Judge Posner, Senior Federal Justice, Repeats Plea for Patent Reform
October 2, 2012 7:30 PM
comment(s) - last by
Judge Posner, regarded as a top expert on intellectual property, claims the nation's legal system is being abused
It's hard to visit
or other science or technology publication over the last couple years without having your eyes assailed by a
. Indeed, as mobile device use has exploded so too has a stream of patent lawsuits, much of which cover areas like user interface design which were considered too ubiquitous to sue in past technology applications (e.g. traditional operating systems, games, the internet, etc.)
I. Judge Posner: Wake Up, the System is a Mess
The landslide of patent lawsuits isn't just a headache for companies and readers. It's increasingly drawing the ire of some of the U.S. legal system's most prestigious experts, who are arguing that companies are exposing flaws in current U.S. Patent Law, gaming the flawed system to achieve anticompetitive ends.
Among them is
Judge Richard A. Posner
. A sitting judge on the
Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals
, Judge Posner occasionally moonlights in Chicago's
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois
for crucial cases, a privilege earned by his glowing reputation and vast expertise regarding intellectual property law. And as a foremost expert Judge Posner has been
increasingly sounding the alarm
regarding the broken intellectual property system in the U.S., which is essentially be used and abused as a tool for large competitors to try to damage each other, and unilaterally to block out smaller competitors.
Judge Richard Posner says the U.S. patent system is broken.
[Image Source: Abel Uribe, Chicago Tribune]
In his joint blog with
University of Chicago
Economics and Sociology Professor
-- another top expert -- he recently posted
a scathing review
of the current law, writing:
When patent protection provides an inventor with more insulation from competition than he needed to have an adequate incentive to make the invention, the result is to increase market prices above efficient levels, causing distortions in the allocation of resources; to engender wasteful patent races—wasteful because of duplication of effort and because unnecessary to induce invention (though the races do increase the pace of invention); to increase the cost of searching the records of the Patent and Trademark Office in order to make sure one isn’t going to be infinging someone’s patent with your invention; to encourage the filing of defensive patents (because of anticipation that someone else will patent a similar product and accuse you of infringement); and to encourage patent “trolls,” who buy up large numbers of patents for the sole purpose of extracting licensee fees by threat of suit, and if necessary sue, for infringement.
The problem of excessive patent protection is at present best illustrated by the software industry. This is a progressive, dynamic industry rife with invention. But the conditions that make patent protection essential in the pharmaceutical industry are absent. Nowadays most software innovation is incremental, created by teams of software engineers at modest cost, and also ephemeral—most software inventions are quickly superseded. Software innovation tends to be piecemeal—not entire devices, but components, so that a software device (a cellphone, a tablet, a laptop, etc.) may have tens of thousands, even hundreds of thousands, of separate components (bits of software code or bits of hardware), each one arguably patentable. The result is huge patent thickets, creating rich opportunities for trying to hamstring competitors by suing for infringement—and also for infringing, and then challenging the validity of the patent when the patentee sues you.
In so many words, what the Judge is saying here is that the U.S. Patent Law is being handicapped by the fact that it does not consider commercial importance or obviousness as a criteria for accepting or rejecting a patent.
II. Patenting the Obvious, Trivial
Why does this matter?
A company with enough time and money can patent every single tiny feature of their complete product, no matter how trivial or unimportant, and then use that vast portfolio to drag its competitors through the mud.
What's the line between a feature and an invention? In the eyes of current Patent Law there is no real distinction. And that's what's leading to the
growing deluge of "junk" litigation
For his part Judge Posner is trying to both sound the alarm and personally knock out bad cases that happen to come through his jurisdiction. For example, seeing that Apple, Inc. (
) and Google Inc. (
) were simply trying to leverage their ubiquitous patent portfolios to harm the other, he twice threw their respective cases out of court [
The "trolls" are multiplying thanks to the growing swell of junk patents.
[Image Source: New Line Cinema; Fair Use clause
TITLE 17 > CHAPTER 1 > § 107
However, Judge Posner is just one man, one who some would argue is one of the few fighting "the good fight" in a broken system. Until that system is fixed, the abuses will likely expand as companies in other fields recognize how to use patents to transform a what society hopes is a free (capitalist) market into a closed (command) market, in which a select few power players seek to ban all would-be product producers.
Judge Posner suggests, "My general sense, however, bolstered by an extensive academic literature, is that patent protection is on the whole excessive and that major reforms are necessary."
He adds that copyright law is suffering from similar issues, although the mess hasn't (yet) reached some epic proportion as it has with patent law. He concludes, "The need for reform is less acute in copyright than in patent law, but it is sufficiently acute to warrant serious attention from Congress and the courts."
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
10/3/2012 8:04:37 AM
Why would anyone with skill want to be an underpaid Govt. employee? The only thing worthwhile with being a civil service employee, the pension, is being attacked and reduced. Plus you get the added bonus of being the whipping boy of every individual with an axe to grind against the government and get the added privilege of being called inept, lazy, stupid and many other pejoratives. You yourself have stated that the backlog is over a year long. This has more to do with budget cuts than anything else. So tell me again, why would anyone work for the govt. unless they had to?
10/3/2012 3:50:14 PM
Budget cuts??? really? You've got to be kidding. The Patent office has seen its budget increase through the past two administrations. Patents and Copyright are only supposed to be around to promote the progress in the useful arts. Patenting a rectangle is hardly what I would call useful, it is clearly obvious and it can also be found in nature... That was just one example.
"Google fired a shot heard 'round the world, and now a second American company has answered the call to defend the rights of the Chinese people." -- Rep. Christopher H. Smith (R-N.J.)
Samsung Alleges in New Filing That Apple's iPhone 5 Infringes on Its Patents
October 2, 2012, 1:01 PM
U.S. Court Denies German Court, Google the Right to Ban Microsoft Products
October 1, 2012, 1:44 PM
Quick Note: TiVo Gets Over $250 Million USD from Verizon in Patent Case
September 24, 2012, 7:15 PM
Swiss Railway Accuses Apple of Stealing Clock Design for iOS 6
September 21, 2012, 11:57 AM
"Googorola" Aims to Ban Most Apple Products, Accusing iMessage Infringes
September 21, 2012, 7:33 AM
Apple iOS 8.4 Rolls Out w/ Fix to Crash-Causing Unicode Text
June 30, 2015, 3:24 PM
Quick Note: Lumia 940 XL "Cityman" Phablet Gets Teased Via Tests
June 29, 2015, 5:51 PM
SanDisk's 200GB microSDXC Card Turns Smartphones Into Enviable PMPs
June 26, 2015, 2:02 PM
Xbox Outsold 108-to-1 By PS4 in Japan, Weekly Sales Fall to 100 Units
June 22, 2015, 1:54 PM
Apple Watch is Available to Order Again, 2.79 Million Units Estimated Sold so Far
June 18, 2015, 5:46 PM
Lumia 940 and 1040 Teased at in Alleged Leaked Images
June 15, 2015, 6:22 PM
Most Popular Articles
F-16 Schools Trillion-Dollar F-35 in Mock Combat, Fleeing is Best Option Pilot Admits
July 1, 2015, 5:53 PM
Apple Music: The Money, The Launch Hiccups, and the Nitty Gritty Details
June 30, 2015, 5:09 PM
Quick Note: Lumia 940 XL "Cityman" Phablet Gets Teased Via Tests
June 29, 2015, 5:51 PM
SpaceX Falcon 9's Seventh Supply Mission to ISS Ends w/ Fiery Stage 1 Explosion
June 28, 2015, 1:10 PM
Windows XP, Vista Users Can Get Free Windows 10 Upgrade Thanks to Loophole
June 23, 2015, 2:23 PM
Latest Blog Posts
Sceptre Airs 27", 120 Hz. 1080p Monitor/HDTV w/ 5 ms Response Time for $220
Dec 3, 2014, 10:32 PM
Costco Gives Employees Thanksgiving Off; Wal-Mart Leads "Black Thursday" Charge
Oct 29, 2014, 9:57 PM
"Bear Selfies" Fad Could Turn Deadly, Warn Nevada Wildlife Officials
Oct 28, 2014, 12:00 PM
The Surface Mini That Was Never Released Gets "Hands On" Treatment
Sep 26, 2014, 8:22 AM
ISIS Imposes Ban on Teaching Evolution in Iraq
Sep 17, 2014, 5:22 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2015 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information