backtop


Print 69 comment(s) - last by retrospooty.. on Feb 27 at 2:40 PM

Push-email is likely gone from the iCloud for at least a year

It is a small thing.  But as Apple, Inc. (AAPL) well knows, it is the little things that sell a product.

I. Bye Bye Bye

Apple had proudly unveiled the iCloud in mid-2011.  The service offers photo streaming, documents "in the cloud", automated backups, and push email/calendar/contacts.  Well, for Germany, Europe's third largest tablet and smartphone market, the good times are over, as the push email functionality is officially banned.

After new Google Inc. (GOOGacquisition Motorola Mobility secured a preliminary injunction just weeks ago in German court, Apple failed to convince a judge to inflate the bond.  As a result, Motorola paid the bond to carry through with the ban.  Some sources are estimating that bond could have cost around €100M ($134.1M USD).

iCloud ban
The iCloud's core push-email is verboten in Germany. [Image Source: 9 to 5 Mac]

Left with little recourse, Apple was left doing the same thing it had forced Android phonemakers to do -- remove features.  To recap, Apple has already forced several Android phonemakers to remove the "bounce" animation from their smartphones, and degrade the quality of scrolling in their gallery.  Those concessions come after preliminary injunction losses in regions such as the Netherlands.  And in Germany Apple has even banned Motorola and Samsung Electronics Comp., Ltd. (KS:005930) from using unidirectional slide-to-unlock, forcing them to use a clunky spiral motion unlock screen.

Apple writes to its German fans the bad news:

Due to recent patent litigation by Motorola Mobility, iCloud and MobileMe users are currently unable to have iCloud and MobileMe email pushed to their iOS devices while located within the borders of Germany.

Affected customers will still receive iCloud and MobileMe email, but new messages will be downloaded to their devices when the Mail app is opened, or when their device periodically fetches new messages as configured in iOS Settings. Push email service on desktop computers, laptop computers, and the web is unaffected, as is service from other providers such as Microsoft Exchange ActiveSync.

Apple believes Motorola's patent is invalid and is appealing the decision.

Apple's calendar and contacts syncing will continue to function as normal in iCloud and MobileMe, despite the loss of push email.

II. Why Was the iCloud Feature Banned, and What Is Next?

The device maker faces an uphill struggle from here on out.  Like many of Apple's patents that it's litigated with, Motorola's push email patent may be invalid due to prior art or other issues (novelty, etc.).  

In the U.S., a lower federal courts judges can ban a product or service via preliminary injunction if they feel that:

a) The described product or service clearly violates the patent

b) There is not a "high likelihood" that a patent is invalid.

The German court system works slightly differently, but the end result is the same.  In Germany infringement proceeds along one track, while validity proceeds along a second, parallel track [source].  A judge can pause (stay) the infringement proceedings to wait for the conclusion of the validity, but only if there is a "high likelihood" of their validity.

Again, both systems rely on the premise of a "high likelihood" of invalidity, which is typically defined at somewhere around 70 to 80 percent.  Of course this is wholly subjective, meaning how one judge might rule could vary substantially from what another judge might rule.

For now Apple's iPads and iPhones have been crippled of a key feature, much as Apple has crippled its competitors. Apple's next soonest hope of killing the painful ruling comes when it pleads its case before the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court, a German appeals court.  The appeals court has a lower standard of invalidity to grant a stay -- it can grant a stay if it feels that there's over a 50 percent chance of invalidity.

Angry iPhone owner
iPhone owners must live with the ban, likely for at least a year. [Image Source: Tech Axcess]

However, the issue for Apple is that the appeals court likely won't hear the case for at least a year -- ironically, a delay which may in part be lengthened due to all the appeals Apple has generated in its its own injunction wins over Android phonemakers.  And, of course, there's no guarantees that the appeals court will even see the patent as 50 percent or more likely to be invalid.

The Android v. Apple patent dispute is increasingly looking like   a stalemate of growing attrition.  Everyone is losing -- especially the customers -- as features disappear from both sides' products.  And there's little sign that the leadership on either side is willing to offer an end to the conflict.

Note 1:

The higher invalidity standard is in major contrast with other EU nations, such as the Netherlands and the United Kingdom.

Note 2:

The push-email patent used in this case is not a patent promised under the "fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory" (FRAND) rules.  Thus, unlike some other recent rulings -- such as a German ban on online iPad/iPhone sales -- Motorola stands no risk of getting in trouble for FRAND abuse for its effort (as, again, the patent is not FRAND).

Note 3:

The patent involved in this ruling is 
EP (European Patent) 0847654 (B1).  The U.S. counterpart: U.S. Patent No. 5,754,119, which covers a "multiple pager status synchronization system and method".

Source: Apple



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

RE: Dear Apple, What goes around, comes around.
By testerguy on 2/25/2012 5:19:46 AM , Rating: -1
quote:
I love how your mind works. Apple does it and its fine. Google uses Moto's patents and its an "attack dog" Google is doing nothing but defending itself from Apple's relentless unwarranted, baseless attacks.


Most ridiculous comment ever (even for you)..

1 - Tony never said that it's 'fine' when Apple does it.
2 - Tony never said that 'attack dog' meant that it wasn't OK to do.
3 - YOU are excusing this using logic of 'defending itself' - which is the most absurd logic ever. Retaliation does not justify a frivolous lawsuit.
4 - Therefore YOU are the only one with bias, saying that it's OK for Google to patent something as obvious as PUSH email - whereas when Apple patents slide-to-unlock, you're up in arms.

Typical anti-apple crier.

Me, on the other hand? Just like in the Slide-to-unlock case, I've not voiced any opinion on which way I believe the court case should go. Consistency - learn.


RE: Dear Apple, What goes around, comes around.
By retrospooty on 2/25/2012 8:01:33 AM , Rating: 2
Right, you voice no opinion either way, just happen to defend Apple vigorously regardless of the issue and that is your sole purpose here, because you dont post in any subject other than Apple.

Thanks for showing me what biased is. At least Tony has other things he comments on. You created your ID only to troll for Apple. This shows the emptiness of your sad life, so just move on. I'm not hearing ya.


By Cheesew1z69 on 2/26/2012 10:32:02 AM , Rating: 2
QFT! ;)


RE: Dear Apple, What goes around, comes around.
By testerguy on 2/27/12, Rating: 0
By Cheesew1z69 on 2/27/2012 10:13:01 AM , Rating: 2
quote:
I haven't defended anyone
Keep telling yourself that....it doesn't make it any less true.

quote:
And as ever, of course, you completely failed to recognise or address your evidenced bias.
Neither do you...

quote:
Feel free to quote which comment of mine 'vigorously' defended Apple in this legal case, though
All of them....as I pointed out before...but you are to dumb to realize this...but it's ok, special people are people too...


By retrospooty on 2/27/2012 11:06:50 AM , Rating: 3
"Whether or not I post in other articles is irrelevant"

Actually it's totally relevant. It shows that you created your ID at AT/DT for the sole purpose to defend Apple. It shows your bias, it shows your agenda and it shows you cant be objective. For anyone to take time out of life for such a petty purpose shows alot in itself. You are a child, that's about all there is to say.


"There's no chance that the iPhone is going to get any significant market share. No chance." -- Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer














botimage
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki