Editorial: Tired Trope -- Blaming Violent Video Games for Navy Shooting is Rubbish
September 18, 2013 5:00 PM
comment(s) - last by
(Source: On Violence)
Would the real exploitative journalists please shut up?
The year was 1927 and in a sleepy town in Michigan
horror was unleashed
. After a bitter defeat a former school board treasurer -- once thought to be a blue blooded American -- plotted "murderous revenge" bombing a schoolhouse and killing 38 children. He then detonated a truck bomb, killing himself and at least six other adults. At least 58 other people were injured in what was the deadliest attack on a U.S. school in history.
Since thorough records have been kept, mankind has a long and trafic history of breeding an occasional psychopath. These individual walk amongst us and often show little to no signs until something triggers them to embark on a murderous rampage. The latest such incident is the tragic shooting that occured at the Washington Navy Yard this week,
claiming 13 lives
, including the shooter's and wounding at least fourteen others.
I. Members of the Media Dredge up Deceptive Diatribe About Video Game Violence
Nobody can know what the families who lost love ones in the shooter's disgusting, cowardly attack are going through now. That's why it saddens me to see members of the media yet again engaging in the same tired, wrong-headed rhetoric; implying either subtly or not-so-subtly that the shooter's love of video games somehow contributed to his murderous rampage.
Aaron Alexis playing video games. [Image Source: The Telegraph]
This angle was perhaps first picked up by Barbara Starr, Ed Payne, Catherine E. Shoichet, and Pamela Brown of Time Warner Inc. (
wrote a story on the shooting
that was picked up by News Corp.'s (
) Fox sites,
, and other online outlets. In that piece they write:
But Ritrovato said his friend never showed signs of aggressiveness or violence, though he played a lot of shooting video games online.
"It's incredible that this is all happening, because he was a very good-natured guy," Ritrovato said. "It seemed like he wanted to get more out of life."
If this first report was subtle about its indictment of online gaming, others quickly became less so, sinking to such lows that
even Jack Thompson would be proud
II. The FUD Pile Rises
Brandon Formby, Tristan Hallman, and Sarah Mervosh of
The Dallas Morning News
, an A.H. Belo Corp. (
) publication parrot this tidbit in slightly more sensational terms,
One of 34-year-old Aaron Alexis’ neighbors told Fort Worth police that he terrified her. Another said that he liked Alexis and that his only flaw was that he often immersed himself in violent video games for hours at a time.
If the shooter liked action movies, would these reporters have described that Mr. Alexis "only flaw" was
and Bruce Willis shoot up "bad guys"? I doubt it; as usual video games holding a special place in the heart of some members of the media as an enternal scapegoat for drugs, sex, and violence.
A timeline of the DC shooting [Image Source: The NY Post]
, however, managed to set an even lower bar, publishing a story by Fort Worth resident Nick Allen whro writes "
Aaron Alexis: Washington navy yard gunman 'obsessed with violent video games'
". The story states:
The Washington Navy Yard gunman Aaron Alexis played violent video games including Call of Duty for up to 16 hours at a time and friends believe it could have pushed him towards becoming a mass murderer.
Aaron Alexis played violent video games including Call of Duty and Resident Evil for up to 16 hours at a time.
[Alexis's] addiction to violent video games and guns was at odds with his devout commitment to Buddhism, which saw Alexis spending half the day every Sunday meditating at the Wat Busayadhammvanaram temple in Fort Worth, Texas over a period of several years. He also spent a month in Thailand in April, The Daily Telegraph can disclose
The darker side to Alexis's character saw him playing violent "zombie" video games in his room, sometimes from 12.30pm until 4.30am.
[Nutpisit] Suthamtewakul [(purportedly Alexis's "best friend")] said: "He could be in the game all day and all night. I think games might be what pushed him that way. He always had this fear people would steal his stuff so that's why he would carry his gun all the time. He would carry it when he was helping out in the restaurant which scared my customers."
Alright, that's enough, this is making my stomach turn.
Some have suggested that playing video games such as
Call of Duty
may have led Mr. Alexis to kill -- I say "rubbish". [Image Source: Activision]
At this point some of you may be sitting at home panicked, recalling your child loves to play
Call of Duty
. Take a deep breath -- your child is not a psychopath. This is another sad instance of heartless exploitation for profit by some members of the media in the wake of another senseless tragedy.
