German Court Overturns Android Victory Due to FRAND Concerns
February 27, 2012 7:24 PM
comment(s) - last by
German court rules Apple's FRAND licensing proposal is fair enough, would be illegal for Motorola to refuse
A German appeals court has handed Apple, Inc. (
) a major victory this week, at the expense of
) acquisition Motorola Mobility. The Karlsruhe Higher Regional Court ("Oberlandesgericht Karlsruhe") elected to stay a preliminary injunction by the lower Mannheim Court, an injunction which could have -- at least online --
banned sales of iPhones and iPads
I. iPad, iPhone Ban Would be Illegal Says Appeals Court
To understand the ruling you have to understand German patent law. In the European Union, different member states have different patent court systems, despite sharing a single unified intellectual property registrar.
In Germany, lower federal courts launch cases along two separate tracks -- an infringement track, and a validity track. The infringement track can ban (via preliminary injunction) a product or service, even if there's a modest prospect that a patent is invalid. The infringement proceedings are typically only stayed by a lower court if there is a "high likelihood" (70-80 percent) of invalidity.
By contrast, German federal appeals courts can stay the infringement proceedings (and potential product bans) if there's a modest (think 50 percent or greater) chance of invalidity.
In this particular case, the infringement track was paused due to a special type of invalidity concern -- invalidity not based on the patent being invalid, but invalidity based on it being illegal to litigate with the patent under current licensing rules.
German authorities have ruled that it would be illegal for Motorola to seek a sales ban on the iPhone and iPad, given Apple's relatively fair licensing proposal. (Pictured: Munich's Apple store) [Image Source: Apple Insider]
The Karlsruhe court ruled that Apple's latest licensing proposal was fair and reasonable enough that Motorola was legally obligated to license the patent to its rival. The key point in the case was that the patents in the case (which Apple was found to infringe by lacking a license) were 3G standards patents governed by fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) licensing terms.
Motorola made it clear it had a lot of issues with Apple's licensing proposal, and for a time the appeals court appeared to be on its side. But via an "iterative approach", Apple crafted a licensing proposal, which was the appeals court felt was fair enough,
. To refuse to license under the terms of that revised offer would be a clear antitrust violation, the German appeals court stated.
A translated ruling is available
II. Growing Headaches for Motorola, Google
Some experts (such as
blogger Florian Mueller) are saying that this loss is especially painful for Google/Motorola as the German court system is relatively friendly to FRAND patent holders using the standards patents to litigate against other FRAND standards holders.
As Apple is also involved in some FRAND patents, the German court was more receptive to Motorola's claims that other international courts might be; a perspective originally praised by Google.
Motorola Mobility's efforts to litigate with 3G FRAND patents aren't working out very well.
[Image Source: Trak]
The loss adds to the cloud floating over Motorola and Google, as a European Union probe into potential FRAND patent abuse continues. Motorola is fighting a two-front war against Apple and Microsoft Corp. (
). Last week Microsoft
filed an EU complaint
against Motorola, claiming it was committing antitrust violations by refusing to license certain FRAND patents.
III. Battle is Far From Over
While Motorola's litigious efforts against Apple are significantly weakened by the ruling, all is not lost for the phonemaker. Motorola has a
non-FRAND ban on the iCloud's push email in Germany
, which is likely to be enforced for at least a year until the appeal is heard. Unlike the iPhone/iPad ban, the appeal is unlikely to be expedited as the case does not share the same compelling FRAND questions.
could be banned by April
if it does not adopt a new unlock mechanism, following a German judge's decision that Motorola's lock graphic violated Apple's pair of patents [
] on a swipe unlock. Motorola stands a good chance of getting this overturned at the appeals level, given the
amount of prior art
. Such prior art was
used to toss out similar claims in the Netherlands
, where invalidity and infringement proceedings are lumped together into a single track.
Motorola's forbidden swipe to unlock gesture [Image Source: YouTube]
However, like Apple with the iCloud ban, Motorola must likely wait almost a year to get the decision tossed, as it is a non-FRAND issue. Motorola will likely be forced to implement
alternative unlock gestures
. Samsung Electronic Comp., Ltd. (
) -- threatened with a similar German ban -- has already done this, putting in place a circular slide to unlock motion.
While the new unlock is clunky, it is likely to prevent Apple from being able to ban the company's products from the market, and may have the added perk of encouraging customers to use Android's more secure built-in Grid Unlock (which was not found to be infringement in Germany to date).
In the long run it's anybody's guess what could happen in Germany. An appeal could allow Motorola to (re)enforce its FRAND-based iPad/iPhone ban, if the first appeals court decision is overturned. Motorola could even invalidate Apple's swipe-to-unlock IP. Alternatively, Motorola could see its iCloud victory nullified and be forced to maintain painful user interface changes, should things go wholesale in Apple's favor.
FOSS Patents 
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
2/28/2012 3:06:43 AM
That the courts would reach this decision is exactly what I've been telling you all on various articles.
'Slide-to-unlock' may be a contentious patent, but at least it's not a FRAND patent.
Companies have obligations which come with FRAND patents which mean they have to be more reasonable with those than non-FRAND patents, such as 'slide-to-unlock'. This is because FRAND patents are necessary to meet standards and to ensure interoperability, whereas non-FRAND patents aren't. Motorola was always going to get into trouble over this.
“So far we have not seen a single Android device that does not infringe on our patents." -- Microsoft General Counsel Brad Smith
German Lawsuit Loss Forces Apple to Cut Verboten iPad, iPhone Feature
February 24, 2012, 11:08 AM
Motorola Demanded $22.50 Per Windows Laptop, Microsoft Complains to EU
February 23, 2012, 4:30 PM
Analysis: Neonode Patented Swipe-to-Unlock 3 Years Before Apple
February 20, 2012, 12:49 PM
Google Now Has Two New Unlock Patent Applications to Counter Apple's IP
February 17, 2012, 8:50 PM
German Judge Bans Androids for Swipe-Unlocking, Despite Prior Art
February 16, 2012, 7:11 PM
Samsung Sees Decline in Share, Shipments in a Growing Smartphone Market
July 30, 2014, 9:43 AM
UK Drivers Must Now Give Their Cell Phones to Police After a Crash
July 29, 2014, 4:37 PM
Ford to Switch 3,300 Employees from BlackBerries to Apple iPhones by Year's End
July 29, 2014, 2:08 PM
Quick Note: Hilton Hotels to Use Smartphones as Room Keys, for Check-In/Check-Out
July 29, 2014, 12:53 PM
Verizon Wireless to Receive Exclusive "HTC One (M8) for Windows" Smartphone
July 29, 2014, 9:13 AM
Report: Microsoft's Chinese Offices Raided
July 28, 2014, 9:16 PM
Most Popular Articles
Facebook Will Force Android, iOS Users to Use Messenger App This Week
July 29, 2014, 11:26 AM
Sony's Xperia Z3 Gets Detailed in Leaked Photos
July 25, 2014, 2:30 PM
Ford's Extensive Use of Aluminum in '15 F-150 Results in $395 Increase for Base Models
July 28, 2014, 3:02 PM
Report: Apple to Launch 12" Retina MacBook Air, 4K Desktop Product Later this Year
July 24, 2014, 4:33 AM
Pentagon's Priciest Project, F-35, Misses International Debut
July 25, 2014, 10:18 AM
Latest Blog Posts
Space Terrorism is a Looming Threat For the United States
Apr 23, 2014, 7:47 PM
Facebook Aims to Provide Internet to "Every Person in the World" with Drones, Satellites
Apr 1, 2014, 10:20 AM
Retail Mobile Sites Experience Outages in Light of Simplexity's Bankruptcy
Mar 14, 2014, 8:48 AM
Tesla vs. BMW: Who Has the Safer EV?
Feb 1, 2014, 2:56 PM
Justice Leaks Details of Next HTC One Two Flagship Phone
Dec 5, 2013, 4:04 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information