backtop


Print 48 comment(s) - last by spaced_.. on Sep 22 at 2:08 PM

Even if Google can settle it faces numerous more antitrust probes on other topics in the EU and U.S.

On Monday, Jonathan Todd, spokesman for the European Commission (EC) -- the European Union's (EU) market regulatory watchdog -- revealed that Google Inc. (GOOG) had reached out to the EC and promised to make serious changes to address allegations made by EU antitrust regulators.

I. EU Receives Google's Last Ditch Pitch

Mr. Todd told Reuters in a statement:

The Commission received a proposal from Google and is assessing it.

Google's spokesperson, Al Verney added:

Our proposal to the European Commission addresses their four areas of concern. We continue to work with the Commission to settle this case.

For Google -- who makes the world's most use mobile operating system, search, and internet advertising platforms -- it's been a bewildering ride with European antitrust regulators.  The company has been probed and threatened by the EU for over three years now.
Google fortified
Google has been warding off antitrust accusations from Microsoft, who runs the smaller rival "bing" search service. [Image Source: Fast Company]

The company can largely thank Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) for its EU antitrust woes.  Microsoft has led two key coalitions -- The FairSearch Coalition, whose members also include Expedia Inc. (EXPE) and TripAdvisor Inc. (TRIP), and ICOMP, whose members also include Foundem, Hot-map, Streetmap, and NexTag -- both of which filed complaints about Google, claiming that Google boosts the ranks of its own services when consumers use its search engine.

While this might sound like smart business, Microsoft alleges it's illegal, and it could be right due to Google's dominant position in the search market and the way EU antitrust laws are structured.

Also, Google is accused of "scraping" or gathering results from its competitors’ services using automated scripts to improve the quality of its own results.  Google does not deny doing some scraping; pointing out that Microsoft does the same.  However, given that scraping is a gray area in current antitrust laws, it is possible that Google could be viewed as committing antitrust abuses when it scrapes smaller competitors.

web scraping
Google has also been accused of abusive scraping [Image Source: Google Images/unknown]

Part of the problem is that in the EU Google has traditionally held a much larger piece of the market.  In the EU Google has held as much as 86 percent of the search market; currently it has around an 80 percent market share, according to Reuters.  This is much higher than in the U.S., where its market share is currently around 67 percent, according to market research firm Comscore.

II. More Antitrust Woes Loom for Google

But whether or not Google has abused its dominant position to further its own services like Gmail, Google Docs, Google Flights, and Google Shopping, it's hard not to feel a bit of sympathy for the chaotic way in which antitrust punishments for Google have been handled in the EU.

After being given a "last chance to settle" in May 2012, Google in Feb. 2013 released a full response, which promised big changes as to how it was scraping and ranking search results.  The EC initially accepted that proposal.  But after Microsoft and others claimed that the punishments weren't severe enough, the EC went back on its approval of the Google settlement and demanded more flesh from Google.

EU books antitrust
 The EU "changed its mind" about Google's settlement offer. [Image Source: nrw.nl]

The EC is a pretty fearsome regulator.  It has nailed Microsoft Corp. (MSFTwith multiple fines totaling around $2.8B USD over Windows antitrust abuses, plus pounded Intel with a $1.45B USD fine for allegations of CPU price fixing.  Its policies have been so aggressive that Apple, Inc. (AAPL) opted to settle in the EU over e-book price fixing accusations, while fighting similar accusations in the U.S.

Google is clearly prepared for the worst.  It has set aside $500M USD to pay for potential antitrust fines in the EU.

To make matters worse for Google, the U.S. debate over Google's search engine tactics has yet again resurfaced.  After probing Google, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) agreed to a proposal where Google promised to make minor changes and would not face any fines.  The FTC even defended that decision against criticism by Microsoft and others who felt that the punishments were too light.  But recently the FTC has been rumored to be cooking up a fresh probe examining a new angle -- looking at whether Google's acquisition DoubleClick engaged in anticompetitive tactics in the search market.
Google Android
Google is also accused of using abusive tactics to promote its free Android operating system, which accounts for four out of every five smartphones and two out of every three tablets sold.

Google also faces allegation of abuse in the U.S. and EU of so-called "standards essential patents" (SEPs), which are supposed to be licensed under the "fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory" (FRAND) rules.  Last, but not least, Google also faces a privacy probe in the EU, in which EC regulators have demanded Google make changes by the end of this month.


Privacy is another major issue Google is being grilled on. [Image Source: Inquistr]

In short, even if Google manages to win over the EU with its settlement proposal and escape fines, it still faces at least two more major topics of antitrust investigation in the EU, U.S., and elsewhere.

Source: Reuters



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

RE: If You Cant Beat Em
By spaced_ on 9/13/2013 5:51:21 PM , Rating: 2
Also, it makes no sense for Google to 'steal' results of something as comprehensive and quick to change as weather data. That'd be ridiculously inefficient and prone to error to crawl a weather site when there's an abundance of weather data providers out there with direct access to data or APIs.

And it seems I'm right: http://www.google.com/intl/en/help/features_list.h...

Unless ofcourse - it's a big conspiracy. Of which I can't find any supporting information, even on Bing.


RE: If You Cant Beat Em
By ven1ger on 9/13/2013 9:19:43 PM , Rating: 3
The 'steal'-ing of weather data is just like the news stuff that news sites are probably complaining about. Just that Google is linking and displaying a snippet of information that most users only peruse, and to get more information they have to click on the link to go to the website. What the complaint seems to be is that most users don't bother going to the news/weather site to generate adclicks. Of course, they could always not allow Google to link to their pages but then of course, we don't hear that part because those sites fear that the clicks they do get from Google, will go to other sites. They don't mind that Google advertises for them a little but they also want the viewers to go to their websites to get the ad revenue, just plain greed.


RE: If You Cant Beat Em
By spaced_ on 9/13/2013 10:21:06 PM , Rating: 2
Given that all evidence points to the fact Google uses a 3rd party weather service to gather their data, which I'm fairly sure they pay for, I'm not sure how they're 'stealing' anything weather related.

The news thing I don't understand, what exactly are they stealing? Google News has been around for a decade and news sites were rejoicing when it first came out. When the Belgian news corporations tried to cut off google entirely a few years back it didn't go so well for them once they realised google was indeed actually doing them a favour.


"If you can find a PS3 anywhere in North America that's been on shelves for more than five minutes, I'll give you 1,200 bucks for it." -- SCEA President Jack Tretton














botimage
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki