Print 73 comment(s) - last by retrospooty.. on Aug 25 at 9:03 AM

Former friends, turned bitter rivals, Google and Apple now own a virtually duopoly on the U.S. smart phone market.  (Source: Flickr)

RIM appears to be fading fast with the BlackBerry smart phone brand dropping over half its U.S. market share over the last year. RIM is rumored to be considering pushing a new OS -- QNX -- to its smart phones in a bid to revitalize them.  (Source: Smart Phone Mag.)

Nokia and Microsoft are looking to Windows Phone 7.1 "Mango" to revitalize their smart phone sales.  (Source: Engadget)

HP courteously recused itself from the market, to webOS fans' chagrin. The departure leaves Microsoft, RIM, Apple, and Google as the only remaining major OS makers.  (Source: Mobile Knots)

  (Source: NPD Group)
Google solidifies its lead, Apple remains close behind

When it comes to veteran market research firm NPD Group, Inc., the latest report [press release] on smartphones is more good news for two major players and more very bad news for a third.

I. Google and Apple's Gains are RIM, Microsoft's Losses

For Google, Inc. (GOOG) and Apple, Inc. (AAPL) the news is happy.  Google rose from a 33 percent market share in Q2 2010 to a 52 percent market share in Q2 2011 -- a 57.6 percent increase in market share which came despite its legal troubles [1][2][3][4][5].  Apple, resigned for now to play second fiddle to Google grew from 22 percent to 29 percent -- a 31.8 percent increase in market share.

The bad news came for Waterloo, Ontario-based Research in Motion (TSE:RIM) who saw its U.S. market share drop from 28 percent to 11 percent -- a 60.7 percent decline.  In the last year the phone maker has lost nearly half its stock value as well.  

RIM appears to be fading fast.  Things look increasingly bleak for the company, which is rumored to be preparing to push its new operating system -- QNX -- into the smartphone market in a desperate revitalization bid.  It's easy to draw analogies between RIM of today and Palm, Inc. at the start of the webOS era -- beloved by some loyal customers, but increasingly scorned by the masses.  The similarities run deep in that both companies followed the largely defunct first-party OS model, a sluggish pace of handset releases, and inferior hardware.

The study also showed troublesome signs for Microsoft Corp. (MSFT).  Windows Mobile held approximately 10 percent of the U.S. market last year.  But by this year its successor, Windows Phone 7, had only accrued approximately 1 percent of the market, while Windows Mobile hung on to 4 percent of the market.  In other words, Microsoft saw its cumulative market share halved.

However, unlike RIM, Microsoft has deep pockets to try to revitalize its sales.  And with the upcoming launch of WP7's first major OS and hardware refresh, Mango, which seems to have strong support from a number of top third party handset makers, Microsoft looks poised to turn the corner and become a viable third place competitor.

II. Motorola Dips, Faces Puzzling Outlook

In terms of individual phone manufacturers, the biggest loser was recent Google purchase Motorola Mobility, Inc. (MMI).  Motorola saw its total market share drop from 15 percent to 12 percent, and its share of the Android handset market drop from 44 percent to 22 percent.

It saw its market share gobbled up by Android rivals LG Electronics (SEO:066570) and Samsung Electronics Comp., Ltd. (SEO:005930).

NPD analyst Ross Rubin was enthusiastic about Google's acquisition, though, which he says is beneficial to Android as a whole.  He comments, "Google's acquisition of Motorola shifts the balance of power in the handset-patent conflict between Google and its operating system competitors. Android's momentum has made for a large pie that is attractive to Motorola’s Android rivals, even if they must compete with their operating system developer."

He adds, "Much as it did in the feature phone market in the RAZR era, Motorola is experiencing increased competition from Samsung and LG in the smartphone market. Closer ties to the heart of Android can help inspire new paths to differentiation."

Of course, the Google acquisition of Motorola Mobility appears to have been primarily motivated from an intellectual property standpoint, so it remains unclear whether it will give choose to give unique advantages to its first party feature phones at its third-party partners' expense.

III. What Will the Market Look Like Next Year?

Overall there's still a great deal of uncertainty in the market.  Hewlett-Packard Company (HPQ) did refine the picture a bit, but voluntarily removing itself (and the ex-Palm webOS unit) from the smart phone market.  

Looking ahead, though, it remains to be seen whether RIM will find a way to revitalize itself or will become an acquisition target for one of the more successful or deeper-pocketed phone makers.  Don't be surprised if RIM has dropped even further in market share next year -- or has thrown its weight behind Android or Windows Phone 7.

But the biggest two outstanding questions are how Mango will be received and what will be the outcome of the Apple-Android legal war.  The outcome of those two factors should play a critical role in determining what the market looks like next August, when we sit back and look at the results of Q2 2012.

In the wild card category Intel Corp. (INTC) still has high hopes for Meego and Mozilla is cooking up a smartphone operating system of its own.  Don't get your hopes up that either of these projects will have generated even enough market share to earn a blip on next year's report, though.

Comments     Threshold

This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

RIM lives, folks
By respighifan on 8/22/2011 2:39:30 PM , Rating: 2
The thing everyone seems to forget is that RIM has a unique position in that it still dominates in any enterprise where IT support is complex and privacy and security are paramount.

Further, it is still growing in certain international markets, so it still manages to be profitable while changing to a new OS - no small achievement that!

