Judge Posner Dismisses Apple-Motorola Case Again, Blasts Apple
June 25, 2012 1:44 PM
comment(s) - last by
Judge took issue with Apple's refusal to assign a reasonable licensing value to patents
Apple, Inc. (
) had a dream. In its dream it no longer had to compete with Google Inc.'s (
). Instead it
resorted to "thermonuclear war"
with Android, gaining sales bans and suing Android device makers with damage claims so exorbitant that licensing was a non-option.
But it's looking increasingly like Apple's dream is but a fantasy, as the U.S. federal court system, like its peers, are growing tired of the company's legal crusade.
I. Great Expectations for Apple
Judge Richard A. Posner
Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals
judge who moonlighted in the
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois
(Chicago), tossed Apple and Motorola Mobility's (a Google Inc. (
suits/countersuits out of court
"with prejudice" during the first week of June. He was upset about both companies' refusal to place realistic evaluations of their patents' worth (both companies reportedly lofted astronomical figures).
It was Motorola who originally initiated this suit, but it was essentially just committing to a preemptive strike after CEO Steve Jobs and Apple lawyers verbally threatened to sue it in late 2010. During the month of October 2010 Motorola dropped the hammer and
Apple followed in suit
with its promised infringement lawsuit.
The legal war was waged in Chicago court. [Image Source: Flickr/
By 2011, Apple was growing eager with anticipation. Motorola was facing scrutiny, as its lawsuit was founded on
fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) standards patents
. Motorola's decision to sue using FRAND IP had already provoked
complaints from Apple and Microsoft
By contrast, Apple's patents were non-FRAND and carried fewer licensing restrictions.
Apple perceived this as an opportunity to demand essentially infinite damages, leading to
a complete ban on current handset models
and forcing Motorola,
to scrap key features that seemingly overlapped with Apple's massive software patent portfolio. Paid critics of Google,
such as Florian Mueller
, eagerly salivated at Android's impending doom after it was "neutered" by Apple patent lawsuits.
Motorola's lawyers fought fire with fire, also requesting massive damages, despite realizing that their patents FRAND status made those damages even more risky.
II. Case Dismissed, Again
In the end Judge Posner rebuked both companies for this approach, dismissing the case. The dismissal was a blow to Google's defense efforts, but was a far bigger blow to Apple's offensive efforts. For that reason it was Apple who petitioned Judge Posner to reconsider, pleading for additional hearings to present revised arguments.
But those hearings came and went and Judge Posner has yet again dismissed the case with stinging words for Apple.
He comments in his ruling, "No more can Apple be permitted to force a trial in federal court the sole outcome of which would be an award of $1."
Judge Richard Posner was not happy with Apple. [Image Source: Abel Uribe, Chicago Tribune]
There would be no injunctions he added -- for either side. They would simply have to compete on the free market, seeing as they could not be reasonable with their requests in court.
He comments, "Both parties have deep pockets. And neither has acknowledged that damages for the infringement of its patents could not be estimated with tolerable certainty."
III. Begrudging Apple Forced to Compete
Apple has seen its anti-Android legal blitzkrieg sputter to a crawl in recent months. HTC Corp. (
implemented a workaround
its handsets to skirt
based on "data-tapping" -- converting phone numbers or addresses to actionable links.
efforts to ban
Samsung Electronics Comp., Ltd.'s (
Galaxy S III
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California
(San Jose/San Francisco).
Judge Lucy Koh
, like Judge Posner, admonished Apple's zealous legal team. She accused them of trying to monopolize her time, commenting, "I cannot be a [full time] Apple v. Samsung judge."
In the Chicago Motorola case part of Judge Posner's frustration stemmed from the fact that Apple
complained at virtually every single stage
-- even after he had
handed them apparent victories
. Apple now is stuck between a rock and a hard place, as if it tries to appeal the ruling, the appeal will likely go to the same circuit appeals court that Judge Posner sits on.
Motorola's Razr MAXX will face no sales bans. [Image Source: Verizon Wireless]
The failure of its lawsuits is a very dangerous dilemma for Apple. A sales ban could help preserve Apple's strong position amid a period where it has made no bold or decisive moves.
death of Steve Jobs
in 2011, Apple's iPhones have seen slipping release schedules. The iPhone 4S did not land
until October 2011
, while this year's
sixth generation model
has yet to be even announced. This slippage stands in contrast to the reign of Jobs in which an iPhone was announced like clockwork each June and launched by late June (with the exception of the iPhone 3GS which launched in early July).
Likewise, after bold steps in terms of interface in early builds, Apple has since stalled.
suffered from bugs
in test builds and lags behind
Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich
Windows Phone 8
in GUI design. Apple is trying to spin its lack of refinements as sticking with "simplicity", but amid these attractive competitors it's looking increasingly demure and dated.
Product progress at Apple has slowed following the passing of Apple CEO/co-founder Steve Jobs
David Paul Morris/Getty Images
In short, the trainwreck of its legal efforts against Android couldn't come at a worse possible time for the iPhone's market hopes.
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
Finally....Some Judges who are tired of this childish bickering...
6/27/2012 10:32:06 AM
It would be hard for Apple to actually show damages. For reasons already known to all. If a consumer wants an Apple product...they will buy one. For those consumers who don't.....they will buy either Android or Win. Apple is trying to eliminate consumer choice. Thats it in very simple terms.
You can't deny the fact that Apple restricts its HW, Software, content access. Try and use an IPAD without using Itunes. Try loading content without ITunes or going through an Apple Portal. You can't...unless you hack the device...which Apple legally challenged already. They DO not want you going anywhere else.
If you have an IProduct...I hope you enjoy it, but know that not everyone wants one.
Freedom of choice.... that's what is key in an open market.
"Well, we didn't have anyone in line that got shot waiting for our system." -- Nintendo of America Vice President Perrin Kaplan
Microsoft Announces Windows Phone 8, Won't Support Current Handsets
June 20, 2012, 12:35 PM
Quick Note: Apple's Maps App Flunks at Geography, Navigation
June 13, 2012, 3:53 PM
Apple Plays Wile E. Coyote, Sees Galaxy S III Ban Attempt Foiled
June 13, 2012, 1:43 PM
WWDC: Apple Announces iOS 6, Shows Off In-house Maps App
June 11, 2012, 2:45 PM
Samsung Sues Aussie Patent Office; Prospect of U.S. Galaxy S III Ban Grow
June 8, 2012, 3:23 PM
Inspiron Laptops & 2-in-1 PCs
September 25, 2016, 9:00 AM
The Samsung Galaxy S7
September 14, 2016, 6:00 AM
Apple Watch 2 – Coming September 7th
September 3, 2016, 6:30 AM
Apple says “See you on the 7th.”
September 1, 2016, 6:30 AM
Apple sued because of iPhone 6 Touch Disease
August 31, 2016, 7:00 AM
Get Ready to wait in line – iPhone 7 due September.
August 18, 2016, 7:15 AM
Most Popular Articles
Update: Problem-Free Galaxy Note7s CPSC Approved
September 22, 2016, 5:30 AM
FDA Cleared, Shockwave Lithoplasty for Peripheral Vascular Disease
September 22, 2016, 5:45 AM
Walmart may get "Robot Shopping Carts?"
September 17, 2016, 6:01 AM
Are you ready for this ? HyperDrive Aircraft
September 24, 2016, 9:29 AM
Smartphone Screen Protectors – What To Look For
September 21, 2016, 9:33 AM
Latest Blog Posts
Burlington Gun Attack
Sep 27, 2016, 5:00 AM
Who is in Risk of Getting Oral Cancer?
Sep 23, 2016, 6:02 AM
France Bans Plastic Eating Utensils in Restaurants
Sep 18, 2016, 10:49 AM
Progress Against Acute Myeloid Leukemia
Sep 17, 2016, 5:30 AM
Apple Watch Series 2 - Number 1 in the Customer Satisfaction.
Sep 7, 2016, 6:19 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information