 The new Windows 7 RTM bug isn't as show stopping as originally believed. It likely falls under the category of avoidable annoyance. Nonetheless, Windows 7 President Steven Sinofsky says the team is hard at work looking for a solution. (Source: ZDNet)
 Don't check the second option -- we warned you. That's the bugged chkdsk option (which is unchecked by default). (Source: ZDNet)
Bug isn't as bad as initially believed, Microsoft is taking steps to fix it
There's a big new bug in Windows 7, a memory leak found in the
Windows
7 RTM. While it takes a somewhat specific -- though not
entirely uncommon -- sequence of commands to trigger, it can hog all
the system's memory and reportedly has crashed some systems -- even
producing, reportedly, the infamous blue screen of death.
First
a followup on the bug. The bug is in the chkdsk.exe, a long
standing Windows utility that allows you to check and repair your
disks. In order to activate the bug you must run the utility
and then choose the -R option from the command line or the "Scan
for and attempt recovery of bad sectors" on the GUI (not the
default option). The bug only occurs when scanning secondary disks or partitions -- something a lot of users don't even have.
While this is a bit of a problem for system
administrators, it now appears that the bug isn't as bad as was
initially believed. Microsoft's newly appointed Windows
President Steven Sinofsky took the unusual step of responding
to one blog discussing the problem, Chris123NT. As
Mr. Sinofsky points out, "While we appreciate the drama of
'critical bug' and then the pickup of 'showstopper' that I’ve seen,
we might take a step back and realize that this might not have that
defcon level. Bugs that are so severe as to require immediate patches
and attention would have to have no workarounds and would generally
be such that a large set of people would run across them in the
normal course of using their PC."
This is definitely a
valid point. There have been such bugs in past Windows OS's --
such as the Windows Home Server bug that corrupted data occasionally
on a variety
of normal reads and writes. However, this is a utility that
most users rarely run, and requires the user to specially select the
second option. Lastly, it appears that the severity of the bug
varies -- on some computers it takes up only 90 percent of the
memory, on others it crashes entirely.
Furthermore, while the
biggest danger is likely that the flaw could be exploited by
malicious parties who gained user level access to quickly swamp a
system, again this isn't necessarily of show stopping variety.
A hacker could just as easily open 200 copies of Microsoft Paint,
which would also likely kill your RAM (with the nice addition of
causing more visual annoyances).
Mr. Sinofsky says the Windows
team is hard at work trying to track it down. He states, "Some
have reported (as above) that this specific issue repros and then
goes away with updated drivers. We haven’t yet confirmed that
either but continue to try. We just kicked off overnight stress
testing of 40 machines of variants as reported by FireRx. We’ll
see."
It looks like the RTM bug may be an example of an
out of control feature. Microsoft looked to give chkdsk more
RAM, reportedly to help it run faster on modern systems with a lot of
RAM. Some are speculating that this feature broke and it now
takes more RAM than it should. What's interesting is that if
true, this means that Microsoft is taking the opposite approach with
disk checking as it is with Antivirus -- the free beta of Microsoft
Antivirus had a smaller-than-average memory footprint.
A
fair prediction seems that Microsoft has a patch on Windows Update
for the utility by launch time and the users are minimally
inconvenienced. In the meantime, try not to select those
specific options in chkdsk.exe, no matter how tempting they seemed.
"If you can find a PS3 anywhere in North America that's been on shelves for more than five minutes, I'll give you 1,200 bucks for it." -- SCEA President Jack Tretton
|
Most Popular ArticlesWindows 8 Dates Leaked, Windows 7 Hits 10 Percent Market Share, IE 8 Now Top Browser February 3, 2010, 9:05 AM Former VP Says Microsoft is "Failing" Despite Windows 7 Profits February 4, 2010, 11:11 AM MIT Creates World's First Computer-Ready Germanium Laser February 5, 2010, 1:20 PM Apple Offers Bounty to Take Yellow IMacs Off UK Owners' Hands February 5, 2010, 10:20 AM Crucial's 6Gbps C300 Hits Stores February 22, Targets Intel February 3, 2010, 12:20 PM
|