RE: RIM lives, folks
By Pirks on 8/22/2011 3:51:20 PM , Rating: 1
Also the new RIM handsets rock, they got rid of all the UI slowness of the previous versions of their OS, got a nice stack of prepackaged apps on their device (GPS nav, HTML5 webkit browser that's as fast and easy to use as iPhone 4's one, facebook, twitter, rss, social feeds, email, youtube, bing, etc etc) and their hardware rocks again, say hello to new 1.2 GHz ARM goodness with full OpenGL ES 2.0, hardware accelerated UI, 720p HD video camera and all the bells and whistles typical consumer is looking for. Plus their app store hit a billion downloads a few months ago, with 3 million downloads a day. Plus Playbook is selling like hot ckes in Australia ( ) plus BBM is a number one choice communication tool in UK, plus new QNX phone, new QNX NDK for Playbook, new Android App Player are all near the release stage and to be unleashed in next 3-6 months.

So yeah, I kinda respect what Mick posts here, but come on, give him a fair judgement. The guy knows absolutely nothing about BB as a platform, its strengths and weaknesses. He's an Android fanboy.

And why would you read BB news from Android fanboy? Mick is so predictable.

I checked out a few new BBs in my local stores, and picked a Torch 9860 yesterday. After comparing it to iPhone 4 and Android hadsets in the store I realized that RIM has actually made it happen - they caught up to iPhone in terms of slick UI, stylish modern hardware and nice/quality packaged apps. Sure the iPhone 5 will change that again but come on, BB catching up to iPhone at all? Who would have believed in that? Not me for sure. But one visit to my local wireless stores and... damn RIM is onto something.

So I'm just sayin' you guys take ramblings of this Android fanboy Mick with a grain of salt. Gotta try those nice new Bolds 99xx and Torches 98xx (both slider and full screen touch ones) for yourself before making a judgement. Don't trust fanboyish hater posts from Mick or Swash, these people are not objective at all. Go try the stuff for yourself! Don't be brand whores, okay? It's such a shame to be a brand whore, seriously.

RE: RIM lives, folks
By bplewis24 on 8/22/2011 4:54:20 PM , Rating: 2
When a RIM fanboy comments on RIM criticism by calling the author a fanboy, it doesn't hold much weight.

RE: RIM lives, folks
By Pirks on 8/22/2011 5:07:41 PM , Rating: 3
Still, if you decide to stay a brand whore, you risk to miss some good stuff, just because it doesn't have the sacred logo. That was my main point. All the rest about recent RIM releases is secondary to that.

So you can be a brand whore or you can go and try different products, your choice man!

RE: RIM lives, folks
By robinthakur on 8/23/2011 6:35:33 AM , Rating: 2
LOL my work handset is a BB Torch and my personal handset is an iPhone4. If I only had the BB I'd probably slit my wrists, it's terrible! There are a million different ways of doing everything and the OS is primitive in the extreme. It is still really slow, the gesture response is way off and the options are unintelligable and spread out through all the apps in what might as well be hidden menus. The KB is ok but I would rather use a functional touchscreen KB in all honesty. I've glanced at the Apps market, and the layout is horrible (surprise surprise) and the apps overpriced. Surprisingly, email is not that great with none of my folders in Outlook filtering through to my BB, if Outlook routes a message to a folder it just doesnc't show up on my BB! The hardware itself is well made (Screen is very bright but horribly low res), but the iP4 is an order of magnitude better. Are we talking about the same BB Torch?

RE: RIM lives, folks
By Pirks on 8/23/2011 12:36:56 PM , Rating: 2
Are we talking about the same BB Torch?
No, not the same. Your Torch is 9800 released in 2010, mine is Torch 9860 released in 2011. Yours is slider, mine is full screen touch device, no hardware keyboard. Yours uses slow clunky old OS 6, mine uses new much faster OS 7. Yours has no 3D hardware, mine has OpenGL ES 2.0 GPU with hardware accelerated UI on top. Yours is slow 600 MHz CPU, mine is mush faster 1.2 GHz CPU. Our phones are VERY different. I'm not talking about YOUR phone in my posts, okay? I'm talking about the NEW BB devices being released right now.

RE: RIM lives, folks
By Pirks on 8/23/2011 1:59:37 PM , Rating: 2
Here you go robinthakur, this is my new BB7 phone:

Isn't it lovely? ;) Must be VERY VERY different from your current old Torch 9800. You gotta play with one in the store and post your impressions here, I'd be very interested in them.

RE: RIM lives, folks
By wordsworm on 8/22/2011 4:02:21 PM , Rating: 5
It lacks one serious function that it used to have: hype.

My wife wanted a Blackberry for years. Then, it was the iPhone. Now, it's the Android via Galaxy tab. What a waste of money all that junk is. What does she want all that junk for anyways? So that she can show it off to her friends. Which is precisely why I'll never buy any of those hunks of junk.

I can see valid applications for these smart phones. I just think that most folks buy them to show off their gadgets to their friends. Of all the smart phone owners I've seen, only two of them really used the smartphone functions for any purpose. One guy ran his servers with one while the other relies on networking for his business.

"When an individual makes a copy of a song for himself, I suppose we can say he stole a song." -- Sony BMG attorney Jennifer Pariser

Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki