The Pirate Bay was the world's largest torrent site; feeding millions of users downloading legally obtained and illegally infringed works. It was the latter that cause the admins’ home nation of Sweden to drop the hammer and announce conspiracy charges and other charges against the feisty pirates. The parties involved included Peter “brokep” Sunde Kolmisoppi, Gottfrid “anakata” Svartholm, Fredrik “TiAMO” Neij, as well as Carl Lundström, who hosted the site via his company, Rix Telecom.
The groups once had dreams of founding their own country, but the proud pirates fell, facing the legal fight of their lives. From telling the lawyers of the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) who were assisting Swedish authorities to "go screw themselves" to releasing intriguing figures that 80 percent of their torrents were legal, the pirates put up a spirited fight indeed. For a time, it seemed they had the prosecution on the ropes -- they had to alter their charges against the group, faced with difficulty proving their current case.
However, in the end it was not enough, and the Stockholm district court found the four pirates guilty of assisting copyright infringement sending them to a year of hard time in jail. To add insult to injury, the court also ordered them to give up their bounty, ordering SEK 30 million ($3.59M USD) in damages.
The three week trial concluded with a somewhat surprising victory for the prosecution. The verdict stated that the Pirate Bay leadership was guilty of "promoting other people's infringements of copyright laws."
The Swedish officials have discovered that their plans to place the feisty group behind bars might be put on hold though, as the group plans an appeal. The Pirate Bay states, "This will not be the final decision, only the first before the losing party will appeal. It will have no real effect on anything besides setting the tone for the debate."
Mr. Kolmisoppi (brokep) twittered this morning urging Pirate Bay fans to stay calm, and noted that there would be no interruption in their service or their fight against the charges. He wrote, "Nothing will happen to TPB, us personally or file-sharing whatsoever."
The leadership held a special press conference for the media at the Museum of Technology in Stockholm, Sweden. At the conference were Rasmus Fleischer of Piratbyrån, Sara Sajjad of Piratbyrån, Gottfrid Svartholm Warg (aka Anakata), Peter Sunde (aka Brokep) and Magnus Eriksson of Piratbyrån. Fredrik Neij (TiAMO) and the fourth defendant Carl Lundström were not in attendance.
A defiant Mr. Warg challenged Sweden's leadership to try to stop the site, stating, "What are they going to do? They have already failed to take the site down once. Let them fail again. It has its own life without us."
As to the order to surrender his supposed bounty, he states, "I already have more debt in Sweden than I will ever be able to pay off. I don’t even live here. They are welcome to send me a bill. I will frame it and put it on the wall."
Asked if he viewed his campaign as fight for technology, Mr. Kolmisoppi responded, "I think it is something in between actually. We have a personal liability for this, we have a personal risk which has some impact on our feelings. But definitely it’s not defending the technology, it’s more like defending the idea of the technology and that’s probably the most important thing in this case - the political aspect of letting the technology be free and not controlled by an entity which doesn’t like technology."
quote: Very cute, except for one small problem: there is no way, and almost certainly never will be a way, to determine mens rea.
quote: You can just as easily say that somebody who developed code for any given word processor had an intention to make it easier for people to commit plagiarism. And, like arguing for or against the existance of god(s), there is no way to prove or disprove that.
quote: where the best you could hope for is a he-said-she-said about what someone's intentions were (or were not).
quote: The guys at TPB can just as easily say they're just huge fans of Johnny Depp, and that's why they called their site "The Pirate Bay."