebing, bro.

quote:
Seems like EricMartello has a personal vendetta against bitcoins. Maybe he lost a bunch of money like a newb or doesn't understand how it all works and this is his way of making himself feel better. Sad.


I have a personal vendetta against bullsh1t...and please, find me a post I made about sh1tcoins recently or any time in the past that was wrong on any point - you won't find one.

I did make money due to sh1tcoins by buying up a bunch of radeon GPUs when they were going used for $150, only to resell just about all of them for $250 or more depending on the model. I sold several GPUs I bought brand new for more than the price I paid for them new.


RE: Ridiculous...
By w8gaming on 3/14/2014 9:40:45 AM , Rating: 2
Bitcoin is more like a commodity instead of currency. Its demand is purely depends on the willingness of someone to hold on to it, in hope of it can be used to exchange for something else later. Its intrinsic value is built on belief. Compare to fiat money, the government is willing to accept it as tax payment. And being a legal tender means borrowers can return loan using such currency and the lender is forced to accept it. All these makes fiat money has some form of intrinsic value. As for Bitcoin, all you can hope for is that someone else believe it worth something and therefore is willing to buy your bitcoins. And if enough people suddenly believe bitcoin worth nothing, the value will drop and eventually it will goes to nothing.


RE: Ridiculous...
By JediJeb on 3/14/2014 5:05:59 PM , Rating: 2
quote:
And if enough people suddenly believe bitcoin worth nothing, the value will drop and eventually it will goes to nothing.


The sad thing is it can also happen to any currency. If say China made the world mad, and the rest of the world refuses to exchange their currency for any other, then that currency becomes worthless outside their own borders, and eventually even within their borders. The Peso in the past was a prime example of how things like this can happen, along with many other currencies. Other than collectors value, what is a Confederate States of America Dollar worth these days?


RE: Ridiculous...
By EricMartello on 3/14/2014 3:41:07 PM , Rating: 2
quote:
You do realize that bitcoin does not equate to MtGOX right? MtGOX is burning in flames (and rightly so), but bitcoin still has a long life ahead of itself as a currency.


Wrong - sh1tcoins only gained popularity because people thought they could "sell" them for dollars. Sh1tcoins did not gain on their own merits (of which they have none) and are not a currency any more than monopoly money is. They have no technical basis for valuation because they represent no entity and no economy. There is no authoritative issuer of sh1tcoins. If "anyone" can "mine" them they are completely devoid of value. How much would gold be worth if anyone could spend $100 to buy a machine that poops out gold?

quote:
MtGOX is just like a bank, they hold your money and offer ways of performing transactions... but if the bank mismanages funds then the bank goes down along with all accounts attached to it. But it is just one bank that is the problem, not the currency that the bank happens to be using.


They're just like a bank in that they're trying to scam you out of your money - the difference is that banks have a legal mandate to do so while the goxster did not grease the right wheels before attempting to separate idiots from their money (a relatively easy process).

Without exchanges sh1tcoins have no value because nobody is going to accept sh1tcoins on their own. Sh1tcoins may have been legit if the exchanges never came into being - but really, the temptation to scam those fools is hard to resist.


“We do believe we have a moral responsibility to keep porn off the iPhone.” -- Steve Jobs














botimage
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki