backtop


Print 97 comment(s) - last by TheSpaniard.. on Jan 22 at 8:27 AM

Cold periods had fewer storms, natural ocean cycles the largest cause of hurricane variability.

I've always been skeptical of the view that global warming leads to stronger hurricanes. The argument behind it seems overly simplistic -- hurricanes feed off warm water, so warmer sea surface temperatures will lead to more frequent and powerful storms.

Elsewhere in our solar system, the exact opposite seems true. Blisteringly hot Venus, for instance, seems to have extremely weak storm activity, whereas icy Jupiter has massive hurricanes that last centuries, large enough to swallow the entire earth several times over. This is only suggestive rather than conclusive, but clearly there's more to storm activity than just raw temperature.

Basic thermodynamics helps to explain why. Storms are essentially large heat engines. It's not temperature that drives a heat engine, but differences in temperature. Global warming, which warms the poles more than the equator, would seem to decrease the latitude-based differential that helps drive a hurricane's rotational energy.

So went my pet theory, at least— but no hard data supported it.

However, the other side had no hard data either. While climate modelers claimed global warming might strengthen storms, actual hurricanologists were adamant that no actual evidence existed. Some pointed to research on wind shear, which suggested that a warmer climate would reduce the conditions that allow hurricanes to form, despite warmer surface water.

In 2005, one hurricanologist, Emmanuel Kerry, broke ranks and claimed to have actual proof that global warming increased hurricanes. For this, Time Magazine quickly named him "Man of the Year". However, last year Kerry publicly recanted his view, admitting that his earlier work was flawed.

With Kerry's renunciation, hurricane scientists were unanimous in their view that global warming wouldn't lead to measurably stronger storms.

But could it do the reverse? Could global warming actually reduce hurricane activity? A pair of Chinese researchers now says this very well may be true, at least for some parts of the earth.

The researchers, using a new branch of science they call "paleotempestology", looked backwards through several thousand years of the earth's history. Using sedimentary deposits, core samples from caves, and other geological proxies, along with documented historical records of hurricane landfalls, they built the longest record of hurricane activity ever constructed. They then correlated it to the varying temperature at each period..

On the global level, the researchers found no link between climate and hurricane activity. Surprisingly, though, cold periods such as the Little Ice Age had the most hurricanes, at least in some regions, a result the team said "begs adequate explanation".

However, the study found a strong link between natural patterns such as El Nino and hurricanes, a clear pattern of rising and falling activity on decadal time scales. These oscillations, known as "ENSO", tended to suppress and enhance hurricanes on a regular cycle, with the cooler "la Nina" years having the most activity.

The research was published in the Chinese Science Bulletin, and can be viewed here.



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

RE: so this story says...
By omnicronx on 1/14/2009 12:42:51 PM , Rating: 1
I'm not a believer in man made global warming, but this article is pretty baseless. While there is no definitive proof that the oceans warming causes stronger hurricanes, trends for the past 15 years, in which we have had the hottest temperatures on record have had more hurricanes, and some of the strongest hurricanes on record. (which to mashers defense is not that big of a period). This being said, there is far more evidence that would prove that an increase in the earths temperature does effect the strength/frequency of hurricanes, than evidence that would prove otherwise.

Masher, we know that man made global warming is probably a myth, but you are starting to tread in areas in which short term data is far more reliable.


RE: so this story says...
By masher2 (blog) on 1/14/2009 12:51:01 PM , Rating: 4
I'm sorry if the article didn't make it clear, but this study, along with countless others, attributes the current post-1970s trend as being due to ENSO effects, rather than global warming. For instance, see this:

quote:
For many years, meteorologists have known that ENSO strongly affects tropical cyclone activity around the world. In some basins, El Niño events increase tropical cyclone activity (e.g., the central North Pacific near Hawaii, the South Paci fic, and the Northwest Pacific between 160 E and the Dateline) (Chan 1985; Chu and Wang 1997; Lander 1994). Tropical cyclone activity decreases in other basins (e.g., the Atlantic, the Northwest Pacific west of 160 E, and the Australian region) (Nicholls 1979; Revelle and Goulter 1986; Gray 1984). La Niña events typically bring opposite conditions.

Hurricane activity in the Atlantic basin is affected by ENSO remotely through changes in the Atlantic atmospheric circulation, largely through the vert ical shear wind profile...

http://www.aoml.noaa.gov/hrd/Landsea/lanina/


RE: so this story says...
By omnicronx on 1/15/2009 5:20:57 PM , Rating: 2
I'm just not convinced here. Correlating Pacific events such as El Nino to Altantic Hurricanes is far from conclusive evidence. Furthermore even if El Nino does directly effect hurricane activity in the Atlantic, its as a result of certain bodies of water raising in temperature and others cooling is it not? I don't see how this would increase the quantity and the severity of recent hurricanes. Its quite possible I am missing something here, as I do not quite understand your findings.
quote:
Atlantic effect An effect similar to El Niño sometimes takes place in the Atlantic Ocean, where water along equatorial Africa's Gulf of Guinea becomes warmer and eastern Brazil becomes cooler and drier. This is related to El Niño's effect on the Walker circulation over South America, which causes the easterly trade winds in the western Atlantic Ocean region to strengthen.


RE: so this story says...
By theendofallsongs on 1/20/2009 11:31:51 PM , Rating: 3
quote:
I'm just not convinced here
Google is your friend. Search "hurricane" and "el nino" and you get about 300,000 links showing you how this is true. Was that so hard?

quote:
It is now well-accepted that El Niño reduces hurricane activity in the Atlantic Basin
http://www.aoml.noaa.gov/hrd/Landsea/elnino/index....


"What would I do? I'd shut it down and give the money back to the shareholders." -- Michael Dell, after being asked what to do with Apple Computer in 1997














botimage
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki