NSA and Congress -- You Will Never Kill the Constitution, It's an Idea
November 10, 2013 2:00 PM
comment(s) - last by
The people vote you into office; they can vote you out
Today we stand at a turning point in the road.
in the U.S. Senate offering radically different visions on how our nation should spend taxpayer money and whether to uphold the Constitution or taking it a step closer to death in the digital age.
I. Freedom and Tyranny Face Off in the Senate
On the one side is the "
USA Freedom Act of 2013
", cosponsored by
Sens. Michael S. Lee
(D-Verm.); a bill which would reign in the
U.S. National Security Agency
(NSA) Orwellian spying campaign.
It would not only stop the warrantless harvest of so called "telephone metadata" -- which includes location tracking records -- but it save U.S. taxpayers potentially tens of billions of dollars, money which could be put back into the economy and be spent on traditional methods that actually improve security.
Backed by unlikely allies like Sen. Rand Paul, Sen. Leahy (left) is fighting to push a bill that does the opposite of Sen. Feinstein's (right) bill. [Image Source: AP]
On the other side is a very different bill. Sponsored by
Senator Dianne Feinstein
(D-Calif.), this bill -- the "
FISA Improvements Act
" -- would extend the Bush administration's
Act by cementing
50 USC § 1861
a provision that allows agents of the
U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigations
(FBI) to without warrant demand "any tangible things (including books, records, papers, documents, and other items)" from a U.S. citizen in order "protect against international terrorism or clandestine intelligence activities."
The latter allowance -- for the government to seize your records without warrant from businesses to conduct "clandestine intelligence" is such an ambiguous and abusable allowance that it has no place being in the U.S. Code.
After all "clandestine intelligence" could mean just about anything to anyone -- to President Bush's administration it
apparently meant spying on Quakers
(among other peace groups), while apparently to President Barrack Obama's administration it
meant spying on the Occupy Wall Street activists
who posed a risk to the banks to pave his way into office like JP Morgan Chase & Comp. (
For some time now there's been abundant hard evidence that so far
every single President
whose administration has had these powers has abused them -- every single one.
[Image Source: Hey NSA! Tumblr]
But all we had before were bits and pieces. Now we have
a much clearer vision of our government's effort
, which appears a cohesive effort not to fight terror, but to create a terrifying police state in which we are tracked on a daily basis. What's more the leaks from Edward Snowden reveal to us the primary reason for this spying -- that the government was funding billions to private contractors like Booz Allen Hamilton Holding Corp.. (
), Dell, and Oracle Corp. (
) to spy on Americans. These contractors also have
funneled tens of millions to the President and members of Congress
At this point we need to review and recognize the facts.
II. The Spy State is a Threat to You, Even if You Are Not a Threat to it
Much of your internet traffic
your geographic locations over time
and your calls
are being stored both at government and at contractor facilities. This is true
even if you have broken no laws
. Tens of thousands of government employees have access to this information and in most cases can file information requests in such a way that you are not legally allowed to obtain them (as you would with warranted surveillance).
Chances are you have a political opinion. Would you like your opinion suppressed?
If past spying on non-terrorist American citizens under the PATRIOT Act is any sign, Congress is
too weak to stop such abuse
s, or, worse yet, is encouraging them. Such information in the future could be abused to harass or detain citizens -- if it hasn't been already. There's a reason why the Founding Fathers protected citizens right against "search and seizures" without a warrant.
The police state can try, but it can't kill the Constitution because it's more than a document, it's an idea. [Image Source: Alan Moore/David Lloyd]
A warrant doesn't preclude abuse. But if judges issue abusive warrant, it will likely become publicly known. By contrast warrantless domestic spying leaves vary little paper trail and hence is the ideal tool to crack down on political enemies. Why do you think nations like China, Russia, and Iran love it so much? After years of condemning them, the U.S. is becoming the latest government to install tools that can be used to silence voices for political change.
