Print 70 comment(s) - last by mehcin.. on Sep 2 at 2:25 PM

The boy shot his caregiver in the head

An 8-year-old Louisiana boy has shot and killed his caregiver, and the video game "Grand Theft Auto IV" is being blamed for his actions.

The incident took place in a mobile home park near Slaughter, Louisiana, and the East Feliciana Parish Sheriff's Office has ruled it a homicide. 

The boy, whose name has not been released, reportedly took a gun and shot his elderly caregiver -- identified as Marie Smothers, a woman of about 87-90 years old (her age hasn't been confirmed yet) -- in the head. The gun is believed to be Smothers'.

The boy said it was an accident, but officers believe it was intentional. The theory is that the boy took the gun and shot Smothers in the head while she was watching TV.

According to reports, officers noted that the boy was playing "Grand Theft Auto IV" right before the murder occurred. The child's motivation for the murder hasn't been confirmed as violence learned from the video game, but reports are leaning in that direction. They seem to be just assumptions with no real evidence. 

Grand Theft Auto IV

Reports also note that the child had a normal and loving relationship with Smothers.

The child has been released into the custody of his parents and likely won't be charged for the crime considering his age, according to Huffington Post

Whether or not video games lead to violent behavior has been a question under review for some time now. Many conflicting studies have been conducted on the subject, but none provide definitive evidence for or against the claim.

For instance, a 2011 study by researchers at the University of Missouri (MU) found that the brain becomes less responsive to violence after excessive and short exposure -- meaning that video game violence leads to an increase in aggression as the line between appropriate behavior and inappropriate behavior is blurred. 

The National Rifle Association (NRA) even blamed violent video games for violent crimes earlier this year after the tragic massacre at Sandy Hook Elementary in Newtown, Connecticut. 

However, a 2007 study by Texas A&M International University researchers in Laredo, Texas found no real link between violent video games and aggressive behavior. 

"Grand Theft Auto" is a video game series that allows gamers to engage in motor vehicle theft within the game. It has strong adult themes, such as the use of weapons and even sexual content, and it is rated "M" for mature. 

Source: Huffington Post

Comments     Threshold

This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

Rated 'M'
By Nekrik on 8/26/2013 2:06:06 PM , Rating: 5
and who takes the blame that an 8 year old was playing a 'mature' rated game?

Seems like the parties responsible for that decision should be considered as well.

RE: Rated 'M'
By Flunk on 8/26/2013 2:27:35 PM , Rating: 5
I think the parties involved are really the only things that need to be considered. Child has access to loaded firearm, M rated video games and who knows what else.

But we all know that the gun is the real problem. Small children and loaded guns don't mix. It sounds like they're talking about games to deflect from the real problem here.

RE: Rated 'M'
By Souka on 8/26/2013 2:44:49 PM , Rating: 5
Couple things...

How'd the kid get the gun? The caregiver is at fault for this happening.

Who let the kid play this game? The caregiver is at fault.

I have twin 8yr old boys... GTA is one game they do not need to play, its just sad really.

RE: Rated 'M'
By Motoman on 8/26/2013 3:03:01 PM , Rating: 5
This is kind of the thing.

Firstly, don't blame the video game (or the movie or the comic book or whatever). is an M-rated game, and no responsible parent or caregiver should be letting an 8-year-old play it.

Secondly, anyone who owns firearms has to be responsible for that firearm...and that means making it 100% impossible for a child to get their hands on a loaded weapon.

Who knows what the kid was thinking...whether he thought he was playing or knew the gun was real and loaded - indeed, whether or not he really grasps the concept of killing someone and making them dead, forever. But it's absolutely inexcusable for a child to be able to gain access to a loaded weapon, regardless of whatever else was going on.

RE: Rated 'M'
By tng on 8/26/13, Rating: 0
RE: Rated 'M'
By ClownPuncher on 8/26/2013 5:53:10 PM , Rating: 3
Accidents happen to the best society has to offer, too. It was just a completely avoidable accident.

RE: Rated 'M'
By tng on 8/26/2013 6:43:23 PM , Rating: 2
Accidents happen to the best society has to offer, too.
Yes they do and for the same reasons as well.

Just wondering if the trailer park is the kids home or just where his babysitter lives, or lived.

RE: Rated 'M'
By mi1400 on 8/27/13, Rating: -1
RE: Rated 'M'
By ClownPuncher on 8/27/2013 11:44:17 AM , Rating: 2
u wot m8?

RE: Rated 'M'
By MZperX on 8/27/2013 11:55:08 AM , Rating: 2
You don't reflect much credit on your own DNA with this post. :-/

RE: Rated 'M'
By WiiKnee on 8/29/2013 8:56:59 AM , Rating: 1
Why isn't there an option in my browser to translate this message?

RE: Rated 'M'
By FaaR on 8/27/2013 6:18:50 AM , Rating: 3
Where is the real mom and dad? Can we just sum this up by saying "Trailer Park Trash"?

If kid is with gramma, presumably the parents are working. Could be passed out drunk at a bar too, who the hell knows, but as the article doesn't say that I don't think there's cause for assuming something in that direction. Also, where do you get the impression they're "trailer park trash"? What a disgustingly fascist way to express yourself.

RE: Rated 'M'
By tng on 8/27/2013 5:54:47 PM , Rating: 2
Also, where do you get the impression they're "trailer park trash"?
Oh the irony, you are so upset that I had the nerve to imply that they were possibly trailer park trash then call me a fascist.

As to where I came up with that, here you are...
The incident took place in a mobile home park near Slaughter, Louisiana

Again, a caregiver? Mom and dad are absent and not even included in the story, 8 year old left to play a game that even I think is to violent for my tastes... If you don't get the association from that, you don't live in the US or haven't for very long and shouldn't talk.

RE: Rated 'M'
By boeush on 8/26/2013 10:59:55 PM , Rating: 2
Who knows what the kid was thinking... whether or not he really grasps the concept of killing someone and making them dead, forever.
I'd say any 8 year old who fails to grasp that particular concept, has to be ruled developmentally disabled (and severely so.) I distinctly remember having a very solid grasp of that particular concept, back when I was 4...

RE: Rated 'M'
By MrBlastman on 8/27/2013 11:30:49 AM , Rating: 2
I don't blame the game but damn, GTA IV is the only game I've ever played that I stopped playing because it was too chillingly realistic. I was walking around on a crime spree in the game, shot a truck driver in the head and they slumped forward with their head on the steering wheel, letting the horn blare forth. I just sat there and stared at it for a minute. I then turned the game off and haven't ever played it since.

This might be surprising considering I love horror movies--slasher films in particular, gore, violence etc. In fact, I love my games more the bloodier they are. I enjoy things depicted in games like Brutal Doom (a mod), Chivalry: Medieval Warfare (who doesn't like chopping people to pieces), Team Fortress 2 (when people exploded for the first time from the rocket launcher I squealed in delight), the original Rise of Triad (eyeballs...) and the list goes on.

The thing is... all of this gore and violence I enjoy... All of it doesn't try to be realistic. There's hyperbole and with it, complete detachment from reality. About the closest a game gets to real is Chivalry and even then since Monty Python has the Black Knight segment in Holy Grail, well, it alleviates a lot of it.

GTA IV, however, doesn't try and exhibit extremes--it tries to be real and simulate reality. This is where the line is drawn. No matter how much we might enjoy gore, violence and mayhem... a rational individual will know how to distinguish fantasy from reality. When reality becomes to great, a boundary is crossed and a sane person might grow disgusted with it.

I know all the games I enjoy are fake. That just makes them more fun because I know in this little fantasy world I can paint the walls red and litter the halls with limbs because in the end, it is so over the top and excessive it is blatantly obvious it is just a game and nothing more. GTA IV crossed this line. It tried to be too stark and I haven't been able to pick it up again as a result. In no way should an 8 year old ever be playing it. Even a 10 year old. It's just too much to handle. I'd much rather my young daughter watch me play Doom or Dark Souls than ever see me play a GTA game.

It doesn't mean we blame the game here but the adults present definitely had something to with it all. With an older person--yeah, we can reason how the game wouldn't have lead them to do something bad but with a young child, on the other hand, well, it might just do enough to desensitize them and in their little heads they might ration... hey, I wonder what it'd be like if I tried it on Granny?

To do that though, would still require a kid with some screws loose to begin with. My daughter is only 3.5 years old and we already teach her hurting people is bad.

RE: Rated 'M'
By ClownPuncher on 8/27/2013 11:48:44 AM , Rating: 3
GTA is about as realistic as an animated Adult Swim version of the Godfather.

RE: Rated 'M'
By MrBlastman on 8/27/2013 1:02:38 PM , Rating: 1
As far as killing of people. The rest of it is as you describe. :)

RE: Rated 'M'
By Totally on 8/26/2013 4:00:53 PM , Rating: 1
I don't mean to be presumptuous but:
The incident took place in a mobile home park...
You're going to have to lower your expectations a little.

RE: Rated 'M'
By DigitalFreak on 8/26/2013 6:38:44 PM , Rating: 2
Not to mention a town called Slaughter...

RE: Rated 'M'
By Devilboy1313 on 8/26/2013 7:16:38 PM , Rating: 2
Who takes a loaded gun, with no trigger lock, to babysit?

No to put the blame on the victim, but there is a level of stupidity that just should not be exceeded.

If you own a gun and are around kids you should always make sure it's not loaded and/or have a trigger lock. It's not that hard. There are just too many stupid people who just don't understand basic firearm safety.

Would you leave your car running with a 8 year old all alone in it? How about a running chainsaw and a child? Of course not, that would be bad parenting.

RE: Rated 'M'
By M'n'M on 8/26/2013 7:51:31 PM , Rating: 5
Who takes a loaded gun, with no trigger lock, to babysit?

In this case, nobody. The 87 yr old woman was the kids grandmother and from what I can tell, the boy was staying at her trailer, hence the "caregiver" terminology. I haven't see anything as to why she had custody of the kid and where the parents where. Neighbors interviewed didn't think anything was unusual about the kid.

So this would seem to be a case of the adult not keeping the weapon (a .38 Detective Special) secured properly. That she was shot in the back of the head while watching TV is largely her fault, lots of kids that age can't be trusted to understand the consequences of what they're doing.

RE: Rated 'M'
By vol7ron on 8/26/2013 10:32:24 PM , Rating: 4
When I grew up my parents taught me not to run with knives or scissors (or fork in mouth) as well as how to hold them properly when transporting them. They explained how it was sharp and how injury could result.

I have friends that teach their children what a sidearm is, how to use one, and they instill in them a responsibility when around firearms.

The problem is education, or lack thereof. That's what parents should be responsible for - educating their children. You don't leave gasoline and matches around without educating your children, you don't own a firearm without also educating your children.

The point of having a sidearm is often to have it in the event you actually need it, so keeping it unloaded, or locked is often a bad idea. Instead, keep your kids educated. The same thing applies to drugs and alcohol. Education is the basis of parenting.

RE: Rated 'M'
By Just Tom on 8/30/2013 10:19:28 AM , Rating: 2
There were times back in the day when I was babysitting my neighbors' kids that I would have liked a gun, or a taser at least.

RE: Rated 'M'
By Ammohunt on 8/26/2013 3:01:58 PM , Rating: 4
But we all know that the gun is the real problem

So if he stabbed her then the knife would be the problem? The real issue is stupid people like those who blame inanimate objects for their own stupidity.

RE: Rated 'M'
By tayb on 8/26/2013 3:15:56 PM , Rating: 5
Did you stop reading at that line and completely ignore the following sentences?

RE: Rated 'M'
By UpSpin on 8/26/2013 3:22:28 PM , Rating: 2
You can dodge a knife much easier than a bullet. You also can fight against some kid with a knife much easier than a kid with a gun. The kid has to get close to you, you can throw objects at the kid or run away, not possible if the kid has a gun.
You also can't accidentially kill someone with a knife as easy as with a loaded gun.
Kids also learn the proper use of knifes very early. They use them daily and know their danger. They know that a knife can do harm to people. They don't know this about guns, because there's no reason for them to use a gun daily.
Even if the kid aimed intentionally at his supervisor, I doubt he wanted to kill her. I doubt a kid really knows the danger of a gun and how easy it is to trigger a loaded gun.
You also can't mass murder with a knife that easy, but it's no real issue with a gun.

So I agree with you that it's a bit easy to just say the gun is at fault, but I disagree with you that a gun is as harmless as a knife. And I don't think the kid was stupid, the supervisor, probably, so I agree with you that the issue is less the gun, more that every idiot is allowed to own a gun.

RE: Rated 'M'
By Ammohunt on 8/26/13, Rating: -1
RE: Rated 'M'
By althaz on 8/26/2013 11:54:23 PM , Rating: 2
A gun is much further disassociated from death and violence than a knife is. This is quite well documented.

There's several issues:
Firstly it's obvious that the kid had problems - they may not have been major ones, but they should know better by eight years of age.
Secondly there's no way a gun should be left where a child can get to it, that should really be illegal (it is where I live) and regardless something that is part of responsible gun ownership.
Thirdly (and following on from my previous point), the caregiver was clearly incapable of proper and responsible gun ownership, so why the hell was she allowed to own a damn gun?
Lastly why is an eight-year-old playing Grand Theft Auto IV? That's (yet another) failure of this kid's parents & caregiver. This isn't the biggest deal, but it seems obvious that this kid shouldn't have been playing it - most eight-year-olds shouldn't (I won't speak for all of them, all kids are different).

RE: Rated 'M'
By spaced_ on 8/28/2013 4:18:45 PM , Rating: 2
Yeah where I come from, we have countless school knifing sprees all the time. Knives are so dangerous.

One time, this 7 year old kid knifed 20 people, kids, teachers after playing a video game. I think it was pac-man and he thought everyone was ghosts. It was after lunch see, he'd just eaten a powerup.

Man people are stupid these days.

Knives = guns = apples = potatoes = chairs = inanimate carbon rod

Like duh!!!

RE: Rated 'M'
By bobcpg on 8/26/13, Rating: 0
RE: Rated 'M'
By Flunk on 8/26/2013 3:36:04 PM , Rating: 2
You missed the point entirely. Read the next sentence, the 8 year old child having access to loaded firearms is the problem. The 8 year old child having access to M rated video games while not good, is not the main issue and the media is disregarding that.

RE: Rated 'M'
By bobcpg on 8/26/13, Rating: -1
RE: Rated 'M'
By TSS on 8/26/2013 3:20:56 PM , Rating: 1
But we all know that the gun is the real problem.


What the real problem is, is that this gets any news coverage at all. Yes, the kid shot her because he was playing GTA. At 8 years old i watched the looney tunes so much i thought real world physics where like the looney tunes and somebody could actually survive having a 10 ton anvil dropped on their head. Would've probably tried that too with my friends if i'd have any 10 ton anvils lying around.

But that makes this 1 shooting related to games out of how much? Google says ~31,000 victems in 2010. That's 0,003%.

Nobody talks about all the other shootings that aren't caused by video games. Nobody talks about the MILLIONS of people playing video games each day, including many young kids if the whining about Xbox whining is true, without picking up a real gun and shooting somebody.

How about the millions that will die from starvation once interest rates rise and the US has to spend 50%+ of tax revenue on *servicing* the national debt each year, leaving no more money for food stamps since no country in the world is buying treasuries anymore (only the fed bought treasuries in june, china and even japan sold, and the fed already owns 31,5% of the entire bond market), causing 50 MILLION americans to no longer be able to feed themselves (for reference: Average US historical interest rate: 6,68%. Mark where interest on debt already incurred reaches $1 trillion: 6%. And dropping).

That's something you can know for a fact, because it is a fact. But who cares about something as "outlandish" or "tinfoil hatty" as that right? Best focus on some 8 year old in some backwater town. Called Slaughter (damn right i laughed that's irony right there).

Sorry for yet another rant but this world is becoming so insane just reading any news is starting to make me crazy. When did idiocy reach these levels? Each day by now i'm spending way too much precious time of my life trying to convince just a few people of the coming disaster and all i'm hearing, after 3 years of that, is "maybe". As far as i'm concirned for the majority the zombie apocolypse has already happened, there is no cure.

Mark my words, in 10 years time everybody here will WISH video games made people violent. Atleast then what'll happen in the next decade could be explained and prevented from ever happening again.

RE: Rated 'M'
By Flunk on 8/26/13, Rating: -1
RE: Rated 'M'
By inighthawki on 8/26/2013 4:21:48 PM , Rating: 4
It is absolutely astounding how many people don't seem to be capable of reading the sentence directly after that one.

RE: Rated 'M'
By SAN-Man on 8/26/2013 4:37:29 PM , Rating: 2
Sounds like the responsible party is dead...

RE: Rated 'M'
By aany on 8/26/13, Rating: -1
RE: Rated 'M'
By km9v on 8/27/2013 11:48:55 AM , Rating: 2
So, forget logic, this is knee-jerk American journalism at it's best. BLAME THE VIDEO GAME COMPANY!!! It's all their fault, can't you see? This poor, defenseless 8 y/o is not to blame, what does it matter that he wasn't properly supervised. And, OMG! Why was there a gun in the trailer? Sue the gun mfg.

RE: Rated 'M'
By Totally on 8/30/2013 10:03:34 AM , Rating: 2
It isn't just American journalism, iirc the Daily Mail and Huffington post will publish trying crimes with violent video games whenever possible and they're British. Your first sentence should read 'forget logic, this is knee-jerk first world journalism at it's best.'

RE: Rated 'M'
By tamalero on 8/28/2013 4:26:47 AM , Rating: 2
even worse, who the hell leaves a gun in the reach of a CHILD???

"It looks like the iPhone 4 might be their Vista, and I'm okay with that." -- Microsoft COO Kevin Turner

Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki