Media Reaction on iPhone 5 is Mixed, Some Pan Apple for Uninspired Showing
September 12, 2012 5:26 PM
comment(s) - last by
Critics say Apple is moving to slowly to compete with innovative competitors
"While many will no doubt proclaim the iPhone 5 to be a miss due to the lack of radical change, I say look at it logically. The last time a product as successful as the iPhone got a radical change it was a total disaster. Remember New Coke?"
James Kendrick, a contributor at
I. Some Reviews Blast Apple for Slow Progress
There's praise in there for Apple, Inc.'s (
-- indeed Mr. Kendrick even titles his piece "Just what Apple needed". But by the same token Mr. Kendrick is openly acknowledging that some folks will be less-than-impressed with Apple's modest hardware improvements and virtual standstill on the operating system front.
Others like "Fake Steve Jobs" -- Dan Lyons -- were far less kind. Writing for
, Mr. Lyons
Somewhere up there, I can hear Steve screaming.... Apple's renowned designer Jonathan Ive has replaced the tiny 3.5in (8.9cm) screen with a slightly-less-tiny 4in (10.2cm) screen? Wow. Knock me over with a feather. What do you do with the rest of your time, Jony? ...despite all its bluster about innovation, Apple has become a copycat, and not even a good one. Why is Apple making the iPhone bigger? To keep up with the top Android phones.
In terms of products, Apple has become the one thing it should never be. Apple has become boring.
writes in a piece entitled "Apple iPhone 5: big innovation takes a holiday":
Let there be no doubt, the device will sell a boatload of units. However, the changes seemed all incremental improvements -- new features that were nice, but none that catapulted Apple ahead and left all rival Android phones in the dust.
Doubtless the hardcore fans will argue that Apple is revolutionary, blazing trails and creating amazing products. But from a more detached view, the company's pace of major innovation seems to be slowing. For example, there didn't seem to be anything new that was the equivalent of a Siri or Retina display.
To be fair, there were some glowing articles as well -- and the majority of bloggers took the high road in terms of simply reporting the facts and details on the presentation.
But the iPhone 5 is perhaps the most mixed reaction to an iPhone since the product's 2007 launch. If the iPhone 4S launch
left some lukewarm
, this one left the critics downright chilly.
Surely this kind of negative publicity would never have occurred under Apple co-founder and two-time CEO Steve Jobs' watch. But
Steve is gone
, and Tim Cook is at the helm, and so far Apple seems to have lost some of its magic which once enraptured most members of the media.
II. Is Apple "Pulling a Vista"?
The reaction draws some analogies to the reviews of Windows Vista. That's not to say the product is the same -- it clearly isn't. Nor are the circumstances. But reading the reviews recap:
I'd say the majority were guardedly positive, saying that Vista looked good overall but wasn't a killer product that demanded instant installation on every PC on the planet. ZDNet’s Ed Bott (who didn’t publish a comprehensive review), PC World’s Preston Gralla, and Paul Thurrott were enthusiastic overall; BusinessWeek’s Steve Wildstrom, CNET's Robert Vamosi, and PC Magazine’s John Clyman all accentuated more negatives than most. Only Forbes’ Manes was extremely negative, period.
's study on the contentious Microsoft Corp. (
) product and one observes some similarities -- a massive company pitching a flagship product that leaves many neutral, and a few vehemently negative, to the point where some were complaining that the innovative fire was gone from the product maker's eyes.
Windows Vista was another iconic product to draw mixed reviews; yet it generated decent sales overall. [Image Source: FoxNews]
The Vista comparison
isn't very flattering
. But remember, Vista sold
copies in 7 months -- almost 30 million licenses per calendar quarter. The lesson? Even if Apple's product is as much of a dud as its strongest critics state, residual product loyalty and its massive sales machines will drive modest sales, much as similar factors at Microsoft helped move Vista licenses.
Technologizer [Vista Reviews]
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
RE: It's About Iterating, Not Re-Inventing
9/13/2012 4:36:16 AM
I think you pretty much nailed it Jason.
But at the same time... the iOS interface is dreadfully simple to use, many people will like for it to stay the same. But why not offer the same UI but with different optional skin choices?
I am running the latest iOS on my iPad1, its quite nice, 6.0 offers nothing (obviously) because of its age. Then I can compare my Galaxy S1 Android 2.3 (running WP7 interface on top) to Android 4.0... and its LOOKS amazing, its slick. I doubt I'll run the WP7/8 UI on top of my new Android phone I'm picking up on Friday (Atrix HD) which has some 4.1 elements. Just using 4.0 was nice to use, vs 2.x which I never really cared for.
On the hardware end, my take:
1) I actually PREFER the smaller size of the iPhone4/5... I wish more Android phones were that small. Something that Motorola did with the Droid RAZR M. They stuck a 4.3" 960x540 screen into a body that is a hair wider than the iPhone 4/5. The screen itself is not as sharp as the 720p screens...it almost has no bezel whatsoever (I wonder if its more prone to breaking?) - it LOOKS AWESOME. The body shape is very nice.
To me, the perfect phone with by the Droid M body style, but slightly bigger body to hold the 4.5" 1280x720 screen. It would STILL be smaller than my Samsung Captivate with its 4.0" screen.
I also think that Apple kept the same size for easy conversion with accessories, even if the DOCK connector is smaller.
2) I'm good with the two-tone back... the metal back won't shatter. I personally like different textures.
3) the front is same-old same-old... I think they could have done a but more?
4) Speakers on the bottom is still one of the better locations (front = even better).
5) inside hardware, seems great... no NFC is odd, but the metal body prevents THAT from happening.
As other have posted... Nokia has done a bit more INNOVATIVE things with the 820/920. I half agree. The 920 is an updated 900. The 900 is an uncomfortable square block. I was sick of it after a minute. The 820 is what I would love to have (If WP8 was something I was willing to use) - it looks great all over. Changeable bodies = easy replacement when its scratched up or for seasons / moods. Only downer is the 800x480 resolution (so 2010).
I wish I liked Windows8 and that the 820 was available with my carrier. It has more of the COOL factor that the iPhone5 doesn't have.
Hmmm... hey, didn't the CEO of FOXCONN say the iPhone5 was going to kill everything else? I don't see that happening. A lot of people will buy it... but not like the iPhone 4. Its an improvement over the iPhone4s in every way, which is to be expected. I think iOS7 will need to somehow GRAB people... But it doesn't.
"Spreading the rumors, it's very easy because the people who write about Apple want that story, and you can claim its credible because you spoke to someone at Apple." -- Investment guru Jim Cramer
Apple Announces 4", LTE Equipped iPhone 5; Pre-orders Begin Sept. 14
September 12, 2012, 1:00 PM
Apple Co-founder and Former CEO Steve Jobs Dead at Age 56
October 5, 2011, 7:51 PM
IPhone 4S Disappoints Consumers, Investors; Siri App Kicked Out of App Store
October 5, 2011, 10:27 AM
Microsoft Exec Suggests Apple's iPhone 4 Debacle is Apple's "Vista"
July 14, 2010, 5:20 PM
Microsoft: 60 Million Vistas Shipped, 1 Billion Windows by 2008
July 31, 2007, 9:20 AM
BlackBerry Passport Flagship Smartphone to be Officially Announced September 24
September 2, 2014, 2:36 PM
Google Plans Small Updates to Make Android Wear Smartwatches More Self-sufficient
September 2, 2014, 11:00 AM
webOS Reborn as LuneOS ROM for Select Android, webOS Devices
September 2, 2014, 10:47 AM
Sony Xperia Z3 Compact Revealed in Leaked Photos
September 2, 2014, 9:53 AM
ASUS' ZenWatch to Arrive Wednesday, Feature Sub-$200 MSRP
September 1, 2014, 2:40 PM
Microsoft Teases Lumia 730 "Selfie" Smartphone Ahead of Thursday Unveil
September 1, 2014, 9:45 AM
Most Popular Articles
Numerous Leaks Detail 4.7" iPhone 6 Processor, RAM, Cellular and NFC Capabilities
August 29, 2014, 10:37 PM
Windows 9: "Upgrade Now" Button Coming for Enterprise Updates, ARM Preview in H1 2015
August 26, 2014, 8:00 PM
L.A. Unified School District’s Apple iPad Contract Canceled Following Heavy Criticism
August 26, 2014, 12:37 PM
Apple Builds Not-So-Secret Secret 3-Story Tower for iPhone 6/iWatch Unveil
August 28, 2014, 3:41 PM
Netflix Accuses Comcast of Ripping Off Customers, Files to Block Merger
August 26, 2014, 5:49 PM
Latest Blog Posts
Space Terrorism is a Looming Threat For the United States
Apr 23, 2014, 7:47 PM
Facebook Aims to Provide Internet to "Every Person in the World" with Drones, Satellites
Apr 1, 2014, 10:20 AM
Retail Mobile Sites Experience Outages in Light of Simplexity's Bankruptcy
Mar 14, 2014, 8:48 AM
Tesla vs. BMW: Who Has the Safer EV?
Feb 1, 2014, 2:56 PM
Justice Leaks Details of Next HTC One Two Flagship Phone
Dec 5, 2013, 4:04 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information