backtop


Print 7 comment(s) - last by Brandonhyl.. on Jun 25 at 11:32 PM


HTC EVO 3D  (Source: BGR.com)

HTC EVO View 4G

  (Source: Engadget.com)
Tablet fares slightly better than the smartphone, although neither is perfect

As we reported earlier this month, HTC is set to launch two new devices in Sprint's flagship EVO lineup — a smartphone (the EVO 3D) and tablet (the EVO View 4G) — on June 24. Both BGR and Engadget were able to get their hands on the devices for some advance reviews. While there are gripes with both devices (more-so on the smartphone than the tablet), both appear to have their merits.

First up, the HTC EVO 3D smartphone received praise from both reviewers for its physical build. While the new device is strikingly similar to its predecessor, its new aspect ratio (16:9 vs. 5:3) makes it a little thinner and easier to hold. BGR describes the feel as "incredibly solid and well-built," while Engadget says that it fails to convey the same sense of quality as the very similar HTC Sensation for T-Mobile.

The display also fails to live up to the Sensation's, BGR notes, although it is "pretty sharp, colors look great, and it’s decently bright." The 3D stereoscopic screen overlay hurts it in the realm of sharpness. Engadget praises the display, but notes that it fails to live up to the quality of the qHD display on the Motorola DROID X2.

Another design weak spot is the massive protruding cameras on the back, which are covered in either glass or plastic — likely to get scratched or dirtied up either way.

The EVO 3D ships with Android 2.3 Gingerbread with HTC's proprietary Sense 3.0 UI on top. The dual-core 1.2GHz Qualcomm Snapdragon keeps things running at a commendable clip. "Everything from the basic UI to the web browser to maps is utterly buttery smooth," Engadget writes. "There is no delay, no hesitation -- just pure instant tactile gratification. Still, there's no escaping Sense, and we're not fans."

As for that whole "3D" thing, it appears to be more of a lackluster gimmick than the next must-have feature. The fact that the quality of the 5-megapixel 3D cameras isn't great doesn't help the cause. "As for 3D, we're not convinced it's fully baked yet -- right now it feels like a gimmick, but we're willing to wait and see how it develops beyond the initial 'gee wiz' phase," Engadget writes, noting that even the original EVO 4G was capable of better shots.

While signal was better than average, both reviews note the poor sound quality of the speaker. 

And what really hurts the device is its poor battery life (despite a whopping 1,730 mAh battery). BGR was able to get a day out of the EVO 3D with moderate usage and no 4G. When the 4G antenna is switched on, that battery life quickly drops to 4-5 hours with even limited use. The 3D cameras also eat up battery more than normal, Engadget adds.

Overall, BGR was able to overlook its drawbacks and enjoyed their time with the device:

The EVO 3D is a better, faster, thinner, lighter, and more capable EVO 4G. ... After spending a week with it, I can confidently say this is my favorite Sprint phone, hands down.

Engadget was not as forgiving:

Ultimately, we've come to think of the EVO 3D as a Sensation with a lesser camera, cheaper materials, worse battery life, and without the ability to roam worldwide.

We won't dedicate as much space to the EVO View 4G tablet, simply because it is almost identical to the 3G HTC Flyer that we saw back in May (with the addition of WiMax support and some small cosmetic differences).

An excerpt from Engadget's wrap-up:

When we think about what made our week with the View so enjoyable, we keep coming back to the well-tooled ergonomics, bright display, and long battery life -- all things that warmed us to the Flyer.
...
The addition of WiMAX isn't enough to soften our criticisms of the Flyer -- even if you prefer the comfort of Gingerbread, this thing still needs more apps that are optimized to take advantage of that bright 7-inch display. With a chunky shape and no ETA for Honeycomb, the View 4G isn't the sexiest or most cutting-edge slate of the bunch.

And BGR's:

I love the form factor and absolutely solid build quality of the View 4G. It’s a top notch tablet, the size is great, and it’s lovely having 4G WiMAX data speeds wherever I go. My biggest gripe is that it doesn’t run Honeycomb yet.

It appears to be a commendable effort for both devices, although the tablet generally scored better marks.


Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

RE: 3D is not a bonus
By cknobman on 6/17/2011 9:23:43 AM , Rating: 2
I am a happy EVO owner as well. My EVO does absolutely everything I want and need it to right now and after seeing the mediocre reviews of the EVO 3D I have absolutely no desire to upgrade.

Only complaint is the stupid crapware HTC and Sprint put on the damn phone!!!!!!! HTC your removing for desire users why dont you show the EVO users the same generosity? (I guarantee if you did I would be a repeat customer!!! As of now I will be heavily investigating phones bundled unremovable apps before my next purchase and will be happy to ditch a HTC phone if someone else makes a model without the crapware on it.)


RE: 3D is not a bonus
By TheRequiem on 6/17/2011 12:28:10 PM , Rating: 2
I have personally seen and reviewed the HTC EVO 3D and while a lot of people or reviewers (a la Engadget) claim it's a gimmick, I don't think so. The 3D might not be overly supported to begin with, but the 3D Video mode is nice, so is the ability to capture your own 3D content and pictures. Also, this phone is realistically about 5 times as fast as the original EVO, the thing responds like it's on turbo mode on everything you do. Plus, the build quality is really high, not sure why it got docked for "cheap materials" on Engadget, this thing is rock solid.


RE: 3D is not a bonus
By The0ne on 6/17/2011 3:29:52 PM , Rating: 1
Well the future of 3D is not clear and that's why people are claiming it to be a gimmick. A incorrect term imo. But there are driving products on the way and hopefully the market will respond better. The services (software mainly) will improve as well, obviously, and that's a very good thing.

I would love to own a EVO but waiting on a good deal...like free hahaha I have yet to pay for a phone :D


RE: 3D is not a bonus
By idiot77 on 6/17/2011 5:22:31 PM , Rating: 2
It's only a gimmick because everyone seems to think it should be mature at launch.

You mean I don't have a pile of 3D apps, games, and widgets? Gimmick.

When I set up my first 802.11a with a parabolic dish and Type N cables everyone I knew said it was a gimmick, until I had the first broad band town.

It's all in the eye of the beholder.


RE: 3D is not a bonus
By The0ne on 6/17/2011 11:44:31 PM , Rating: 2
Yes, it's quite funny actually to read others stating that iPad has pretty much corner the market when the tech is still new. Very narrow minded if you ask me to say such things. Just wait til the end of the year when the 2nd iteration of the dual core gadgets come about, hopefully more polished.


"Can anyone tell me what MobileMe is supposed to do?... So why the f*** doesn't it do that?" -- Steve Jobs














botimage
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki