The topic of ISP data retention came up once again in the halls of Congress. A new bill, known as the “Internet SAFETY Act,” seeks to compel ISPs and anyone who hosts a Wi-Fi access point to log all information that could identify users, in order to assist police investigating child pornography.
Known formally under the full title “Internet Stopping Adults Facilitating the Exploitation of Today's Youth Act,” the Internet SAFETY Act is actually two companion pieces of legislation – one working its way through the Senate as S.436, and the other through the House as H.R.1076. Their sponsors are Senator John Cornyn and Representative Lamar Smith, and both are republicans hailing from Texas.
“While the Internet has generated many positive changes in the way we communicate and do business, its limitless nature offers anonymity that has opened the door to criminals looking to harm innocent children,” said Cornyn in a Thursday press conference. “Keeping our children safe requires cooperation on the local, state, federal, and family level.”
Both bills are virtually identical, and contain the same language. “[Providers] of an electronic communication service or remote computing service” will be required to retain “all records … pertaining to the identity of a user of a temporarily assigned network address” for two years.
Observers interpret the law to mean anyone who runs a network that assigns users a temporary IP address, internal or external – which would cast ISPs like AT&T in the same lot as coffee shops and corporate networks using DHCP.
CNET notes that both the U.S. Department of Justice’s position and legal definition of “electronic communication services” line up with this interpretation.
“Law enforcement officials had a chokehold on child pornography before the Internet exploded,” reads a Dallas Morning News editorial penned by Rep. Smith. “Perpetrators relied on the postal service to traffic their trade, and, by the end of the 1980s, postal investigators were winning the battle.”
“But the Internet changed everything. Now criminals can view pictures, download videos and watch the live molestation of a child. Pedophiles have, in effect, found a safe haven online.”
Citing the imagery of a TV crime drama, Rep. Smith wonders: “How many times have we seen TV detectives seek call logs of a suspect in order to determine who he has been talking to? What if the telephone companies simply said to the detectives, ‘Sorry, we get rid of that information after 24 hours’?”
Increased data retention favors a completely different set of suitors as well, says Electronic Privacy Information Center director Marc Rotenberg: the music and movie industry. Such a bill would “create new risk” for web surfers and peer-to-peer users, spawning legal fishing expeditions and lawsuits.
“It's a terrible idea,” said Rotenberg.
Perhaps spurned on by privacy advocates’ calls for service providers to have a shorter memory – a call that many have listened to – or the death of COPA, it appears the Internet SAFETY Act is the latest in a series of anti-child-pornography initiatives seeking to lift the veil on internet anonymity.
quote: +1 I'm also getting very tired of the government sticking its ugly nose where it doesn't belong. Whats that smell...
quote: Well get used to it. At least for another 4 years. We have a President who not only has the audacity to tell businesses how much their CEO's should make, but will end up federalizing a huge portion of our economy. You think he's going think twice about slapping massive restrictions and controls on the Internet ? To Obama and the Democrats, there is NO PLACE they don't think they belong.
quote: Their sponsors are Senator John Cornyn and Representative Lamar Smith, and both are republicans hailing from Texas.
quote: Before trotting out the usual Democrat bashing, you should reread the article. The sponsors of this bill are both Texas Republicans. So much for your claim that the grass is greener on the other side.
quote: How soon they forget the last 8 years...
quote: to rape it of it's natural resources in a war with zero international support?
quote: the guy launched an unnecessary, illegal,
quote: if he didn't pour money into the economy you wouldn't have a pot to piss in right now.