III. The Spy State is Spending You and Your Children Into Debt
Spying on the masses of law abiding citizens is not only condoned behind closed doors by companies like BAH and Oracle,
it's explicitly lobbied for
. As a result your money is being funneled to massive for-profit corporations, while providing little antiterrorism benefit.
The NSA at best claimed that call records were used in one or two anti-terrorism cases. And it is unclear whether either case involved an actual U.S. citizen or evidence that traditional, Constitutional law enforcement tools would have been insufficient to stop the plot.
Bribery pays big dividends in U.S. politics. Given that federal politicians have little legal responsibility to recuse themselves from decisions involving campaign donors and given that the payoff is $220 USD per $1 USD spent lobbying it's a dream investment.
[Image Source: Haberrus]
In other words, the NSA spying is quite possibly
the most expensive, least effective law enforcement effort
in the nation's history.
This is yet another piece of evidence showcasing the merits of a 2011 peer-reviewed economics
University of Kansas
School of Business
which estimates that per $1 USD spent on lobbying a company gets back $220 USD, on average in contracts, tax breaks, grants, etc. Is it surprising that some individuals would sacrifice the public's privacy in exchange for a 220-fold return on investment?
Today federal spying is low cost and focuses more heavily on U.S. citizens. This all equates to more pork for paid of polticians to push. [Image Source: The People's Cube]
Even Joseph McCarthy didn't have tens of billions to splurge on spying on millions of Americans. After showering special interests with blatant payoffs, the best weak excuse that the NSA can give is "we think it
have stopped a person or two who
have committed a terrorist attack, but we can't reveal many details to back up our claims!"
Trying to find those terrorists... [Image Source: Mashable]
An who knows how long those one or two hypothetical terrorists will last. After all, the NSA originally claimed over the summer that the domestic spying had been used to foil 54 terrorist plots, only to back off that claim when more evidence emerged strongly indicating that was a ridiculous falsehood.
This laughable back-tracking brings to mind
's "Would you believe....?"
Imagine if the federal government spent a billion to monitor every mugger and murderer. Talk about BIG government!
IV. The Spy State Opens the Doors to Insider Trading, Corporate Espionage
laughable sliding scale of the tax code
to "green subsidies"
, to inconsistent enforcement, it's no secret the federal government
loves to manipulate the government
, manipulation that almost happens to
benefit the special interests who pay politicians way into office
With this bold era of spying on both U.S. and international networks, it's important to remember that small business, mid-size businesses, and ... yes... even corporations all have their data swept up in the same net. In other words, the NSA spying program represents the world's best ever corporate espionage opportunity.
After receiving a record amount of special interest money, will the Obama administration return the favor by offering the spy state's domestic espionage capabilities? [Image Source: AP]
Just imagine your JP Morgan Chase, and you're invested in companies A, B, and C, which compete in various markets against companies D, E, and G respectively. Wouldn't it be great to know what D, E, and G were planning, who they were talking to, and what they were designing?
Well, with the NSA spying high ranking shareholders could go to their Obama administration contacts and request this information be covertly delivered. These contacts would have little choice but comply (otherwise they might wind up being
branded a "traitor"
like Mr. Snowden and face prosecution or death).
Alternatively, a domestic investment firm like JP Morgan or BlackRock, Inc. (
) -- or even a foreign investment firm like The China Vanguard Group, Ltd. (
) -- could use their relationship with contractors like BAH or Oracle to gain access to illicit insider information to pass along to their investments. I chose Vanguard and BlackRock as they both are among the largest shareholders in Oracle according to
the largest), who is widely thought to
have provided ongoing support for PRISM and other NSA spying programs
Imagine if large investment banks had access to insider secrets and were shielded prosecution by the politicians they donated to. [Image Source: David Sachs/SEIU]
Let's assume this abuse has not happened yet, but let's be very cautious and try to think what would happen
if it did
. Would anyone find out?