III. Video Games are Far From the Only Violence in the Media
Let's face it mankind, since the dawn of time has fought wars and killed each other. There have always been murderers that shocked their towns big and small. These things upset mankind, yet on some level
viewing them in a ficitionalized context
is a cathartic release.
Norse poets fanticized about murderous half-humans in the epic tale
Of the Victory-Scyldings, need little dismay him: / Oaths he exacteth, not any he spares / Of the folk of the Danemen, but fighteth with pleasure, / Killeth and feasteth, no contest expecteth.
Modern media is less subtle. In
Bruce Willis's character John McClane famously remarks, "Yippee ki-yay motherfucker" before blowing up a plane full of bad guys with a lighter.
raps in his song "Role Model":
Now follow me and do exactly what you see
Don't you want to grow up to be just like me?
I slap women and eat 'shrooms then O.D.
Now don't you want to grow up to be just like me?
Me and Marcus Allen went over to see Nicole
When we heard a knock at the door, must have been Ron Gold
Jumped behind the door, put the orgy on hold
Killed them both and smeared blood in a white Bronco
But when video games depict murder or violence -- even against villainous sorts and their henchman, suddendly people think this form of entertainment has some precious and special role in turning law abiding citizens into murderous madmen.
Guess what -- there is
no proof that it does
There has been no conclusive scientific consensus from the psychological research community that playing violent video games
make gamers more violent
-- or even more desensitized to violence. B.D. Barthelow in 2006 claimed evidence that video game violence was desentisizing individuals to real world violence
in a journal paper
. But H.J. Bowen,
found no link between violent video games and desentization in a 2011
IV. My Grandfather Was Obsessed With Shooting Games, and Was a Law-Abiding Veteran
I'll add a personal note to this appeal to reason. My grandfather served his country in World War II and the Korean War.
Like Mr. Alexis
he eventually retired from service and became a veteran, but worked in civilian service for his remaining working years.
He could chain smoke and down a fifth with the best of them, although he later quit the latter indulgence after being told by his doctors after his first and only heart attack that he need to either quit smoking or drinking or he would die.
But like Mr. Alexis my grandfather loved video games. Yes, surprisingly, my first exposure to violent video games came from my veteran grandfather.
He was one of the first people I knew with a computer and he loved DOS and early Windows video games. As a child my parents -- pacifists -- wouldn't let me play violent video games, but when I went to gramps's house I would watch wide eyed with wonder as he gunned down Nazis in
and demons in
My grandfather played
, but it never caused him to kill people. [Image Source: ID]
If you wrote a sensational piece on my grandfather in his later years it might be entitled something like "Chain smoking veteran was "obsessed" with violent video games". And it would be true.
But for all his love of killing in games, never once did my grandfather -- a proud gun owner -- kill another U.S. citizen in cold blood. Video games were simply an entertainment, and at worst they reminded him of his military adventures "back in the war." My grandfather had his flaws, surely, but he was a respectable family man, staying faithful to my late grandmother and raising three boys and two girls.
V. Puritanism in the Press: The Specter of Tipper Gore Reappears
Video games don't make a killer.
A much more plausible correlation in my mind is simply the fact that Mr. Alexis was a veteran with combat experience who had been trained to kill; and claimed to be
suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder
(PTSD) after 9/11. Whether or not his claims were valid, studies have linked PTSD in veterans to acts of violence. A 1997 study on Vietnam War vets asserts:
[R]esults suggest that combat veterans with PTSD exhibit greater interpersonal violence than combat veterans without PTSD, and that there are multiple factors in this population which determine violent behavior.
Unfortunately when veterans with PTSD do erupt in outbursts of violence, they have the optimal training to end their own lives -- and the lives others -- with lethal precision.
Puritanical efforts to ban violence in entertainment
such as Tipper Gore's famous effort to block Dead Kennedys musician Jello Biafra's Constitutional right to free speech:
...are powerless to stop violence, while they rob us of their freedoms. For that reason I think such arguments are despicable and diametrically opposed to the values of our nation.
Censorship sucks. [Image Source: Nation States]
As the Bath County, Michigan incident from 1927 illustrates, sometimes there is no clear answer. When that killing rampage occurred their were no video games. And the man who did it was an electrical engineer with no conflict-related PTSD or military training. The reality is that there are a certain scant handful of individuals in society who might be set off on a deadly rampage by any number of factors that might upset a normal individual, but not trigger such an appalling act.
VI. Stop the Exploitation of the Victims of Violence
Ultimately I'm glad that Mr. Alexis was shot dead, not merely because it prevented more tragic loss of life, but also because it didn't agonize survivors with false narratives.
in the Norway shootings of 2012
in which a white supremacist terrorist killed 69 people, mostly teens, the shooter survived and went on to spin a wild tale of how he "trained" for the shooting by playing "
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
wildly popular title
published by Activision Blizzard, Inc. (
). While this is clearly factual, regardless of what Mr. Anders Behring Breivik (the psychopathic Norwegian behind the killings) claimed video games did not convince him to kill people, nor did they give him the proper training to kill people.
Anders Breivik, a murderous psychopath and self-proclaimed anti-Islamic Christian terrorist. claimed that he had "trained" for his murders by gaming. [Image Source: CNN]
When so-called "lone wolf" shooters die one can always hope we are spared
these false narratives
-- their radical views on religion (or lack thereof), their views on entertainment (Manson thought the Beatles told him to kill), or foul comments -- all of which do nothing but further confuse, mislead, and sadden those affected by the tragedy.
The Bath County bomber did not play games, but he was every bit as violent as Mr. Alexis.
[Image Source: Wikimedia Commons]
I was hopeful that the victims' families in the DC shooting would be spared such false narratives, but unfortunately some less scrupulous members of the media had other plans. I hope that the people propogating these narratives -- particularly Nick Allen -- come to realize and regret how exploitative and unfounded the tired controversies they're trying to reignite are.
Video games don't kill people, people kill people. At the end of the day I believe in the Constitution as one of the greatest documents ever created by man. And for that reason I say to journalists seizing on the "violent videogames" connection: I respect their right to free speech, just as I
respect their right to bear arms
. But they would be wise realize that if they abuse either right -- as Mr. Alexis did -- they alone will be responsible for the pain and deception they have wrought.
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
9/19/2013 12:36:27 AM
Author: You are totally wrong. You become what you eat, what you watch, listen to, the video games you play and like the people you hang with. This is all common sense and so logical a 10yr old knows it. Violent video games and movies desensitize you to violence, they make you used to it.... You like it, crave it and start thinking that violence and shooting is a solution. Seriously, common sense. This author can try and blow smoke all he wants, but it only makes him seem very foolish and stupid to be honest.
9/19/2013 3:35:08 AM
This is the most naive, dangerous comment on this topic. I'd have downrated it myself, but I needed to set some facts straight.
1. Mental illness is drawn to certain types of behaviors. For example, there is a well-documented correlation between illicit drug-use and mental illness...on the magnitude of appx. 70%.
2. Correlation does not equal causation. In the case of #1, drug use is essentially self-medicating behavior, NOT the root-cause of mental illness.
3. No matter how much you play COD, nothing comes close to live combat. No one ever got PTSD from playing COD. By the same token, games and other media (apart from, perhaps gore-porn) simply cannot desensitize a person to violence in real life; except, perhaps, for those who have a mental deficiency in the first place.
4. If what you propose--regarding 'you become what you consume'--then myself and a large host of DT users would probably be engaged in wanton shooting sprees on a regular basis. Please re-read #2 above. For an individual with perversion (sexual, cannibalistic, etc), the base desires exist regardless of outlets available. Simply because outlets that somewhat cater to those perversions exist...does not mean that those same outlets CAUSE the perversion. Occams razor would suggest quite the opposite.
In your case, I'm going to apply Hanlon's razor regarding your comments.
9/19/2013 8:37:00 AM
Sane people can separate games from reality. It is true that movies, news, and other media have desensitized us to violence somewhat. However, it is still necessary for the U.S. to censor videos of flagged-draped coffins coming back from the Middle East (not to mention images of innocent women and children that our military has maimed and killed) to damp down anti-war protests. Sane people are wired to believe that killing is very wrong.
Fifty years ago, we confined mentally unstable citizens to mental institutions. To save money, we now let them roam our streets. Many of the recent shooters were clearly unstable and would have been locked up under the old system. If guns were not available, they would have found another way, such as running trucks into crowds, dumping gasoline into buildings after blocking the exits, converting fireworks into bombs, etc.
Dr of crap
Dr of crap
9/19/2013 8:57:33 AM
YOu sir, Mr p05esto, are a moron.
And only add to the pussifying of the US. This ONLY happens to the insane.
Hey why don't you get elected? We need more like you in charge! ( that was sarcasm by the way).
The crazies like you need to go away, far away. Take this guy out PAINFULLY. This lets be kind crap has to stop. Punish the eveil ones and maybe that'll stop this shooting spree we have now.
9/19/2013 10:44:13 AM
I eat a lot of chicken, I mean a lot. And the only tv shows I watch are breaking bad and sons of anarchy. Contrary to your theory, I haven't become a meth dealing biker with feathers at all.
I also have played violent video games since I was 10 years old and the thought of being in a physical confrontation terrifies me.
9/19/2013 1:16:42 PM
I was trained, as a U.S. Marine, to fight, protect, defend and kill. In fact I was taught to kill several different ways.
I own several weapons and carry on occasion. I've never had even the remote urge to use any of my weapons to shoot and kill anyone (or use any of my training for that purpose).
However, I do not have a metal illness. Reason guides me every day. Those that hear voices in their head, directing them to do horrible things, no longer have the ability to reason. Those people are ill and need our help. We ignore these people and they get worse and worse until the voices speak louder than anything else. This is how these tragedies occur. Not by movies or video games. I play many video games, many of them violent. I watch many movies, many of the of the action genre that have violent themes. Still no urge to kill anyone.
Sick people need help, we should be helping them before the tragedy occurs.
"This is about the Internet. Everything on the Internet is encrypted. This is not a BlackBerry-only issue. If they can't deal with the Internet, they should shut it off." -- RIM co-CEO Michael Lazaridis
8-Year-Old Boy Murders Elderly Woman, "Grand Theft Auto IV" Takes Flak
August 26, 2013, 1:55 PM
NRA Blames Video Games for Violent Crimes, Then Releases Shooter Game
January 15, 2013, 1:03 PM
Norwegian Terrorist Brags He Learned His Skills in COD:MW2 Video Game
April 19, 2012, 10:37 AM
Man Threatens to Blow up Best Buy After They Deny Him Modern Warfare 3
November 10, 2011, 11:49 AM
Parents Fight to Ban Educational Math Game for Being Too "Violent"
June 8, 2010, 12:03 PM
AMD CEO: Windows 10 Will Launch at "The End of July"
April 20, 2015, 7:24 PM
Testers Trolled by Promise of Uninstallable Windows 10 Preview Build 10061
April 16, 2015, 2:52 PM
Rumors Heat up About 2016 Windows 10.1 (Windows "Redstone") Release
April 8, 2015, 9:26 PM
Report: Windows 10 Successor is Codenamed "Redstone" After Minecraft Item
April 7, 2015, 2:03 PM
Windows 10 Build 10049 Installation May Take Hours, Will Fail if You Have < 8 GB
March 31, 2015, 2:59 PM
Windows 10 Build 10049 Airs, Complete With Project Spartan Browser
March 30, 2015, 7:12 PM
Most Popular Articles
Raytheon $1.9 Billion Purchase of Websense Raises Tough Questions
April 20, 2015, 1:57 PM
After Record-Setting Week, Samsung Predicts 70 Million GS6/GS6 Edge Sales
April 17, 2015, 8:39 PM
HBO to VPN HBO Now Users: Prove You Live in U.S. or We Will Terminate You
April 21, 2015, 12:17 PM
Testers Trolled by Promise of Uninstallable Windows 10 Preview Build 10061
April 16, 2015, 2:52 PM
Apple Plans In-Store Workshops to Teach Users How to Use Its Smartwatch
April 17, 2015, 1:02 PM
Latest Blog Posts
Sceptre Airs 27", 120 Hz. 1080p Monitor/HDTV w/ 5 ms Response Time for $220
Dec 3, 2014, 10:32 PM
Costco Gives Employees Thanksgiving Off; Wal-Mart Leads "Black Thursday" Charge
Oct 29, 2014, 9:57 PM
"Bear Selfies" Fad Could Turn Deadly, Warn Nevada Wildlife Officials
Oct 28, 2014, 12:00 PM
The Surface Mini That Was Never Released Gets "Hands On" Treatment
Sep 26, 2014, 8:22 AM
ISIS Imposes Ban on Teaching Evolution in Iraq
Sep 17, 2014, 5:22 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2015 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information