Apple's Case Against Motorola/Google Dismissed "With Prejudice"
June 8, 2012 11:00 AM
comment(s) - last by
Frustrated judge takes issue with parties inability to agree, unwillingness to license
Both Apple, Inc. (
) and Android operating system maker Google Inc. (
subsidiary Motorola Mobility
saw a potentially
precedent setting ruling
, in which both parties cases were dismissed by an irate federal judge.
I. Dismissed With Prejudice
Judge Richard A. Posner
Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals
judge who moonlighted in the
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois
(Chicago) for this critical case, seemed to imply that both companies were trying to abuse the legal system, wasting its time with unclear arguments.
Both companies agreed that money would fix the alleged wrongs caused by the other's infringement. But Judge Posner was frustrated by the fact that neither company could reasonably justify the exorbitant sums they were claiming their patents were worth.
Judge Richard Posner was frustrated with what he viewed as ridiculous arguments from Motorola Mobility's and Apple's legion of lawyers. [Image Source: Abel Uribe, Chicago Tribune]
Also, Judge Posner complained about Apple's lawyers filing a mired myriad of motions. In this regard, Apple's insistence at objecting to every ruling of Judge Posner's may have hurt it in court.
Notably, Judge Posner had stated in a preliminary ruling that some features in Google/Motorola Mobility's Android operating system
infringed on Apple's intellectual property
complained about its victory
, with its legal team essentially bellyaching about the fact that the Judge didn't find in their favor for every single claim, even though he had found in their favor for
most of them
Judge Posner's decision to dismiss the case was quite resolute, in that he dismissed it "with prejudice", writing, "I have tentatively decided that the case should be dismissed with prejudice because neither party can establish a right to relief."
II. Appeal? Unlikely
Either company will have a tough road ahead appealing that decision as Judge Posner is a senior member of the Appeals court which would hear their case. In short Apple versus Motorola is probably over in the U.S. with no damages awarded to either company, on account of their legal teams' inability to be reasonable (according to Judge Posner).
The only possible alternative route would be to file further complaints to the
U.S. International Trade Commission
. But such complaints may not be taken seriously given the prestige Judge Posner holds among federal judges nationwide, in part thanks to his service for years as an esteemed faculty at the
University of Chicago
Apple's options to appeal or complain to the ITC are scarce. [Image Source: ArsTechnica]
Other than the ITC or an appeal, both companies will likely be banned from filing lawsuits against each other until 2014. It's important to note that Motorola Mobility was already
found innocent by the ITC
of Apple's accusations of infringement on several patents.
III. Good News for Customers; Bad News for Lawyers
Arguably this is a big win for consumers in that there will (likely) be no product bans, and the pair will be forced to compete on the market. Of course some Apple and Android fans may fantasize about banning each other’s products, but to the average consumer, such bans would at best be an annoyance.
On the other hand, it's a blow to both companies' legal efforts. For Google, it loses the ability to use Motorola Mobility as a club to beat Apple back from suing other Android handset makers, such as HTC Corp. (
). It was Motorola Mobility that filed the first lawsuit against Apple on Oct. 6, 2010.
For Apple, who
filed countersuit against Motorola Mobility
on Oct. 29, 2010, it is also a blow. While Apple did not necessarily start this fight explicitly, its former CEO Steve Jobs long implied Motorola Mobility (and Google) were in infringement and that he would eventually
"destroy" them with bans
Indeed, bans could have destroyed Motorola or at least have forced its new owner Google to reach deep into its pockets, given that the smartphone maker is already
struggling mightily with profitability
. Now Motorola's lawyers will be free to focus on their
court battle with Microsoft
Apple and Motorola Mobility will be forced to begrudgingly compete on the market.
[Image Source: Obama Pacman]
A diluted market is a dangerous market for Apple, as it learned in the 1980s. It is in Apple's best interest to keep the smartphone market
a two-company race
with Samsung Electronics Comp., Ltd. (
), should its efforts to
ban Samsung's product line
fail. Having a host of smaller alternatives like Motorola and HTC could eventually hurt Apple in the long run, as Apple would be fighting a one-man sales battle against a crowd of rivals.
