Motorola Fails to Score the Hat Trick, Losing to Apple at Last in Germany
February 10, 2012 1:15 PM
comment(s) - last by
Loss is setback, but Motorola's hopes of forcing licensing under threat of a ban are still alive
Motorola Mobility has lost a 3G patent claim against Apple, Inc.'s (
) in Mannheim regional court in Germany. The preliminary loss is the first for the Android phonemaker, who thus far has
done very well
in German court.
patent rumble with Samsung
Electronics Comp., Ltd. (
) has drawn the bear's share of the tech community's attention -- thanks to the fact that the companies are
vying for the number one spot
in smartphone sales. But Apple is fighting a quieter, but equally important legal war against Motorola Mobility.
I. Key Decisions Have Apple on the Ropes in Germany
Motorola, who may soon be owned by Android maker Google Inc. (
, is fighting a particular fierce legal battle in Germany, where it's scored two key victories -- one against Apple's use of 3G signal technology, and one against Apple's use of push email via the iCloud.
for refusing to license to Apple standards patents -- patents governed by the "
fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory
" (FRAND) rules of mandatory licensing -- instead looking to ban Apple's products with them (Samsung defends this approach, saying it is not possible to reasonably license when Apple is trying to ban its products).
By contrast Motorola has made a big point of making it clear that it does not
to ban Apple's products, unless it has to, and that its main objective is to get Apple to pay it a "fair and reasonable" rate for its 3G-related patents.
Motorola, unlike Samsung, hopes that it can negotiate licensing terms with Apple for its 3G FRAND patents, but has allegedly been met with resistance. [Image Source: Device Mag]
This approach is identical to
that taken by Microsoft
) on certain operating system technologies, which it has
to license and is
currently suing Motorola
for refusing to license.
Motorola defines this rate as 2.25% of the net-selling-price (to carriers, not to customers) of the 3G iPhone and iPad models. Apple appears to feel that this rate is not "fair", and further that it' worthwhile to try to make Motorola prove its case before agreeing to licensing.
It is hard to objectively determine whether this rate is truly "fair" as the terms of most licensing agreements are not made public, and further likely vary on a case-by-case basis.
Motorola has gone a long ways towards providing such "proof", winning two German rulings against the Cupertino company, thus far. The iCloud is currently banned in Germany due to one of those rulings, preventing some Germans from receiving push email service. A ban on the sales of iPads and iPhones using 3G -- originally set to go into place last week -- is set to resume soon, after a brief respite was handed down from the higher Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court.
II. Motorola Gets First Taste of Defeat
But in its latest case, Motorola was not as fortunate. It claimed that Apple infringed claim 9 of
a "method and system for generating a complex pseudonoise sequence for processing a code division multiple access [CDMA] signal".
Motorola claimed a similar technology appeared in the iPhone, given that it used modern 3G signals. The point of contention here was whether there were potential alternative implementations.
Typically with a FRAND patent relating to wireless communications, it's restricted because there's only
optimal way to handle a certain signal problem, within a certain specification. Hence allowing a company to deny its competitors access would stifle the industry and potentially create a monopoly.
But here Apple essentially argued the "FRAND" patent wasn't FRAND. While it offered no direct evidence to support that its phone implemented a different algorithm, it essentialy argue that the burden of proof was on Motorola to find and demonstrate the algorithm was being used in the iPhone and iPad's hardware or software.
Interestingly, the German judge bought this novel defense. He took issue with the use of the word "means" in the patent,
. He said that since the patent was demonstrating means, it was effectively not a standards (FRAND) patent, but rather an implementation patent. Thus Motorola was trying to prove the wrong point; looking to prove standards use versus looking to prove a common implementation.
The Mannheim Regional court in Germany [Image Source: Borgelt & Partners]
The ruling could have important implications locally in Germany, as it opens the door for further dissection of FRAND patents.
The judge dismissed the case, as a results, so there's no "round two" for Motorola, in this case, barring an appeal to the Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court.
Following the Mannheim rejection this week, Motorola is 2-for-3 in patent cases it has brought against Apple in the EU's third largest smartphone and tablet market. Apple is working very hard to either prove the invalidity of Motorola patents in these victories, or win an appeal on the ground that it is not infringing on them.
Either way, if even one survives, it could force Apple to pay licensing fees to Motorola. The last thing Apple wants is to be stuck playing Samsung to Motorola's Microsoft. Its victory this week took it one step closer to unwinding Motorola's string of victories. But there's a long hard road ahead if it hopes to emerge fully victorious.
A fourth case will be ruled on April the 13th -- a Friday. That case is tied to the two victorious ones -- the GPRS (3G) patent case and the push-email patent case. Motorola originally won when Apple no-showed in November, but in a second trial in court last week Apple was determined to make a deal.
In exchange for acknowledging the validity of Motorola's GPRS FRAND patent, Apple would want to reserve the privilege to challenge future applications on the basis of "patent exhaustion" -- meaning that it would likely not have to pay royalties on the iPhone 4S, despite its use of 3G. The court wasn't buying this argument, but the final ruling won't come until April 13.
An injunction could force Apple into the one thing it most wants to avoid -- a royalties sharing arrangement.
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
RE: Dailytech using Chinese writers?
2/10/2012 2:47:10 PM
Sorry for the double post....network error....
"Well, we didn't have anyone in line that got shot waiting for our system." -- Nintendo of America Vice President Perrin Kaplan
German Appeals Court Approves Galaxy 10.1N, Tells Apple "Deal With It"
February 9, 2012, 6:01 PM
Google's Motorola Mobility Purchase Approval Expected Next Week
February 9, 2012, 3:02 PM
Germany Bans Apple's iCloud; iPhone 4, iPad 2 Spared From Second Ban
February 3, 2012, 5:24 PM
Apple Beat Android-Leader Samsung in 2011 Global Smartphone Sales
February 2, 2012, 7:23 PM
EU Nails Samsung With Formal Investigation Over 3G Patent Abuse
January 31, 2012, 9:32 AM
Retiree Sues Apple For $7,500 for Wiping Honeymoon Photos From His iPhone
November 30, 2015, 10:23 AM
iPhone 7 May Pack 3-4 GB Memory, More Storage; 4-Inch Comeback is Rumored
November 20, 2015, 10:12 PM
OnePlus One, OnePlus 2 Will Receive Android Marshmallow in Q1 2016
November 16, 2015, 9:58 AM
Lenovo Whoa: Motorola Droid MAXX 2 and Turbo 2 Break Cover in Leaks
October 26, 2015, 3:12 PM
Leak: Apple Preps for First Real Android App Foray With New Apple Music App
October 24, 2015, 1:59 PM
Pepsi Smartphone? Empty Calories Coming Soon to the Midrange
October 12, 2015, 11:41 PM
Most Popular Articles
Free Windows 10 offer ends July 29th, 2016: 10 Reasons to Upgrade Immediately
July 22, 2016, 9:19 PM
Top 5 Smart Watches
July 21, 2016, 11:48 PM
Latest Blog Posts
Sceptre Airs 27", 120 Hz. 1080p Monitor/HDTV w/ 5 ms Response Time for $220
Dec 3, 2014, 10:32 PM
Costco Gives Employees Thanksgiving Off; Wal-Mart Leads "Black Thursday" Charge
Oct 29, 2014, 9:57 PM
"Bear Selfies" Fad Could Turn Deadly, Warn Nevada Wildlife Officials
Oct 28, 2014, 12:00 PM
The Surface Mini That Was Never Released Gets "Hands On" Treatment
Sep 26, 2014, 8:22 AM
ISIS Imposes Ban on Teaching Evolution in Iraq
Sep 17, 2014, 5:22 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information