Dutch Court Slaps Apple With Another Loss in its Anti-Android Crusade
January 24, 2012 7:46 AM
comment(s) - last by
EU court concludes that thorough review of prior art narrows Apple's design rights, vindicates Samsung
Apple, Inc. (
) has lost its latest round in its legal war against Android, as signs of a stalemate with Android continue to grow.
I. Android and Apple Reaching a Stalemate
All things considered, Apple should be pretty pleased at its recent results. It's managed to charge back to a
near tie in the U.S. market
, driven by pent up demand for a new iPhone, which was finally
fulfilled by the iPhone 4S
. Meanwhile Apple has successfully defended itself against arch-rival Samsung Electronics Comp., Ltd.'s (
in the Netherlands
, among other regions.
But that success has been soured by Apple's failure to win the legal fight it started.
On Tuesday, a Dutch court rejected Apple's appeal of a relatively pro-Samsung lower court ruling. The lower court ruled that the
numerous visual differences
between the iPad and Samsung's Galaxy Tab tablet line were compelling enough to rule out design infringement -- a key point Apple was trying to prove.
win on a single point
in the lower court case --
European Patent 2,059,868
-- a patent which covers features within a photo gallery app, features that the court found were too similar in Samsung's Android Gallery (pictures) app. This similarity was removed via a simple software update that overhauled the Gallery app, allowing Samsung to resume sales of its smartphones and tablets.
Lawyers for Apple filed an appeal, hoping a higher court might change their mind
about the design difference. But Apple had no such luck.
II. Dutch Court Complains Germans Didn't Consider Enough Prior Art
The Dutch court found Apple's design patent to be perfectly valid, but ruled that given the existence of at least two similar devices at the time of its launch (prior art), its design scope was narrow, and hence was not eligible for a blanket patent on all rectangular slab tablets.
The Dutch court considered the following examples of prior art in reaching this decision, as noted in the
U.S. Patent Application No. 2004/0041504 A1
the Knight Ridder tablet
the HP Compaq TC1000
Canadian Design Patent 89,155
Japanese design no. 887388
Japanese design no. 1142127
By contrast, the Düsseldorf Regional Court -- who will rule next week on whether to grant Apple a new preliminary injunction against Samsung's new German-specific Galaxy Tab 10,
complete with reworked case design
-- only considered the Knight Ridder tablet at the TC1000 in its determination that Apple should be granted a broader injunction over all "minimalist" rectangular tablets. In other words, the Dutch court says its German justice peers -- and perhaps Samsung's German lawyers --didn't do their homework very well.
But signs that the German court may be ready to change its mind as the preliminary ruling found that
Samsung's redesign was sufficient to escape infringement claims
III. Quick Peek: Do You Think These Products are the Same?
In the past we've highlighted the differences in design between the iPad, and the Galaxy Tab 10. This seems an appropriate time for a refresher. The difference include:
Only Galaxy Tab 10.1 has a camera (compared to the original iPad).
The thickness in the design patent doesn't match the thickness of the iPad or Galaxy Tab (please measure this in an imaging software, in pixels, if you don't believe us).
Bezel sizes don't match between any of the three designs.
Connectors and buttons on the side are different.
Screen sizes and aspect ratios are different.
Only the iPad has a home button.
All tablets are clearly and unambiguously branded.
The back color doesn't match.
IV. The Impact of the Prolonged Court Battle
The Dutch court has now rejected both Apple and Samsung's initial claims. Apple
continues to file new claims
, but one has to wonder how long it will continue before it tires of wasting energy and effort in what is increasingly a losing battle. The same goes for Samsung. Expect the German ruling to be pivotal in the future of this legal war. A win could embolden Apple, but a loss would make the lawsuit crusade look increasingly self-destructive for the American electronics firm.
The Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 (original design) [Images Source: 9to5Google]
In many ways the lawsuit crusade is part of late Apple CEO and co-founder Steven P. Jobs'
. But one has to wonder as these suits drag on, whether customers will slowly grow aware of these actions and tire of Apple's litigious ways.
Apple's desire to try to circumvent competition via the courts is puzzling, given that it seems to be doing alright already in terms of recent sales versus Android. While its suits have helped to
stifle the proliferation of Android tablets
slightly, they have mostly just left the Cupertino, Calif. company with
legal bills and negative publicity
. This stands in sharp contrast to Microsoft Corp.'s (
friendlier pro-licensing approach
, which has earned fat payouts on the wave of Android phonemakers' --
-- sales successes.
de Rechtspraak (Dutch Appeals Court)
This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled
1/24/2012 3:30:12 PM
So, it's pretty well known around here Picard had his ready-room tablet back when S:NG was produced in the early 1990's. And there was another tablet concept way before that in sci-fi that I can't recall. Since no one else mentioned it yet it looks like Harrison Ford's character is holding some type of mini-tablet in Blade Runner (for those who have The Final Cut version it's exactly at 00:16:00 - other versions should be fairly proximate, Deckard is sitting shotgun to Gaff as they ride towards Tyrell Corp). Or maybe it's supposed to be a memo pad, I think it's more fitting to have a tablet in the same camera shot of the hovercar interior ;)
I just can't figure out what Apple intends to do with the obvious arguments that were covered in another court case-- that being: human-beings have mostly similarly sized hands; we use hands to operate machines; and, the rectangle is not an invention that can be patented. Therefore, there will be very few differences in physical appearance (not to mention weight/mass) for a product in order to be used by an average consumer.
Apple needs to invent real stuff of its own instead of being such a bunch of ripoffs that turn into crybabies that tattle-tale to the courts with dubious arguments.
RE: Prior art
1/24/2012 3:35:19 PM
btw, Harrison Ford's character is holding the object with two-hands the same way a table is held and almost looks like he's playing tetris or space invaders
(dang it, no edit)
"This is about the Internet. Everything on the Internet is encrypted. This is not a BlackBerry-only issue. If they can't deal with the Internet, they should shut it off." -- RIM co-CEO Michael Lazaridis
Samsung Loses 3G Patent Case Against Apple in Germany
January 20, 2012, 8:42 AM
A Cupertino Comeback: Apple and Android are Almost Tied in U.S. Sales
January 18, 2012, 1:07 PM
Apple Dusts Itself Off and Tries Again, Targets 10 Samsung Smartphones in Germany
January 17, 2012, 9:01 AM
Advisors: Apple Should Drop Patent War, Seek Alliances with Android-Based Phone Makers
December 29, 2011, 10:26 AM
Germany Becomes Latest Court to Reject Apple's Android Assault
December 22, 2011, 3:17 PM
New Reversible "Type-C" USB Plug Coming in Mid-2014
December 4, 2013, 10:38 AM
IDC Reports PC Shipments Will Decline by Double Digits in 2013
December 4, 2013, 10:18 AM
Canon EOS M2 Digital Camera Unveiled In Japan
December 3, 2013, 11:10 AM
Applebee's to Place Tablets at Each Table for Paying the Check, Ordering Food
December 3, 2013, 10:01 AM
Quick Note: Sony PS4 Sells 2.1 Million Units
December 3, 2013, 8:16 AM
UK iPhone Sales Show 5S Preference by Three-to-One Over 5C
December 2, 2013, 10:55 AM
Most Popular Articles
NSA Snares Americans' Porn Viewing Histories in Effort to Target Muslims
December 1, 2013, 9:00 PM
Coalition of 20+ Tech Firms Backs MRAM as Potential DRAM, NAND Replacement
November 29, 2013, 11:59 PM
Fed Up With Cheating OEMs, Microsoft Trolls Chromebooks in New Ad
November 27, 2013, 4:09 PM
Xbox? PCs? Mobile? Microsoft Wants One Windows to Rule Them All
November 25, 2013, 8:21 PM
Seattle Restaurant Bans Google Glass, Tells Wearers to "Just shut up and get out"
November 27, 2013, 10:27 AM
Latest Blog Posts
Global Cyber Espionage Concerns Reveal Growing Cyber Armies
Nov 29, 2013, 11:04 AM
Is The Period Becoming an Expression of Anger?
Nov 26, 2013, 2:02 PM
NSA and Congress -- You Will Never Kill the Constitution, It's an Idea
Nov 10, 2013, 2:00 PM
AT&T Explores $100B+ USD Deal to Acquire Vodafone's European Operations
Nov 4, 2013, 7:34 AM
U.S. Army Developing Cyber, Electronic War Arsenal
Oct 31, 2013, 4:49 PM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2013 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information