Washington Federal Judge Denies Germany's Right to Ban Windows
April 12, 2012 4:08 PM
comment(s) - last by
Even if Germans side with Motorola enforcement using FRAND patent is illegal opines judge
Faced with licensing demands from Microsoft Corp. (
) ($10-$15 per handset) and the
threat of a ban
from rival gadgetmaker Apple, Inc. (
), Motorola Mobility has been pushing forward with its
of using its standards-heavy patent portfolio
. That approach currently has it
under antitrust investigation
in the European Union, but has not dissuaded Motorola from pursuing enforcement.
Motorola, a top Android phonemaker, continues to operate independently -- for now -- after Chinese regulators
held up the approval
of the company's
acqusition by Google
). China appears to be using the delay as a means of bargaining with the search engine provider who has
opposed its censorship demands
. That means that for now Motorola Mobility is forging its own way in court.
I. Judge Appears Skeptical of Motorola's FRAND Enforcement
controversial lawsuits against Microsoft
, which span several international courts, hit an unusual snag when the
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington
ruled in a special hearing that Motorola could not enforce a FRAND-based ban on Microsoft in Germany.
Microsoft has complained that Motorola is asking for thousands of times the typical "fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory" (FRAND) rate (which typically is around 2 cents per device). The patent in question is a Motorola patent on h.264 -- a commonly used video encoding standard.
A Washington federal court has forbidden Motorola from banning Windows sales in Germany until a U.S. case advances.
[Image Source: All About Samsung]
The restraining order, put in place by presiding judge
Judge James Robart
, may be enforceable as Motorola Mobility is a U.S.-based firm. However, it is unusual in that it is a case where a U.S. federal court is moving to essentially strip a top trade partner of its judicial authority in the short term.
In addition to the pending German case, Motorola and Microsoft are duking it out in a corresponding U.S. case that is currently being heard by Judge Robart. Until a May 7 hearing in the U.S. case, Judge Robart says that any attempts to enforce a ban on Windows sales in Germany (via preliminary injunction) would be illegal. He's forcing Motorola to post a $100M USD bond in the interest of compliance.
While the U.S. case has not been ruled on, the decision indicates the presiding Judge is skeptical of the validity of Motorola's FRAND based litigation.
II. What the Ban Might Have Meant to Motorola
Some believed Motorola might pull off a product ban in the Germany ruling, which was set to land on April 17. Germany's legal system works a bit differently in that patent validity is run in a separate track, meaning that in most cases -- even where there's a strong possibility that a patent is bad or being unfairly enforced -- the German court still enforces a ban on the alleged infringed product for the duration of the trial. Apple has achieved
similar bans of Motorola
Comp., Ltd. (
) Android devices in Germany.
Microsoft said the temporary ban on the injunction was necessary, writing in its motion for a restraining order, "If Motorola's sharp tactics are allowed to unfold, Microsoft will be denied a meaningful remedy in this action. Microsoft seeks a preliminary injunction here to preserve the status quo, to preserve this Court's ability to grant Microsoft meaningful relief, and to prevent irreparable harm to Microsoft and the public in the meantime."
Motorola and Microsoft are fighting over 100 patents, but the German case focused on only two, involving the h.264 codec. [Image Source: Joker Blog]
Jess Jenner, a lawyer with Ropes and Gray -- the firm representing Motorola in the U.S. case -- argued that a ban would be acceptable given that Motorola could repay Microsoft if the U.S. court later ruled it to be unfair. And she said the restraining order would be the equivalent of meddling in foreign justice, stating, "You are being asked to interfere with a German court. It's an intolerable intrusion on another country's prerogative."
Judge Robart didn't buy that line of logic.
Microsoft claims that the German lawsuit -- which only involves 2 patents out of the 100 being disputed in the U.S. -- is a mere maneuver to gain leverage by Motorola, exploiting Germany's controversial ban-friendly IP enforcement. As even a temporary ban on Windows sales in the large EU nation would be a financial blow to Microsoft, Motorola could use a ban to try to force a more favorable settlement in the U.S.
A jury trial is scheduled for November in the U.S., if the companies cannot settle their differences before then.
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
RE: This is absurd
4/13/2012 10:41:34 AM
Apparently, I've a wanted man for my time on the Autobahn. :P
His examples were a bit off, but he did correct himself that the only laws that are applicable would be ones at the federal level.
RE: This is absurd
4/17/2012 9:09:22 PM
Except where posted, 120mph on the autobahn is below the legal speed limit ... no laws broken at any level.
120mph in open desert is unlikely to break any laws other than illegal entry/trespassing...so yes that was a bad example.
US has no universal speed laws. All of our speed laws are location specific and for that reason are unlikely to trigger prosecution. Violate speed laws in Germany and the US Embassy will be happy to recommend a lawyer to represent you in German court, but unless the US declares it illegal for a US citizen overseas, the US will simply monitor the proceedings to ensure they are fair.
Bed a 12 yo sex worker in Thailand and you had better hope Uncle Sam never finds out, as that will put you in jail the moment you return to the US. Get involved in production or sale of illegal (in US) drugs without a proper license from the local government and you might be explaining why to some DEA agents. There are indeed laws that will put a US citizen in jail for crimes committed outside US territory. Sex crimes & drug dealing are simply examples, there are others.
"It's okay. The scenarios aren't that clear. But it's good looking. [Steve Jobs] does good design, and [the iPad] is absolutely a good example of that." -- Bill Gates on the Apple iPad
EU Kicks Motorola While It's Down, Opens Official Antitrust Proceedings
April 3, 2012, 9:10 AM
Judge's Ruling Upholds Apple Patent, Could Jeopardize Android's Future in the U.S.
April 2, 2012, 9:32 PM
German Court Overturns Android Victory Due to FRAND Concerns
February 27, 2012, 7:24 PM
Motorola Demanded $22.50 Per Windows Laptop, Microsoft Complains to EU
February 23, 2012, 4:30 PM
German Judge Bans Androids for Swipe-Unlocking, Despite Prior Art
February 16, 2012, 7:11 PM
"World's Smallest Chess Code" is a Cheating Novice (But Still Kind of Lovable)
January 28, 2015, 2:24 PM
Microsoft's Windows 10 Now Has "Over 2 Million" Public Testers
January 28, 2015, 9:25 AM
Quick Note: With Windows 10, the Windows Source Hits Build 10,000
January 20, 2015, 2:05 PM
Microsoft Kills "Mainstream Support" Windows 7
January 13, 2015, 1:01 PM
Windows 10's "Spartan" IE11 Variant Will Get Firefox/Chrome-Like Extensions
December 30, 2014, 1:30 PM
Cortana, Xbox App, OneDrive Apps/Settings Backup Added to Windows 10 Build
December 15, 2014, 3:43 PM
Most Popular Articles
Under the Hood: How DirectX 11.3 and 12 Will Supercharge Windows 10 Gaming
January 23, 2015, 12:34 PM
2016 Cadillac CTS-V Packs 640 hp Punch with 200 mph Reach
January 23, 2015, 3:25 PM
Microsoft Shows Off Latest Windows 10 Build, Preps it for Next Week Release
January 21, 2015, 2:57 PM
Google Fixes Homophobic "Bug" in its Translator
January 27, 2015, 2:31 PM
Will Google Become America's Fifth Major Carrier?
January 22, 2015, 12:42 PM
Latest Blog Posts
Sceptre Airs 27", 120 Hz. 1080p Monitor/HDTV w/ 5 ms Response Time for $220
Dec 3, 2014, 10:32 PM
Costco Gives Employees Thanksgiving Off; Wal-Mart Leads "Black Thursday" Charge
Oct 29, 2014, 9:57 PM
"Bear Selfies" Fad Could Turn Deadly, Warn Nevada Wildlife Officials
Oct 28, 2014, 12:00 PM
The Surface Mini That Was Never Released Gets "Hands On" Treatment
Sep 26, 2014, 8:22 AM
ISIS Imposes Ban on Teaching Evolution in Iraq
Sep 17, 2014, 5:22 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2015 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information