backtop


Print 37 comment(s) - last by Hawley Roddick.. on Jun 2 at 4:05 PM


This weekend a video showing Foxconn guards roughing up an employee also leaked, raising questions over whether Apple's demand for secrecy is leading to employee abuse.   (Source: Shanghaiist)
Is the real story here the suicides themselves, or the abusive working conditions revealed by the investigation?

Last week we reported on a shocking expose conducted by the Chinese newspaper Southern Weekly which revealed harsh working conditions at a Foxconn plant that assembles iPods, iPads, and more.  The poor working conditions were brought into sharp focus after a string of suicides at the plant, including one questionable death of an employee that lost an iPhone prototype.

On Friday another employee took their life, raising the death toll to 8 this year. And along with the report came a recently leaked video of security guards at the company's Beijing facility allegedly beating up an employee.

Many questions surround the suicides and their potential connection to employee abuse.  Among the most common questions is whether the Foxconn suicide toll is abnormal.

Many observers have noted that China has a high suicide rate.  This is certainly true.  China's suicide rates have been slowly falling for the last several years, but they're still among the world's highest.  In 2007 the rate was at 286,000 suicides a year.  That's about 21.4 people per 100,000 people.  According to the latest World Health Organization figures, this rate has dropped to around 13.9 suicides per 100,000 people.

Given that figure, it would be easy to assume that Foxconn's Apple plant would typically have a suicide rate of about 46 people a year, given that it officially employs over 330,000 people (some reports have put the true figure at closer to 400,000 people).

However Foxconn's own statistics raise more questions regarding the situation.  Foxconn reported only 3 suicide deaths at the plant in 2009 (in line with the premise that a well employed work force has a lower suicide rate).  There have been no widespread reports of suicides at Foxconn motherboard plants this year.

The rash of recent suicides comes as employees have been being pressured to work long hours to fulfill demand for Apple's popular iPhones and iPads.  Also there's the recent video and fresh reports of security staff antagonizing employees in wake of Apple's demand for unparalleled secrecy at the plant.  One of the three suicides that occurred at the plant last year came after security staff beat an employee who lost a prototype of the fourth generation iPhone.  Foxconn guards have also beat up reporters trying to interview workers at Apple's secret plant.

Apple's own recent internal audit complained that many of its suppliers were engaging in abusive working practices, including forcing employees to work unpaid overtime, and using child labor.  It did not tell which suppliers were found in violation.

It is important to consider that Apple is certainly not the only company whose products are manufactured by Chinese employees reportedly working in poor conditions.  Intel, Nintendo, Sony, Dell, Hewlett Packard, Microsoft, and Amazon are among Foxconn's other customers.  Nonetheless, the pressure in terms of secrecy at these facilities (and corresponding employee abuse) may not be quite as high.

At the end of the day, the question now becomes how to receive these numbers.  Are they acceptable given that they still seem better than China's population as a whole?  Or are they unacceptable given the reportedly hellish working conditions at the plant, that may be directly causing the suicides?  And regardless of that debate, should the true story here perhaps be that the workplace conditions at Apple's manufacturing partners border on abuse?


Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

Huh?
By icanhascpu on 5/23/2010 9:49:39 PM , Rating: -1
How is this an Apple plant again? Apple should cut ties and find a different hardware producer, and so should everyone else that gets goods from this plant.

But why are you calling it Apples plant (except a small part near the end), went that is horseshit? Where are the names of all the other companies that get parts or products from this place in your lame headline?

Oh that's right, its because the majority of the people that read DT don't like apple (Cant blame them) and its easy picking for you.

Talk about journalistic ethics. You're a coward, and you take tragedies like this and warp them to fit your fucked up journalistic ends.

OH WAIT, it was just a blog, disregard everything I said, right.




RE: Huh?
By quiksilvr on 5/23/2010 10:10:34 PM , Rating: 2
I suggest you do your research before going on a rant. Foxconn and Apple have been interrelated in the past and in this current incident as well.

Sun Danyong's supposed suicide in 2009 for losing the iPhone prototype.

The Reuters reporter being assaulted by Foxconn security on photographs they took on a public road.

Yes, we know Intel and HP and Dell have stuff made from Foxconn as well, but it's mainly because of all the Apple related incidents that it is referred to as Apple'c company. That and the fact that most Apple products are made there.


RE: Huh?
By leuNam on 5/24/2010 11:10:10 AM , Rating: 2
you're right! it's not apples plant...but...apples fruit.. sheesh...
OH WAIT, it was just a comment...left


"A politician stumbles over himself... Then they pick it out. They edit it. He runs the clip, and then he makes a funny face, and the whole audience has a Pavlovian response." -- Joe Scarborough on John Stewart over Jim Cramer














botimage
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki