Report Claims Global Warming is Increasing Brain Eating Amoebas
June 28, 2013 8:00 AM
Infections are mildly correlated to population, with little evidence supporting warming hypothesis from non-experts
is one nasty microorganism. A member of the amoeba family, it resides in inland bodies of water in North America. It attacks humans -- particularly young men. An alarmist report, backed by a non-expert, is proclaiming that
may drive infections. Is this the case? Let's examine the facts.
The amoeba enters via the nose and works its way into the brain where it multiplies, slowly killing the victim. The time between infection and onset of symptoms is nearly a week and the symptoms are rather nondescript at first -- headaches, vomiting, and confusion.
Once infected, the host's
brain is literally eaten alive
. The disease is referred to as PAM (primary amebic meningoencephalitis).
[Image Source: Trevor Haggie]
Since 1962 only one patient (out of 128 confirmed infections) has survived and infection by the deadly parasite -- a 99 percent fatality rate. In most cases, the infection isn't even caught. Vanderbilt University medical school professor William Schaffner describes diagnosis as more luck than any other factor, remarking, "It’s not something that’s necessarily touched on in medical school. You have to really probe what patients were doing in the last several days, you have to ask if they were swimming. Honestly, an accurate diagnosis is basically serendipity."
is a deadly amoeba. [Image Source: CDC]
Given the low rate of infections -- and even lower rate of infections that are recognized before death -- treatment is more guesswork than science. Patients are administered a cocktail of antibacterial and antifungal compounds. Jonathan Yoder, an expert with the
Centers for Disease Control
’s division of parasitic diseases, describes in
a recent interview
, "That’s very frustrating for us. Did the treatment only work that one time? Does it work at all? Would other treatments work better? We just don’t know."
The potentially bad news is that PAM incidents -- at least correctly diagnosed ones -- are on the rise. Here's a graph with the # of deaths and state of the death by year:
PAM incidents by year [click to enlarge] [Image Source: CDC]
Notice that there were big jumps in confirmed infections in the 1970s and in the 2000s. So what's to blame?
II. Hypothesis: Warming is To Blame
has run a rather alarming piece entitled "
Brain-eating amoebas thrive in US lakes as global warming heats waterways
". To be fair they have a source for this --
Bowling Green State University
(Ohio) Sports and Leisure professor. Now Professor Heggie has no professional degrees in epidemiology or microbiology, but he tracks
infections as a hobby.
Yet, he speaks authoritatively, telling
, "The climate is changing, and let me tell you, so is this. If warm weather keeps up, I think we’ll see N. fowleri popping up farther and farther north."
Is warming to blame for the rise in infections? [Image Source: Tehran Times]
's Katie Drummond writes, "That speculation seems to be reinforced by recent cases of PAM, once a health woe confined to fresh water in southern states like Texas and Arizona. In Minnesota, public health officials were stunned to see two fatalities caused by N. fowleri — both young children — in 2010 and 2012. The cases are the only in state history, and occurred about 550 miles farther north than any previous reported PAM fatality in the US."
The author is correct, two infections have occurred in Minnesota which are the only infections reported in Northern states. But note that nowhere in the piece do the real experts -- Dr. Schaffner and Professor Yoder -- suggest that the rise in infections is related to warming (a hypothesis fielded by Professor Heggie alone). Let's dig into whether the rise in infections is truly correlated with warming.
III. The Boy Who Cried Warming (Hypothesis Invalidated)
Let us consider factors that could drive rates of confirmed infections up (along with a suggestion on how it might impact infection rates):
resides in water 86 degrees and up)
National population (more people would mean more infections, you'd expect)
Urban population (people use more crowded water resources)
Papers on the disease (more interest means more awareness, more confirmations)
Mutations (hardy strains survive in new habitats)
Let's acknowledge, but toss out #5, as we don't have the data to track that.
To analyze this, let's first compile the rate of infections per decade which peaked from 2002-2011, thus far [Sources:
]. For #1 let's take the average rise in surface air temperatures over the U.S. on a decade averaged basis [
]. For #2 we can use widely available census data [
]. For #3 we can use data from a world clearinghouse [
]. For #4 we can use Thomson Reuters "Web of Knowledge" Product.
With this data in hand, we simply analyze the correlation of cases per decade versus influence and here is what we find:
Actually climate change has the
correlation of any examined factor. The strongest correlations are with the population itself (around 0.86), and more specifically with the urban population (around 0.85).
