quote: You're right, it only takes away the rights of the thousands or millions who might visit the offending website, only to find it shut down because of ONE offender/offense. Not to mention the website could be one that people depend on for their livelihood.
quote: Not to mention all the First Amendment issues this bill brings up. But I guess that's more 'hysteria' too...
quote: You say you don't support the bill, yet constantly cook up ways to interpret it as being legitimate and legal. It's NOT.
quote: There is no right to visit a specific website in the Constitution,
quote: However, I can remove myself from the fray and look at the law objectively and say that, according to my knowledge, it doesn't infringe on any Constitutional rights as it is written.
quote: And this is where you prove you don't understand the Constitution at all. At all! Whatsoever.
quote: Excuse me but I've already provided links, and I can find more, of experts who have FORGOTTEN more about the Constitution than you or I will ever know, who soundly disagree with you.
quote: You're being deliberately obtuse to the point of ignorance, sad to say.
quote: I am well aware that Mr. Tribe disagrees with me, but what Mr. Tribe proposes is that individuals, in their own capacity, are equivalent to states and the federal government, and they can run afoul of the First Amendment. There has been no case where the Supreme Court has ever stated this to be true.
quote: As I noted above, there is no Constitutional right to visit a website and I highly doubt the Supreme Court will ever say that there is.
quote: Constitutional law is so amorphous because the Constitution was made intentionally vague to avoid situations where Congress would be unintentionally denied a power necessary to govern.
quote: (yes, I know it is an attorney hired by the MPAA, but he is still bound by ethics)
quote: Now if you bring me a link to Erwin Chemerinsky, Kathleen Sullivan, or Gerald Gunther saying the law is unconstitutional
quote: Furthermore, I noted above that I don't like the law
quote: That's like saying because the Constitution doesn't specifically say I have a right to walk and chew bubble gum, that Congress can pass a law saying I can't. Again, you prove you just do NOT understand the Constitution and enumerated powers.
quote: Again, proving your ignorance. The Constitution is not vague at all. Not even close.
quote: Basically your supporting the same mindset that has lead up to the mess we have now. Interpreting the Constitution so the commerce clause, for example, can be cited as to allow the Government to do everything and anything. Even things specifically NOT granted to them in this document you call "vague".
quote: All of those people are JUST as respected and accredited and qualified as Tribe. Yet because they haven't spoken out on SOPA yet, and Tribe has, that automatically makes him wrong and my source not count? Man that's a terrific debate tactic you're using. I'll have to remember to try that sometime...
quote: This is someone who thinks it's "Constitutional" for Obamacare to force citizens into buying federally ran health insurance for christ sake.
quote: No. If you're against me on this, then you ARE supporting the law.