Let's see, at most a dozen or so people -- many of whom are financially motivated to cover up this illegal behavior are involved in the theft of corporate secrets (courtesy of the NSA). NSA data requests are justified by vague forms, which are not made public. Thus it is unlikely Congress would know, let alone citizens. But what about the FBI and NSA?? Oh right, like they're going to catch illegal behavior
at the companies they pay to do their "police work"
(or lack thereof). Where are they going to gather evidence? From nicely asking Oracle?
In conclusion even if you're a big "evil" corporation, unless you happen to be
financially tied to someone who in turn is collecting data for the NSA
you should be scared out of your mind that your data might be stolen and passed to rival for corporate gains. I'm very surprised that more people aren't discussing this disturbing possibility.
Large special interests could use spying systems as corporate espionage tools to consolidate wealth. [Image Source: Mother Jones]
invariably happens on some scale
via tactics like data scraping, hired hacking, and
trade secrets theft by current/former employees
. But the last thing America needs is for the government installing a superspying system that is by nature, the world's best ready-built corporate espionage tool.
V. Fool Me Once, Fool Me Twice... Will We Learn?
If you believe Congressional incumbents like Sen. Feinstein have been behaving in a criminal, unconstitutional, treasonous manner, working to funnel your money to special interests, install tools to allow the theft of corporate secrets, and potentially
suppress true voices of change
, recognize that their efforts didn't start yesterday. Sen. Feinstein and others have been supporting the PATRIOT Act and spying by the NSA and other agencies for over a decade now. In many cases their family members have profited handsomely off their positions of power, which they obtained by acting as shills without a conscious to special interests.
It's true special interests gave these politicians the money to buy advertising and (possibly) to suppress media visibility of potential political rivals. But at the end of the day everyone with internet access could have examined their voting record and could have sent a clear message by voting them out of Congress.
Either you're to blame, or your fellow citizens are to blame.
The two headed monster continues to feed as long as the voters keep installing it in office.
[Image Source: Anthony Freda]
Either way the solution is clear. Explain to your politically apathetic friends why the government is taking is wrong. Write letters to politicians. Sign petitions. And most importantly vote -- and do everything in power to make sure your friends vote.
Senator Feinstein and
Senator Mitch McConnell
(R-Kentucky) voted for the original PATRIOT Act in 2001. To be fair, 99 out of 100 Senators made the same decision.
But they had the chance to reconsider in 2006 -- and they blew it. That time around the support wasn't nearly as unanimous with Sen. Udall, Wyden, and 8 others uniting in an opposition "Nea".
They fooled use once. They
fooled us twice
. Surprise, surprise here they are voting for it again.
How many times do the
enemies of the U.S. Constitution and our civil liberties
have to fool us before catch on? How many times can we afford to overlook the decisions of our elected officials, when they support
the same anti-freedom efforts
again and again??
Most citizens seem opposed to the government spying on us, and if they're not they're generally only unopposed under the false premise certain members of Congress have somehow convinced Americans of -- that by robbing Americans of our civil liberties and
treating law abiding citizens as criminals
we're somehow "safer".
Yet here time and time again, our glorious masses
vote the trolls of the political world back into Congress
Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Kent.) claims to be conservative but is awash in big government special interest kickbacks and support for Orwellian spying. [Image Source: AP]
That's not to say there aren't a few politicians who fight the status quo --
Sen. Ron Wyden
Sen. Mark Udall
Sen. Rand Paul
(D-Kentucky), and a handful of reps, e.g.
Rep. Dr. Ron Paul
former Rep. Dennis Kucinich
(D-Ohio) -- come to mind. You might not agree with all of these elected officials' opinions, but they make it relatively clear in their votes that they actually care about defending America and engaging legitimate political debate.
But by and large they are in the minority, despite the fact that their views appear to represent those of most Americans.
The Tea Party and libertarian-leaning republicans have been complaining about President Obama's spying ever since he took office almost. Yet many have voted for Senator McConnell, who pushed this spying program. Liberal democrats complained non-stop about President Bush and the PATRIOT Act -- yet most in California have made the dumbfounding decision to vote Sen. Feinstein into office not once, but twice -- first in 2006, then in 2012 by landside margins that had some labeling her as "
America's most popular politician
For those who hate the PATRIOT Act, but voted for Sen. Feinstein in 2006 and 2012, let me illustrate to you how ridiculously easy it would have been to figure out you're making a mistake last year.
1. Go to Google.
2. Click on the
! (appropriately from the URL "Educate-Yourself.org")
4. Make yourself a delicious sandwich, and crack open a cold beer -- you deserve it, that was a lot of work.
[Image Source: Moerlein Lager House]
Are the masses that stupid? Are we too lazy to care as we're herded like sheep towards the demise of our freedoms?
Or are many of us suffering from some sort of collective Stockholm syndrome where we fall in love with our abusive captors, cowering, yet crawling back to their feet after each beating?
VI. You Can Fool Some of the People Some of the Time, But You Can't Fool All the People All the Time
Either way, the answer is to not be part of the problem. Educate yourself, educate others, and vote for true change. So what can you do?
First let's work to protect the whistleblower who allowed us to defend the Constitution.
Mr. Snowden certainly
broke company protocols, agency protocols, did damage to employers
, did damage to the government's reputation, gain unauthorized access to digital systems, and
violated federal computer statutes
in the U.S. Code of Law, he was forced to do so uphold his most important duty --
defending the Constitution
CIA analyst and published author Barry Eisler points out,
throughout most of our nation's history (and even the CIA and NSA's history, which are respectively brief and briefer by comparison), citizens serving the U.S. military and U.S. intelligence agency's key oath was to protect the Constitution -- not to swear to keep secret immoral actions that undermine the Constitution.
If Mr. Snowden is a criminal in today's bloated, special interests-controlled federal government, he's a hero by the standards of our fathers and grandfathers. You can recognize this by asking for President Obama for a pardon on We The People -- the official government petition site:
Pardon Edward Snowden
A banner in Hong Kong thanks leaker Edward Snowden. [Image Source: AP]
If you're feeling particularly punitive you can sign a petition to charge one of the politicians who supported his condemned him and charged him with criminal offenses:
Try Senator Dianne Feinstein in a Federal Court For Treason To The Constitution
Hold DNI Clapper accountable for lying to the Senate about the NSA on March 12, 2013
" (on MoveOn.org)
To Impeach The Speaker of the House of Representatives
" (on MoveOn.org)
Or be positive and sign something like:
Pres. Obama: Tap Sen. Ron Wyden to Head NSA
Second -- and most importantly -- study the records of your local officials and the people running against them carefully and be sure to vote.
[Image Source: BrentHodson]
Attend peaceful protests against the NSA and the politicians who support it. As Gandhi said, "Non-cooperation with evil is as much a duty as is cooperation with good."
NSA protesters condemn mass spying on Americans. [Image Source:
And educate your children on the nature of what is occurring in our federal government, in hopes that if our generation can not achieve change, that theirs will.
VII. If It Were Easy, We Wouldn't Be In This Mess
Remember it's your vote, your support that puts politicians in office, if the public mobilizes and refuses to be silence by special interest money.
Rep. John Boehner
(R-Ohio), Sen. Feinstein, Sen. McConnell are spending your own money to spy on you. Let your actions tell them loud and clear -- STOP.
The cost of inaction is not only harm to our great nation, harm to U.S. freedom. If the people stand idle, this campaign of universal surveillance
will continue to harm our allies
. Don't let special interest-funded politicians turn the U.S. into a destructive, anti-freedom force.
Don't allow the U.S. government to
seize domestic and international business data
. Don't give special interest-funded politicians the capacity to funnel confidential corporate communications of foreign businesses to American banks so that they can insider trade on this knowledge. Don't allow your government to
manipulate the market
[Image Source: Young Pollitically Active Professionals]
I quote Haile Selassie I:
The preservation of peace and the guaranteeing of man's basic freedoms and rights require courage and eternal vigilance: courage to speak and act - and if necessary, to suffer and die - for truth and justice; eternal vigilance, that the least transgression of international morality shall not go undetected and unremedied
We must stay ever vigilant and carefully consider the ideas of the Constitution and whether the people we're voting for are respecting them in the digital era.
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
RE: Wrong country
11/12/2013 2:54:26 PM
This is an excellent question Jason. Why do people keep voting these people in and justifying their position?
I believe Eckhart Tolle answers it best - in short it's a form of collective unconsciousness. Any of his books offer great insight on why people act the way they do.
"This is about the Internet. Everything on the Internet is encrypted. This is not a BlackBerry-only issue. If they can't deal with the Internet, they should shut it off." -- RIM co-CEO Michael Lazaridis
Sen. Feinstein's "Improvement" to NSA Spying on Americans: Make it Legal
November 4, 2013, 4:20 PM
Google's Eric Schmidt Says NSA Spying on Data Centers is "Not OK"
November 4, 2013, 11:38 AM
Top Tech Firms Battle Over Whether NSA Should Spy on Americans
November 1, 2013, 5:33 PM
Biodiesel Lobby Distances Itself From Ethanol Lobbyists Amid Biofuel Backlash
October 30, 2013, 4:44 PM
Tech Kings: Facebook, Google, Verizon, AT&T, et al. Set Lobbying Record
October 24, 2013, 8:42 AM
Latest By Jason Mick
Retiree Sues Apple For $7,500 for Wiping Honeymoon Photos From His iPhone
November 30, 2015, 10:23 AM
Creationists are Mad About Google Doodle Depicting Evolution
November 24, 2015, 8:48 PM
iPhone 7 May Pack 3-4 GB Memory, More Storage; 4-Inch Comeback is Rumored
November 20, 2015, 10:12 PM
DHS and TSA: Whoops, We Missed That 73 Airport Employees May be Terrorists
November 19, 2015, 2:16 PM
Glenn Beck's Attempt at Anti-Refugee Meme Proves He's Really, Really Dumb
November 18, 2015, 4:17 PM
OnePlus One, OnePlus 2 Will Receive Android Marshmallow in Q1 2016
November 16, 2015, 9:58 AM
Jumbo Joust: iPad Pro vs. Surface Pro 3 vs. Surface Pro 4
November 11, 2015, 1:00 AM
Twitter Senior VP: "Diversity is Important, But We Can’t Lower the Bar"
November 9, 2015, 9:59 AM
"Prepare to be Punished": Microsoft is Killing OneDrive With Cuts, Blames Users
November 3, 2015, 8:23 PM
BlackBerry Priv is an Amazing Android So Secure You May Never Hear of It
November 2, 2015, 2:46 PM
Twitter Senior VP: "Diversity is Important, But We Can’t Lower the Bar"
November 9, 2015, 9:59 AM
CNN Resorts to Internet Censorship to Promote Clinton Over Senator Sanders
October 15, 2015, 2:47 PM
Breaking Bad: How to Crash Google's Chrome Browser With Just 8 Characters
September 23, 2015, 11:08 AM
Quick Note: Amazon UK Offers £10 Back on Any Order £50 or Over
August 3, 2015, 12:05 PM
Editorial: Reddit Allows Itself to be Hijacked as a Hate Platform For Racist Bigots
July 21, 2015, 6:32 PM
Mozilla and Facebook to Adobe: It's Time to Kill Flash
July 20, 2015, 6:30 PM
Latest Blog Posts
Sceptre Airs 27", 120 Hz. 1080p Monitor/HDTV w/ 5 ms Response Time for $220
Dec 3, 2014, 10:32 PM
Costco Gives Employees Thanksgiving Off; Wal-Mart Leads "Black Thursday" Charge
Oct 29, 2014, 9:57 PM
"Bear Selfies" Fad Could Turn Deadly, Warn Nevada Wildlife Officials
Oct 28, 2014, 12:00 PM
The Surface Mini That Was Never Released Gets "Hands On" Treatment
Sep 26, 2014, 8:22 AM
ISIS Imposes Ban on Teaching Evolution in Iraq
Sep 17, 2014, 5:22 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information