I'd be inclined not to discount the relatively high correlation to the amount of peer-reviewed research published per decade, though it's hard to say whether this is a cause or an effect. Ironically
report hints at this. Mr. Yoder comments, "I'll swear my life to that — this is being wrongly diagnosed [for bacterial meningitis]. If someone died of meningitis, I’d suggest looking into that case a little more closely ... and looking at where the brain was eaten away at."
A 1970 study shows that for every 16,000 cases of bacterial meningitis, one was actually a misdiagnosed case of PAM.
But even these correlations are highly speculative when one looks at the graph of change in the various variables, scaled to change in PAM infections per decade:
Is there an outside possibility that warming is having some affect on PAM? Perhaps, but it seems unlikely, given that most cases remain in southern states, some of which have actually cooled (like Georgia):
[Image Source: EPA]
Furthermore, while Minnesota is among the states to have warmed more over the past century, Michigan and the Eastern states have warmed at least as much -- yet had no cases. Michigan and Minnesota have roughly the same number of lakes [Source:
] over 100 acres -- yet there were no infections in Michigan.
In other words, while
is certainly a poorly understood disease and frightening public health threat. But to blame warming for this disease (or publicize such claims) is highly dubious. Quite simply put, the correlation is weak, as is the supporting evidence for such a claim. It appears this is yet another case of crying wolf.
CDC via Epidemiology and Infection [abstract]
"Paying an extra $500 for a computer in this environment -- same piece of hardware -- paying $500 more to get a logo on it? I think that's a more challenging proposition for the average person than it used to be." -- Steve Ballmer
Warming Evangelist Hansen Retires; Researchers Advise Panic Despite Flat Temps
April 11, 2013, 7:18 AM
Baffling Illness Strikes Africa, Turns Children Into Mindless "Zombies"
March 20, 2012, 9:11 PM
PIQ ROBOTTM reveals its new artificial intelligence software
November 29, 2016, 12:59 AM
One more time - Happy Thanksgiving to Everyone Around the World
November 24, 2016, 4:00 AM
Google’s Smart Contact Lens Project gets halted for 2016
November 20, 2016, 7:00 AM
Cell Research Study shows African Americans have greater immune response to infection
November 10, 2016, 1:00 AM
UTHealth Clinical Trial Shows Progress Using Stem Cells to Treat Traumatic Brain Injury
November 8, 2016, 1:00 AM
Uber Partners with Circulation to Pilot Program Connecting Transportation and Digital Health Care
November 6, 2016, 5:00 AM
Most Popular Articles
What Can You Do with Your New Echo Dot?
December 3, 2016, 5:00 AM
Google has developed Deep Learning Algorithm to detect Diabetic Eye Disease
December 4, 2016, 5:00 AM
Microsoft Surface – Which Surface is Right for You?
December 2, 2016, 5:00 AM
The iPlugmate is an Excellent iPhone Flash Drive at a Great Price. (Deal Expires in 3 Days)
November 23, 2016, 1:00 AM
Foscam R2 Home Security Camera System – High Quality High FHD Security Video Footage with No Monthly Fees
December 1, 2016, 2:00 AM
Latest Blog Posts
Latest Tech News
Dec 8, 2016, 5:11 AM
In The News
Dec 7, 2016, 5:00 AM
e Guide: Mobile Security for 2017
Dec 6, 2016, 5:00 AM
Apple Car is Not Dead
Dec 5, 2016, 1:00 AM
Dec 4, 2016, 5:00 AM
Dec 3, 2016, 5:00 AM
Dec 2, 2016, 5:00 AM
Surface Ergonomic Keyboard
Dec 1, 2016, 3:01 AM
Chapeconense plane crash: Football rallies around Brazilian Team
Nov 30, 2016, 1:00 AM
How to Extends Your iPhone’s Battery Life
Nov 29, 2016, 12:49 AM
Nov 28, 2016, 1:12 AM
News: Fidel Castro
Nov 27, 2016, 5:00 AM
Nov 26, 2016, 5:00 AM
Changes in Social status affect the way genes turn on and off within immune cells.
Nov 25, 2016, 5:12 AM
Austrian far–right hopeful Hofer may back EU vote.
Nov 24, 2016, 4:00 AM
Final Fantasy XV Leaked Before Nov 29 Launch Date
Nov 23, 2016, 1:00 AM
Nov 22, 2016, 2:26 AM
Nov 21, 2016, 1:00 AM
HTC Makes Big Moves in China
Nov 20, 2016, 2:00 AM
Do you know who is the number one company in the word?
Nov 19, 2016, 5:30 AM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information