U.S. Court Denies German Court, Google the Right to Ban Microsoft Products
October 1, 2012 1:44 PM
comment(s) - last by
Appeals court ruling offers Microsoft a key win in its legal battle against Android
Microsoft Corp. (
) appears to have dodged a major bullet in its legal battle against Android operating system maker Google Inc. (
I. German Windows Ban Dealt a Deathblow
While most Android OEMs
to Microsoft's licensing demands, Google vowed to fight back. It has been using its
$12.5B USD acquisition
-- patent-rich Motorola Mobility -- as a key tool in that battle.
A win would likely free Motorola's fellow Android OEMs
from licensing fees
, while a loss would mean that Google would be forced to accept that part of the revenue from every Android phone sold go to Microsoft (typically, $10 or more per phone).
Motorola was seemingly on the verge of a major win, thanks to a German court's decision to
ban the Xbox 360 and certain versions of Windows
for possibly infringing on Motorola's patents. However, that ban was called into question when
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington
Judge James Robart -- a judge in Microsoft's home state -- ordered that
it would be illegal for Google to enforce the ban
A judge has blocked Google from banning Microsoft products in Germany via Motorola.
[Image Source: TechnoBuffalo]
Now, a panel at the
9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco
that ruling, commenting, "At bottom, this case is a private dispute under Washington state contract law between two U.S. corporations."
II. Microsoft Can Ban Motorola, but Motorola Can't Ban Microsoft: Fair?
The message is that Google/Motorola cannot fight their war by proxy in Germany, a nation with a reputation for "
banning first, asking questions later.
But the ruling also raises certain questions, as it did not prohibit Microsoft from enforcing its
German ban on Motorola's products. Much like Motorola, Microsoft secured the ban from a German court months ago. As a result Motorola's Android handset stock in the German nation may soon be
taken to disposal locations and destroyed
While it may seem puzzling how a U.S. court can prevent a German court from banning products, it can effectively do so as Motorola resides in the U.S. and could face fines and other penalties if it refuses to comply. Thus U.S. courts can in roundabout fashion prevent foreign court rulings, when the ruling is made in favor of a domestic company and the American court opposes it.
Motorola's German suit involved two patents covering the h.264 codec. [Image Source: Joker Blog]
The now-defunct German ruling was based on a pair of h.264 patents --
, a patent on an "adaptive motion compensation using a plurality of motion compensators" (filed in 1992), and
a patent on an "adaptive compression of digital video data" (filed in 1994). As these are standards patents, Motorola may face additional punishments following an
by EU inquisitors regarding FRAND licensing abuses (as Motorola potentially should not have been able to sue with the patents).
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
RE: Opening a can of worms.
10/2/2012 12:14:08 AM
They are German patents obtained pursuant to EU law. However, that's irrelevant to the case before the US court. Under common contract law in place in most states in the US, including Washington, there is a concept of a "third party beneficiary." I am not a lawyer, but as I understand it, essentially it means that a third party, in this case Microsoft, has the contractual right to enforce an agreement between two other parties (in this case Motorola Mobility and the ITU) from which the third party would benefit.
It boils down to this. Motorola Mobility entered into a binding agreement with the ITU that in exchange for the ITU incorporating its patented technology into a new standard, Motorola Mobility would grant worldwide licenses to that technology on FRAND terms. Microsoft is saying it wants to enter into a license on those FRAND terms. The court is adjudicating whether Microsoft has third party beneficiary rights, and if so, what those FRAND terms should be. They don't want Motorola Mobility doing an end-around by forum shopping in an important foreign market in an attempt to essentially blackmail Microsoft into accepting a settlement.
Think of it this way. What if, 5 years ago, Microsoft and Motorola Mobility entered into a 20 year agreement to cross-license all of their patents at set terms, and to adjudicate any disputes through binding arbitration in London. If a case were brought before a court, that court would likely rule that the parties needed to bring the case before the arbitrator as they agreed. They likely wouldn't take too kindly to an attempt by one of the parties to seek an injunction that would effectively overturn the intent of the contract.
"This is from the DailyTech.com. It's a science website." -- Rush Limbaugh
Germany Could Destroy Motorola Handsets After Microsoft Victory
July 30, 2012, 11:11 AM
Google Completes Acquisition of Motorola Mobility, Layoffs Likely
May 22, 2012, 11:47 AM
Windows, Xbox 360 Could be Banned in Germany as Patent War Continues
May 2, 2012, 3:20 PM
Washington Federal Judge Denies Germany's Right to Ban Windows
April 12, 2012, 4:08 PM
EU Kicks Motorola While It's Down, Opens Official Antitrust Proceedings
April 3, 2012, 9:10 AM
UK Teachers Want Parents to Cut-Off Their Children's Internet, Tablet Use at Night
April 17, 2014, 3:40 PM
Quick Note: Chrome Remote Desktop App for Android Launches
April 17, 2014, 9:26 AM
Report: Apple Plans to Integrate Shazam Song Finding Functionality into Siri
April 17, 2014, 9:15 AM
Bring Your Own Battery: LG Isai FL Likely is G3, First U.S. Quad-HD Android
April 16, 2014, 7:38 PM
Project Moonshine: Google's Plan to Flatten Android App Icons Leaks
April 16, 2014, 1:46 PM
Apple, Microsoft, and Major U.S. Wireless Carriers Embrace Smartphone "Kill Switch"
April 16, 2014, 10:08 AM
Most Popular Articles
Cities to Carpoolers: Sharing Your Car is Illegal, We Will Seize Your Cars
April 4, 2014, 9:17 PM
A-10 Warthog May Live to Fight Another Day with Support from Lawmakers
April 14, 2014, 9:41 AM
EFF: NSA May Have Used IRC Botnets to Exploit Heartbleed for Last Two Years
April 14, 2014, 4:43 PM
Quick Note: Toyota Attempts to Erase “Boring” Image with ’15 Camry SE Hybrid
April 16, 2014, 11:36 AM
A Bug's Life: Female Cave Bugs Have Penises, Penetrate Males for Three Days
April 17, 2014, 7:20 PM
Latest Blog Posts
Facebook Aims to Provide Internet to "Every Person in the World" with Drones, Satellites
Apr 1, 2014, 10:20 AM
Retail Mobile Sites Experience Outages in Light of Simplexity's Bankruptcy
Mar 14, 2014, 8:48 AM
Tesla vs. BMW: Who Has the Safer EV?
Feb 1, 2014, 2:56 PM
Justice Leaks Details of Next HTC One Two Flagship Phone
Dec 5, 2013, 4:04 PM
Global Cyber Espionage Concerns Reveal Growing Cyber Armies
Nov 29, 2013, 11:04 AM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information