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois via SBNation [PDF]
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
6/8/2012 11:18:39 PM
Yes, friendly CEO Tim Cook should allow everyone from Asus to Dell and HP to copy the MBA. He should let all the research which went into making the original iPhone software and hardware partnership and all the innovations (including their design) since then they have come up with like the iPad to be use by other companies because one company selling its inventions at a premium is not in the interests of the consumer now is it? Better to let all the far east OEMs sell their products cheaper to us and we will be happy, leaving Apple with the high end selling only by virtue of its marketing.
Did I leave anything out of how you lot would like the world to be? Just remember that Samsung are playing the game now throwing increasing cores and power at the phone market. How else are they innovating exactly? It took Apple and the iPhone to set the industry alight, without it we would all still be using motorola Blackjacks and blackberries
6/8/2012 11:37:50 PM
Oh, you mean Apple's design patent for a thin wedge with the thick end missing, since they omitted pretty much everything else from consideration for infringement? Think about that for a second and recall your elementary math class: they got a patent for an acute angle.
While I agree that Samsung's previous habit of trying really hard to make the Galaxy S and Tab look like Apple products was shameless, I think Apple is going too far to claim that a geometric shape is novel, when it was mostly made possible by things like SSDs and ultrathin displays, which Apple did not create.
6/8/2012 11:57:41 PM
How else is Samsung innovating?
Transparent LCD screens?
Foldable, durable LCD screens?
Apple invents NOTHING of use to the technology, they poach, package, and then market it as if they were the first game in town.
All that being said... GO ASUS! =)
6/8/2012 11:59:28 PM
One more vid for you:
"If you mod me down, I will become more insightful than you can possibly imagine." -- Slashdot
Apple Looks to Kill Samsung's Galaxy S III and the Rest of Its Family
June 7, 2012, 2:08 PM
Google Completes Acquisition of Motorola Mobility, Layoffs Likely
May 22, 2012, 11:47 AM
Motorola Androids Banned in the U.S.; Samsung May be the Last Survivor
May 18, 2012, 7:00 PM
Apple, Samsung Snag 99% of Mobile Phone Profits
May 4, 2012, 11:53 AM
Motorola Bleeds More Cash as it Waits for Google to Save It
May 2, 2012, 2:02 PM
Microsoft to Close Nokia Store, May Lose Over a Hundred Thousand Apps
January 26, 2015, 11:15 AM
BlackBerry CEO Claims Devs are Violating Net Neutrality by Not Supporting BB10
January 22, 2015, 4:37 PM
Will Google Become America's Fifth Major Carrier?
January 22, 2015, 12:42 PM
Report: Samsung Drops Snapdragon 810 From Galaxy S6, Will Use Its Own Chips
January 21, 2015, 1:47 PM
Report: Windows 10 Preview to Expand to Mobile Devices in February
January 20, 2015, 2:24 PM
IDC: 2014 Sales Show PC Isn't Dead, But Desktop May be Dying
January 19, 2015, 1:50 PM
Most Popular Articles
Microsoft Shows Off Latest Windows 10 Build, Preps it for Next Week Release
January 21, 2015, 2:57 PM
Under the Hood: How DirectX 11.3 and 12 Will Supercharge Windows 10 Gaming
January 23, 2015, 12:34 PM
IDC: 2014 Sales Show PC Isn't Dead, But Desktop May be Dying
January 19, 2015, 1:50 PM
Police are Using New Handheld Radar Sensors to Peer Into Houses w/out Warrant
January 20, 2015, 1:35 PM
Report: HTC One M9 (2015) is Tied to Under Armour-Powered HTC Smartwatch
January 19, 2015, 11:10 AM
Latest Blog Posts
Sceptre Airs 27", 120 Hz. 1080p Monitor/HDTV w/ 5 ms Response Time for $220
Dec 3, 2014, 10:32 PM
Costco Gives Employees Thanksgiving Off; Wal-Mart Leads "Black Thursday" Charge
Oct 29, 2014, 9:57 PM
"Bear Selfies" Fad Could Turn Deadly, Warn Nevada Wildlife Officials
Oct 28, 2014, 12:00 PM
The Surface Mini That Was Never Released Gets "Hands On" Treatment
Sep 26, 2014, 8:22 AM
ISIS Imposes Ban on Teaching Evolution in Iraq
Sep 17, 2014, 5:22 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2015 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information