Print 96 comment(s) - last by mindless1.. on Oct 19 at 4:02 PM

2011 Chevy Volt
But Volt's true nature may actually be an improvement, plus early reviews are complementary

In the week when auto editors turned in their first reviews of test drives of General Motors' upcoming 2011 Chevy Volt, there's been a bizarre twist that's largely overshadowed these initial impressions.

In a wild twist, Larry Nitz, GM's executive director of electric and hybrid powertrain engineering, has revealed that the gasoline engine actually will drive the Volt mechanically.

Previously, GM had maintained that the Volt was a battery electric vehicle (BEV).  When the battery's 40-mile range (since revised to "25 to 50 miles") was nearing exhaustion, a turbocharged 1.0-liter 3-cylinder gasoline engine kicked in, supply electrical current directly to the batteries and motor to provide more than 200 extra miles in range.

That platform was known as "E-Flex".  But unbeknownst to anyone, GM was pulling a bait and switch.

Today, Mr. Nitz revealed that 
actual powertrain.  The Volt, it turns out, is not a BEV like the 2011 Nissan Leaf.  It is actually a plug-in hybrid electric vehicle (PHEV) like the 2012 Ford Focus or 2012 Toyota Prius EV.

The internal combustion engine (ICE) -- now a 1.4L 84 hp 4-cylinder design -- and the 149 hp permanent-magnet AC electric motor both feed into a planetary gear set and three electronically controlled, hydraulically activated multi-plate clutches.  The resulting automatic transmission is marvel of electro-mechanical engineering offering a blend of efficiency and power.  The entire powertrain is bolted together to minimize noise, vibration, and harshness (NVH) and reduce space usage.

Arguably this advanced transmission is much better for customers than what GM initially 
said it was offering.  As Ford Motor Company pointed out in our recent interview with their head of electrification, BEVs suffer from poor performance in cold or hot weather, as the battery's performance deteriorates sharply. 

So why the bizarre farce on GM's part in claiming its BEV was really a PHEV, when the actual design would be more beneficial to the majority of customers?  Mr. Nitz claims that GM had to deceive the public in order to secure its patents on its unique transmission.  Now with the patents in hand, he was free to go public with the new powertrain platform, dubbed "Voltec", he says.

Turning to what GM had intended to be the focus this week, 
MotorTrend and The Detroit News have taken their first drives in the upcoming PHEV and are quite enthusiastic.

The Detroit News writes:

After I drove more than 32 miles on electric power only — in a very un-eco-friendly manner — the Volt’s little engine began powering the car. This was the moment I had been waiting for: It’s one thing to power a car with batteries, but it’s revolutionary to have a gas engine supply the power to electric motors.
The succession of power is more seamless than a presidential election. The engine is quiet and keeps humming along. There’s never a glitch, a pause or a moment when the engine noticeably kicks on or off. For the most part, once the initial battery charge is drained, the engine produces the electric power to drive the motor. 

Most of all, there's nothing to adjust to in the Volt. My 75-mile trip used a total of 0.9 gallons of gasoline. But I would have been happy to drive farther. 

And MotorTrend opines:

The Volt is no sports car, but it blows Toyota's plug-in Prius away (9.8 seconds to 60 mph), and runs neck and neck with a 2.4-liter Malibu in acceleration and handling tests. Figure-eight performance is virtually identical at 28.4 seconds and 0.59 g, and the Volt's 119-foot stops from 60 mph are just 3 feet longer-impressive, given its 226-pound weight disadvantage and low-rolling-resistance tires. (The Prius weighs 376 pounds less than the Volt, yet it just matches its 0.78g lateral grip, trails both Chevys by 0.4 second on the figure eight, and needs 131 feet to stop from 60 mph.)

Based on these reports it appears that GM's "surprise" of the ICE hooking up directly to the transmission to drive the wheels seems indeed to be a good one.  On the other hand, many will likely dwell on the fact that GM pulled a bait-and-switch on the customer.  

After all, some customers really want an honest-to-goodness BEV and may now being a bit bummed that they instead ordered what essentially amounts to a souped up plug-in hybrid.  Others have been vocal critics of the vehicle (and GM in general) and will likely jump on GM's deception as a platform to attack the vehicle (and GM in general).

Perhaps GM was right -- they had to mislead the public to protect their intellectual property.  But the move was certainly a very bad decision in terms of public relations.  GM can only hope that the public settles down and comes to realize the bottom line -- that it's offering them a superior package than what it initially promised to deliver.

Comments     Threshold

This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

MPG is all that matters
By mattclary on 10/11/2010 2:13:33 PM , Rating: 5
end of message...

RE: MPG is all that matters
By lennylim on 10/11/2010 2:21:41 PM , Rating: 4
Don't forget the price. I think it matters a lot too.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Mojo the Monkey on 10/11/2010 2:47:11 PM , Rating: 4
Seriously. Without a new drivetrain tech in place, which might have satiated some early-adopter-technophiles, this is a WAY overpriced hybrid with numbers that are far below expectations for that kind of price premium. Fail.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Schadenfroh on 10/11/2010 5:57:58 PM , Rating: 5
Thanks to our government, you get to help subsidize that price.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By chick0n on 10/11/2010 10:55:24 PM , Rating: 2
Its called Government Motors for a reason.

Everything fails.

By therealnickdanger on 10/12/2010 9:08:00 AM , Rating: 5

Too big to fail.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By stirfry213 on 10/12/2010 1:25:35 PM , Rating: 2
Even subsidized, this product is WAY too expensive for what it is. There is nothing revolutionary about this product. I'm convinced this will be a failure, I just hope it fails before significant amounts of our tax payer dollars are wasted on this POS.

*wave hand*
This is not the car you've been looking for...

RE: MPG is all that matters
By sinful on 10/12/2010 7:59:37 PM , Rating: 2
You don't understand, the benefits will TRICKLE DOWN to you!

RE: MPG is all that matters
By spread on 10/13/2010 3:32:12 AM , Rating: 3
Golden shower economic theory.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Mojo the Monkey on 10/13/2010 1:46:14 PM , Rating: 2
This is priceless.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By mattclary on 10/11/2010 3:55:25 PM , Rating: 2
Agreed 100%.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By invidious on 10/11/2010 5:40:50 PM , Rating: 2
Total cost of ownership is all that matters if you are thinking with your wallet. After looking at the total cost of ownership of electric cars vs normal cars I was not impressed.

FYI I decided to buy a 2011 mustang convertible because how much fun you have with your money is more important than how much you spent.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By solarrocker on 10/11/2010 2:41:36 PM , Rating: 2
size would matter to me also, mean would like to transport a little more then a hamster if possible.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By RivuxGamma on 10/13/2010 2:56:54 PM , Rating: 2
Eff that. I don't want Richard Gere as my passenger.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Fenixgoon on 10/11/2010 2:44:19 PM , Rating: 2
I disagree - the reason why the volt was supposed to be so impressive (and warrant its price tag) was that it was a series hybrid, unlike any other vehicle to date.

Not that I'm in the market for the Volt, or any hybrid, but I'm either disappointed or angered by this announcement, not sure which.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By nafhan on 10/11/2010 2:54:46 PM , Rating: 2
And the reason series hybrid is supposed to be impressive was because it would supposedly use less gas... If they're meeting the advertised performance figures (which have never been completely clear to me) and not changing the price, it shouldn't matter what type of powertrain they use.
I will say that this is kind of weird, though.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Spivonious on 10/11/2010 2:57:14 PM , Rating: 1
Exactly. The Volt has become an overpriced Prius. Why won't we just let GM go out of business? They are incapable of producing anything revolutionary.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By MozeeToby on 10/11/2010 5:06:46 PM , Rating: 5
Ok, reading through the source article to make sense of what has all changed and it's not as clear-cut (at least to me it isn't) as the DT writers make it out to be. I'll try to make this clearer that the source did:

The volt has two electric motors, a drive motor which is the primary and a smaller secondary motor that kicks in at high speeds but also does double duty as the generator. If there's juice in the battery, the two motors work together to achieve high speeds. Where it gets interesting is if there isn't juice in the battery.

At low speeds, if the battery is depleted, the small motor disengages from the drive train and connects up with the gas engine to recharge the battery. Everything up through this point the Volt is working as advertized. At high speeds, however, the primary drive motor doesn't have the horsepower to power the car by itself.

At this point, the secondary motor/generator engages into the main drive train and begins to push the car as well. However it is continuing to function as a generator at this time, the energy that is actually turning the motor is coming directly, mechanically from the gas motor. At this point, the Volt is (rather confusingly) acting as both a serial and a parallel hybrid.

Drive Train <------ Primary Drive Motor
Secondary Motor <-----> Battery
Gas Engine

And yes, the arrows are important and accurate in the diagram, the secondary motor both charges the battery and acts as a mechanical pass through to drive train. This allows them to get away with less total weight and cost in electric motors (since the secondary motor is doing double duty as a generator). It also means that this does not break the drop in replacement idea the generator. Anything that can either A) charge the battery at a high enough rate that both motors can be run simultaneously or B) turn the secondary motor at the correct rate can be dropped in as a replacement.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Alexvrb on 10/11/2010 8:10:06 PM , Rating: 2
So basically it has the best of both worlds? True serial operation when the battery is juiced up, and improved parallel operation when the battery is down but you still need to haul butt? Nice!

Thanks for the explanation and especially for that diagram, Mozee. MUCH better than the WTFBBQ article above.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By priusone on 10/11/2010 8:13:24 PM , Rating: 2
Great job at explaining how the system works. I had wondered why the ICE wouldn't help power the rig while charging the batteries. Going from gas -> generator -> electric motor -> powertrain and not including the ICE into the power train sounded strange.

It would be neat be have an option that would prevent the ICE, while charging the batteries, from contributing to the powertrain just to spite those who are crying about GM making a smart move. Personally, I thought people salivated at the thought of power draining extra HP.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By ilkhan on 10/11/10, Rating: 0
RE: MPG is all that matters
By priusone on 10/12/2010 12:07:26 AM , Rating: 2
What part of the article or comments make you think that it must use the ICE? Don't go over the 30+ mile limit and all it should use is the electric motor.

People paid good money for Pruis's and without a major retrofit, could they travel 30+ miles without the engine kicking on? Yeah, hydrogen fuel cells will be great when we finally have access to them, and having more solar panels and more energy dense batteries will be awesome, but do we complain about a major automaker embracing electric vehicles or do we see the glass has half full?

As was stated in my other post, kudos to GM for making a vehicle that coulf travel 30+ miles without gasoline, and for way under $100,000

RE: MPG is all that matters
By topkill on 10/12/2010 2:31:13 PM , Rating: 3
You're confusing 30 miles with 30mph. What GM is saying is that when you get up to highway speeds the ICE kicks in to help turn the wheels because it is more efficient for high speed driving.

This has nothing to do with the all electric range.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Solandri on 10/12/2010 12:29:13 AM , Rating: 3
Even with this explanation I'm pissed. Part of the reason people loved the series hybrid idea is that the battery provides 100% of the actual propulsion. At which point you can replace the ICE with a fuel cell, or a bigger battery, or solar, or whatever else you want without changing the vehicle's performance.

The Volt can still do that. All that's changed is that instead of the electric motors driving the wheels directly, there's a drivetrain between them and the wheels. A secondary motor hooked up to the ICE is also connected to this drivetrain.

If you think about it, it makes a *lot* more sense to do it this way than the pure electric model people thought it was going to be. In the pure electric model, the electric motor drove the wheels - always. When the battery ran out of juice, the ICE would drive a generator which converted the mechanical energy into electricity, which would be sent to the electric motors, which would turn it right back into mechanical energy. You're probably looking at 80%-90% efficiency there tops, probably more around 75%.

The way GM is doing it, while the battery has juice, the car is driven purely by the electric motor. You lose a tiny bit of energy in the drivetrain, but it should be minor (they're typically 98%-99% efficient at transferring power). If the battery runs out of juice, the ICE gets a direct mechanical linkage to the wheels thus eliminating any conversion losses.

Bottom line is, the primary goal here is energy efficiency. The direct mechanical linkage between the ICE and drive wheels is more efficient than having to convert mechanical energy, to electric, back to mechanical energy. The only people who should be upset about this are people whose primary goal is the elimination of ICEs, even if it causes lower energy efficiency. Those people are not environmentalists, they're social engineers trying to make the world conform to their flawed (less efficienct) view of how the world should work.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By DominionSeraph on 10/12/2010 3:05:55 AM , Rating: 2
Does the system balance torque so the ICE operates at wide-open throttle to both charge the battery and aid the driveline? Because if it doesn't, while the mechanical linkage may be efficient, you're losing efficiency in the ICE.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Solandri on 10/12/2010 6:04:05 AM , Rating: 2
Yes, that occurred to me after I posted. But any decrease in ICE efficiency due to not operating at ideal RPM has to be less than the efficiency losses in converting the power to electric and back to mechanical energy. If that weren't the case, auto makers would be redesigning every ICE car in production to replace the mechanical transmission with an electric generator -> electric motor setup.

Since that isn't happening, it's safe to conclude the a mechanical linkage with sub-optimal ICE RPM is more efficient than an electrical linkage with optimal ICE RPM. Automakers have been trying for decades to obtain the holy grail of a continuously variable transmission. If it were possible to do that using a generator and electric motor, they'd have done it already. They haven't done it, ergo the efficiency losses in a generator -> electric motor combo exceeds the efficiency losses from running the ICE at sub-optimal RPM.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By ilkhan on 10/12/2010 4:01:22 PM , Rating: 2
What I read is that at highway speeds, the ICE uses some of its output to directly power the wheels, the generator doesn't put out enough juice to power the wheels at freeway speeds on its own without the battery providing additional juice. Thus the problem. It may be better for simplicity but it kills the concept of series hybrid.
Also as mentioned below, mechanical simplicity takes a huge hit this way.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By MozeeToby on 10/12/2010 5:04:05 PM , Rating: 2
Well, close. The generator probably does put out enough electricity to power both electric motors directly, the problem is that the second motor (the motor that is necessary to reach freeway speeds) is busy functioning as the generator. It simply isn't available to provide power to the wheels because it is busy charging the battery. So, since this electric motor already has a connection to the drive shaft (to help the primary at freeway speeds) and to the ICE (to charge the battery) they just hook up both connections at once.

So, if you had, for example, a hydrogen fuel cell that could supply enough electricity to charge the battery faster than both motors deplete it at highway speeds, you could drop that in as a replacement for the ICE. You just remove the mechanical connection to the secondary motor, make a software change to the gearing system, and everything else stays the same. You could even do the same thing with an ICE, but you'd have to bring along your own generator to make it work.

Honestly, except for a pretty big leap in complexity (and therefor maintenance costs) it seems to be a better design. Personally, I would have preferred a single drive motor and a direct serial connection, but this is, in a different way, a very brilliant design.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By MadJak on 10/12/2010 3:50:14 AM , Rating: 2
you will probably find that the ICE can still run at optimal power bands. There will be a planetary gear system that will either feed the power of the ICE to the Secondary electric engine for 100% power store to batteries, or bipass the electric engine to drive the wheels. Kinda like the toyota CVT. This is probably where the patent will be.

So the engine can run at a set RPM and sit in it's efficiency band, and have part of its power split to the wheels and/or part to generate power to be stored into the batteries. The ratio will depend on how much power you need at specific speeds and whether or not that can be supplied by the electric engines(s) or needs the ICE to boost.

By Thats Mr Gopher to you on 10/12/2010 6:11:16 AM , Rating: 4
Jason Mick FAIL
MozeeToby WIN

RE: MPG is all that matters
By espaghetti on 10/12/2010 12:44:16 PM , Rating: 2
Does this mean that I no longer need to plug this car in to charge the batteries?

I don't see that in your otherwise incredible diagram.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By MozeeToby on 10/12/2010 12:51:38 PM , Rating: 2
You never had to, even with the old way that it worked. If you want your 25-50 miles of all electric operation you'd want to plug it in whenever possible and charge the battery. If you don't plug it in, the ICE kicks in to provide both energy for the battery and, in the more recently released design, mechanical power for the drive train. As always, you can still drive the Volt everyday without plugging it in, you'll just use more gas that way.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By espaghetti on 10/14/2010 2:07:18 PM , Rating: 2
Thank you

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Marlonsm on 10/11/2010 3:03:41 PM , Rating: 5
In the article, in a 75 miles drive, 32 of which being electric the car used 0.9 gallons, it means 47.8MPG after the engine started.
Not a bad consumption, but to be honest, I expected more.
Maybe when battery tech advances and cars like the volt won't need to carry all that extra weight.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By MonkeyPaw on 10/11/2010 8:45:50 PM , Rating: 2
The guy did say he drove it pretty hard. 47mpg may not be so bad if he was dogging the crap out of it. If he was babying it, then yeah, that's not fantastic.

What I would like to know is the range of the vehicle. 230-250 miles on a tank is pretty bad if you do long trips a lot.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Reclaimer77 on 10/11/10, Rating: -1
RE: MPG is all that matters
By MozeeToby on 10/11/2010 4:09:45 PM , Rating: 3
Maintenance matters quite a bit too. An all electric drive train is relatively indestructible and having the gas motor only running at the perfect point of its power curve also improves reliability, putting that mechanical power directly to the drive train adds all kinds of complexity and presumably adds full transmission into the mix as well. It takes this from a design that is far simpler than a traditional auto to a design that is far more complex than a traditional auto.

Also, secrecy needed to protect patents? That isn't how the patent system works. If you publish, you're protected. If you don't publish and the competition comes up with the same idea (either via convergent design or a leak) you're SOL. His explanation makes no sense (unless he really thinks that the design is so groundbreaking that it was worth the risk just to get an extra 6 months of coverage at the end of the patent's life).

RE: MPG is all that matters
By Gungel on 10/11/2010 4:20:55 PM , Rating: 2
So why should I route the power from the engine to generator to the battery tho the electric motor to a transmission and than to the wheel when I can just go strait from the engine to the transmission to the wheel without adding all that loss of efficiency. I think it's actually great news for the Volt that we combine range extender and hybrid.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By dubldwn on 10/11/10, Rating: 0
RE: MPG is all that matters
By tastyratz on 10/11/10, Rating: 0
RE: MPG is all that matters
By MozeeToby on 10/11/2010 4:40:58 PM , Rating: 2
A) With a serial hybrid there is little to no need for a mechanical transmission of any kind. Depending on the electric motors used they can power the wheels directly, and a properly tuned engine can directly run the generator.

B) If the gas engine is only being used to charge the battery, it can be highly tuned to a very narrow power band. That gets more power out of a smaller engine, something that is only possible because the engine can always be running at the same RPMs. Being able to tune the engine to a narrow power band allows you to greatly increase the efficiency, enough to overcome losses in the generator and batteries.

C) A drive train that is taking power from two different sources (an electric motor and a gas engine) will be, by definition, more complex than a drive train taking power from only one. That makes maintenance more difficult and failures more likely.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By 91TTZ on 10/11/10, Rating: 0
RE: MPG is all that matters
By foolsgambit11 on 10/11/2010 9:45:57 PM , Rating: 2
Because, amazingly, it is possible to have less total energy transmission losses by going from generator to alternator to batteries to electric motor to simple electric transmission to wheels than having an ICE-to-transmission-to-wheels setup. It's all about how much more efficient a generator running at peak efficiency is compared to a engine tuned for direct propulsion (which needs a wider, but inherently less efficient, power band), coupled with the fact that the losses in each step along the electrical trail are smaller than the losses along the mechanical one.

To be honest, most of my (albeit lay) knowledge of serial hybrid systems like this comes from reading up on sailboat propulsion systems, which do have different torque/horsepower requirements (and user priorities as far as fuel usage and engine running time), so losses in a car's transmission for an electric motor may be greater, and the trade-offs in other ways may make less sense. But serial hybrids have been in use on some high-end sailboats for a few years now, I think.

RE: MPG is all that matters
By bug77 on 10/11/2010 5:41:26 PM , Rating: 3
Maintenance matters quite a bit too. An all electric drive train is relatively indestructible...

The drive train may be relatively indestructible (the Titanic was supposedly unsinkable), but the battery is not. That's going to have a huge impact on both the maintenance cost and resell value.

There's only one thing sure about EVs: they're not ready yet.

"If you mod me down, I will become more insightful than you can possibly imagine." -- Slashdot

Most Popular ArticlesAre you ready for this ? HyperDrive Aircraft
September 24, 2016, 9:29 AM
Leaked – Samsung S8 is a Dream and a Dream 2
September 25, 2016, 8:00 AM
Inspiron Laptops & 2-in-1 PCs
September 25, 2016, 9:00 AM
Snapchat’s New Sunglasses are a Spectacle – No Pun Intended
September 24, 2016, 9:02 AM
Walmart may get "Robot Shopping Carts?"
September 17, 2016, 6:01 AM

Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki