Is Microsoft Trojan Horsing Itself? CEO Candiate Elop Reportedly Wants to Break up Company
November 8, 2013 12:30 PM
comment(s) - last by
Sources close to Microsoft unveil Mr. Elop's controversial vision to sell of Xbox, Bing units
Incoming Microsoft Corp. (
executive vice president of devices Stephen Elop
is considered a front-runner for the CEO job,
with the departure of Steve Ballmer
took over from company cofounder and long-time CEO Bill Gates in 2000
. His candidacy is
sparking a fierce debate
over his executive track record and what direction Microsoft should move in as it looks to adjust to the new reality of an
increasing mobile-centric devices and software market
I. A Strange Track Record
Depending on who you ask Mr. Elop is either a quiet genius at saving companies -- or a bizarre master of destroying them.
The Canadian executive grew up in Ontario and went to school at
in Hamilton, Canada, studying computer engineering and management. Six years after his 1986 graduation, he scored his first major position as director of consulting at Lotus Software. At Lotus he played an admittedly smaller role in big direction decisions. But following an acquisition by International Business Machines Corp. (
) in 1995, he would soon move on to more influential roles.
Stephen Elop [Image Source: IBTimes]
Joining Boston Chicken (and Einstein Brothers Bagels), a rapidly growing fast-food franchise, he was appointed CIO. He rode along until 1998 when the company's large debts led it to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protections. Boston Chicken was subsequently acquired by McDonald's Corp. (
) and rebranded Boston Market.
Again, Mr. Elop jumped ship to another role, becoming an IT manager at Macromedia, a software firm who wrote the widely used Flash plugin and the Dreamweaver webpage development environment. Mr. Elop ascend to CEO in 2005, and three months later the company was sold to a top web/graphics software firm Adobe Systems Inc. (
) -- apparently Mr. Elop had learned a trick or two from the sales of Lotus and Boston Market.
Mr. Elop was CEO at Macromedia in 2005 and suprvised its sale to Adobe. [Image Source: Fotki]
But it is here that opinions diverge. Some
believed that Adobe had overpaid
and that Stephen Elop had played a clever game by first stoking rumors of a possible Microsoft buyout, which in turn
triggered a panicked bid from Adobe
. Indeed, Adobe paid $3.4B USD for Macromedia -- a 25 percent premium on share prices before the deal was announced. While Macromedia
[PDF], at the time investors were still quite wary with the fresh memory of the burst of the dot com bubble still in their rear view and this kind of premium for a software firm due to speculation about secret counterbids from another rival seemed downright "paranoid" to quote one analyst.
Others weren't as impressed with Mr. Elop's decision. Adobe had a poorer reputation for customer service at the time and many were angered at the prospect of it
gaining a virtual "monopoly"
over key internet software.
Even as this debate raged on, Mr. Elop didn't take long to leave from his new position as president of worldwide operations at Adobe. In 2007 he jumped ship to Juniper Networks, Inc. (
) a Californian networking equipment manager. He spent a quiet year there as COO.
Stephen Elop, at an Office 2010 launch event [Image Source: Microsoft]
Then he jumped to Microsoft, where he served as head of the business division, producing a number of successful, if controversial products,
such as Office 2010
, which continued to back
the "ribbon" menu format
, introduced in 2007 before his arrival.
II. Nokia Run -- A Trojan Horse or a Turnaround Wizard?
In 2011 he would make another surprise jump up the corporate ladder,
of struggling Finnish phonemaker and telecommunications equipment firm Nokia Oyj. (
). Many were wary of his ties to Microsoft and track record of being tied to firms who were acquired.
At the 2011 Mobile World Congress (MWC), the mobile industry's top trade show, Stephen Elop was asked outright by one member of the audience during a Q&A session
whether he was a "Trojan horse"
. Indeed if Mr. Elop's history didn't raise enough eyebrows, his subsequent decision to
switch Nokia over to solely using Microsoft's Windows Phone platform
Some accuse Stephen Elop (right) of being a Trojan horse during his two year reign at Nokia. [Image Source: Reuters]
In the end he
restored Nokia to profitability
-- but also ended up orchestrating a sale of Nokia's devices unit
to Microsoft for $7.2B USD
. Given that Nokia had
a market cap of $32.84B USD
in 2011, clearly Mr. Elop's cuts had taken a heavy toll on the phonemaker.
Again, here's where controversy take hold. Some say that Mr. Elop indeed has proved that he was a Trojan horse on a clear mission to devalue Nokia, briefly restore it to profitability, and then pass it off to Microsoft as a vehicle for Windows Phone. They cite a
$25M USD payout Mr. Elop received
as part of the purchase deal as "proof" of this alleged conspiracy.
Others contend that Nokia's aging
Symbian "burning platform"
left it in an uncompetitive position and that Mr. Elop performed admirably given the circumstances, and that Mr. Elop's past relationship with Microsoft was not a factor in his strategy. They point out that the sale allowed Nokia to
focus on the stable telecommunications market
rather than dividing its focus.
Ford Motor Comp. (
) CEO Alan Mulally (left), former Nokia CEO Stephen Elop (center), and former Skype CEO Tony Bates are considred front runners for the CEO job. [Image Source: AP/Reuters]
Now even as he settles in to his position at Microsoft, some
consider him a front-runner to be CEO at Microsoft
. One theory is that he might receive the position as a reward for his successful role as Trojan horse at Nokia.
III. Stephen Elop's Wild (Alleged) Plan for Microsoft
a new report in
is raising fresh questions -- not only about Mr. Elop's historical connections to major corporate acquisitions, but also regarding his fitness to lead Microsoft.
reports that Mr. Elop's proposed plan to Microsoft's CEO search group is to untie Microsoft's various software products -- most notably Office -- from Windows. While Office is current available for Apple, Inc. (
) Mac computers, Mr. Elop wants to offer full fledged versions of Office for the Apple iPad, tablets running Google Inc.'s (
) Android, and notebook computers running Google's Chrome OS. He'd pursue a similar approach for other products such as the Visual Studio development environment.
Windows sales have fallen, but should Microsoft kill the OS and focus on software? That seems to be Mr. Elop's alleged vision. [Image Source: Reuters]
Furthermore, Mr. Elop reportedly wants to directly sell off some non-software, non-mobile devices business.
Besides emphasizing Office, Elop would be prepared to sell or shut down major businesses to sharpen the company’s focus, the people said. He would consider ending Microsoft’s costly effort to take on Google with its Bing search engine, and would also consider selling healthy businesses such as the Xbox game console if he determined they weren’t critical to the company’s strategy, the people said.
At Nokia, Elop cut 40,000 jobs and reduced operating expenses by 50 percent. While Microsoft doesn’t face the same cost constraints, Elop would probably impose job cuts and belt-tightening to create smaller teams, said the people.
nodded in approval
of the thought of selling the
money losing Bing
. But the idea of selling the Xbox business is much more controversial as it is
a unit Microsoft has said is profitable
at worst is accused of being a "break even" business
Maybe unloading Bing
be a good idea. [Image Source: Business Insider]
Between breaking an exclusivity -- an approach which to many, would be akin to
Microsoft abandoning Windows
, its core product -- and the plans to chop off other business units for the auction, the most prevalent reaction at the overall plan appears to be shock. Some are asking --
is Microsoft "Trojan horsing" itself
Of course, this report has not been confirmed, and even
makes it clear that its sources said Mr. Elop had not finalized his proposed plan to the search committee.
Is Microsoft "Trojan horsing" itself? [Image Source: Venitism]
Microsoft's Frank Shaw mocked the report, stating, "We appreciate Bloomberg’s foray into fiction and look forward to future episodes."
However, top Windows blogger Paul Thurrott
calls the report
"credible" and actually agrees with Mr. Elop's (alleged) controversial plan. Likewise Paul Ghaffari, manager of Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen's $15B USD portfolio (which includes $2B USD worth of Microsoft stock -- about a 0.6 percent stake) has backed a similar proposal for spinning off Xbox and Bing, a move he says would pump Microsoft's profits by 40 percent, by reducing operating expenses.
The search business and even Xbox, which has been a very successful product, are detracting from that. We would want them to focus on their best competencies. My view is there are some parts of that operation they should probably spin out, get rid of, to focus on the enterprise and focus on the cloud.
Sounds like true or not, some have the same idea Mr. Elop supposedly does for radically transforming Microsoft.
It's worth watching this one carefully, as Stephen Elop does have an uncanny knack for both scoring unlikely positions of power and for chopping up and packaging companies for sale. Could Microsoft appoint Mr. Elop CEO? And if it does, would he make the wild decision of leaving the struggling Windows platform to a slow death and unloading major portions of Microsoft's diverse hardware, software, and internet service empire? We shall wait and see.
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
RE: he's crazy!!
11/9/2013 5:05:55 PM
But you're just one person.
And so are you unless you cite a source that shows otherwise ;)
I for one have a windows phone and find that bing and google provide nearly similar enough results that I find the direct integration of bing as the search provider to be far more convenient than trying to find a google app or go to their website.
RE: he's crazy!!
11/9/2013 9:30:40 PM
I'm a WP user and I'd readily confirm that Bing does a adequate job. It's doubtful many WP users goes through the trouble of using a different search engine. Then again, that's damning by faint praise. When you're a challenger you have to do better than the incumbent. Can you come up with any area where Bing does better than Google? The only thing I can think of is that there's less advertisement. But that's just a function of it being a failure from a business perspective.
And I have to say, Bing Map is a net negative on Nokia phones. It sucks and it always pops up when what I want is the Nokia app.
RE: he's crazy!!
11/10/2013 9:19:53 AM
I know Cortana is "on the way", whenever, but Windows Phone is severely lacking in online services integration. Bing isn't an essential part of the WP experience until they can integrate it in the way that
integrates itself into Android.
I'm taking my gf to see the Thor movie today (yeah yeah laugh it up), here is what
will do for me: includes the latest movie ratings from Rotten Tomatoes, helping me pick the right movie. It lets me purchase tickets through Fandango. It reminds me when I need to leave for the theater. And it displays my e-tickets for the movie once I arrive at the theater.
ALL through the
The lack of that kind of deep online service integration makes Bing and Windows Phone look stale by comparison. Cortana needs to come and come soon, and she better bring her A game.
RE: he's crazy!!
11/10/2013 5:04:12 PM
This is the first post you've ever made on any subject that has been worth reading. Well done!
"DailyTech is the best kept secret on the Internet." -- Larry Barber
Microsoft Shortens List of Potential CEOs
November 5, 2013, 11:25 PM
Microsoft Wants to Sell 16 Million Windows Tablets this Holiday Season
November 1, 2013, 9:32 AM
Nokia Sells 8.8 Million Windows Phones in Q3, Transitions to Telecom Sales
October 29, 2013, 8:11 PM
Acquired Hands: Nokia's Elop, Skype's Bates Top Contenders for Microsoft CEO
October 10, 2013, 5:39 PM
Microsoft Lavishes Nokia's "Trojan Horse" CEO With $25.5M
September 19, 2013, 7:20 PM
Free Windows 10 offer ends July 29th, 2016: 10 Reasons to Upgrade Immediately
July 22, 2016, 9:19 PM
Quick Note: Whoops, Microsoft Pushed Unwanted Windows 10 to Some Users
October 15, 2015, 9:04 PM
Quick Note: Windows 10 Insider Preview Build 10565 Fixes Boot Camp 6.0 Issues
October 13, 2015, 11:39 AM
Microsoft's HD-500 ("Display Dock"), the Magic Sauce Behind Continuum
October 6, 2015, 5:30 PM
Quick Note: Windows 10 Hits 110 Million Devices, VMs
October 6, 2015, 4:30 PM
Windows 10 on Raspberry Pi, IoT Devices Sees Developer Debut
August 12, 2015, 2:41 PM
Most Popular Articles
iPhones May Get Curved Screens Next Year
August 24, 2016, 6:45 AM
Drones at the Airport
August 26, 2016, 5:00 AM
First Apple Computer Auctions for $815,000
August 27, 2016, 7:51 AM
5 Easy Ways to Lower Blood Pressure By Monique C. Bethell, Ph.D.
August 25, 2016, 8:00 AM
2 NEW PlayStation 4 Models - Unveiling September 7th
August 23, 2016, 6:23 AM
Latest Blog Posts
First Self-Driving Car debut on the streets of Singapore
Aug 28, 2016, 4:10 PM
Coming Soon - Drones and Airports
Aug 24, 2016, 12:40 PM
SolarCity’s Gigafactory: A Milesone in Emerging Technology by Lily Emamian - 15 August 2016
Aug 15, 2016, 6:30 AM
Sceptre Airs 27", 120 Hz. 1080p Monitor/HDTV w/ 5 ms Response Time for $220
Dec 3, 2014, 10:32 PM
Costco Gives Employees Thanksgiving Off; Wal-Mart Leads "Black Thursday" Charge
Oct 29, 2014, 9:57 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information