Print 15 comment(s) - last by Skywalker123.. on Aug 23 at 1:51 PM

Voyager 1  (Source:
There are differing views as to where Voyager 1 is

NASA's Voyager 1 has reportedly left our solar system, according to a group of scientists from the University of Maryland (UMD) -- but NASA disagrees.  

The UMD team -- led by Marc Swisdak, UMD research scientist; James F. Drake, a physicist at the University of Maryland, and Merav Opher, of Boston University -- have created a model that they claim proves the Voyager 1 has finally left our solar system and entered interstellar space. 

In fact, the team believes Voyager 1 crossed into interstellar space July 27, 2012. But NASA researchers still don't believe Voyager 1 has done so. 

How is there such a huge disconnect between both beliefs? On NASA's side of the situation, Voyager 1 has recorded erratic shifts in solar particle and galactic particle counts -- and at one point, solar particle counts disappeared while galactic particles remained, which would indicate an exit of our solar system -- but the lack of directional change in the magnetic field makes NASA scientists skeptical of whether Voyager 1 has truly entered interstellar space.

The heliosphere -- which is a bubble of charged particles surrounding our solar system and is dominated by the sun -- has a heliopause transition zone that leads to interstellar space. This is a zone with unknown properties, but many believe that the loss of solar particles and the remainder of galactic particles is a sign that the craft has left the heliopause transition zone. A different direction in the local magnetic field is also a key sign. 

So how are there no solar particles, but the magnetic field's direction hasn't changed? Scientists believe Voyager 1 has entered a heliosheath depletion region, where it remains in a section of the heliosphere. 

However, the UMD team's model of the outer edge of the solar system may have a new solution that points to Voyager 1's exit of the heliosphere entirely. 

According to the UMD researchers, magnetic reconnection -- which is the breaking and reconfiguring of oppositely-directed magnetic field lines -- is the explanation. The team said that the heliopause isn't the split between inside and outside of the solar system. Rather, it's a "porous" structure that creates a set of magnetic spots, which are self-contained and appear in a magnetic field due to a "fundamental instability." Galactic plasma and cosmic rays are allowed to mix with solar particles through the use of reconnected field lines. 

Reconnection sites issue slopes in the magnetic field, where solar particles are known to decrease and galactic particles increase. However, the magnetic field direction doesn't change, and this is how UMD researchers explain what NASA is finding. 

UMD isn't alone in its way of thinking. In March of this year, a new study conducted by researchers at New Mexico State University in Las Cruces suggested that Voyager 1 exited the heliosphere on the edge of the solar system in 2012 as well. These findings were based on the fact that levels of anomalous cosmic rays (which are in the heliosphere) dropped to 1 percent from previous levels while levels of galactic cosmic rays (which are outside the solar system) increased to twice their previous levels during late August 2012. This was the highest these levels have ever been. 

The Voyager 1 is a NASA space probe that was launched in 1977 to study the outer solar system.

Source: Science Daily

Comments     Threshold

This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

On a side note...
By xrror on 8/19/2013 3:45:46 PM , Rating: 5
I still think it's amazing that a probe built around 1975'ish (when were they built?) is still functioning enough to give useful science return.

It should be interesting to see if New Horizons can hang in there long enough after it's main mission is over to do something similar. Lets's hope!

RE: On a side note...
By drycrust3 on 8/19/2013 4:28:09 PM , Rating: 2
I think the Voyagers are one of the greatest long term contributions to science by America. Even today, much of what goes into space has to contribute to a country's propaganda, but in the long term that effort was of almost no value at all.
As far as I know neither Russia nor China have launched any probes like what America has, let alone the share number of probes America sent out. To be fair, Russia did send a few robots to the moon at the time of Apollo 11, but hasn't done a thing since, which is a real pity because they could have explored almost the entire surface by now.
I guess there isn't a lot of point in sending out space probes and robots unless you want to make the information it gathers freely available.
Even today some of what we know about space is information that the Mariner craft gathered in the 1960s.

RE: On a side note...
By JediJeb on 8/19/2013 4:38:43 PM , Rating: 2
Didn't the Russians send one of the first probes to Venus, or was it Mercury? I remember at the time it was one of the more successful probes that had been sent out.

RE: On a side note...
By drycrust3 on 8/19/2013 5:43:49 PM , Rating: 2
Oh yes, apparently they did send some, like Venera 7 landed on Venus. However, it seems that Russia hasn't sent any since the mid 80s, when they co-operated with several European countries to do a series of missions to Halley's comet.
The Chinese have one space probe, Chang'e 2, in operation at present, but I don't know what its mission is.
Here is a list of space probes that have escaped earth orbit, but excludes those in Lagrangi points, that are actually active:

RE: On a side note...
By wordsworm on 8/22/2013 11:54:11 AM , Rating: 2
You're thinking of the Soviets.

RE: On a side note...
By Solandri on 8/20/2013 1:42:10 PM , Rating: 2
The Voyagers actually weren't the first spacecraft to visit the outer planets. Pioneer 10 was the first to visit Jupiter, while Pioneer 11 did a flyby of both Jupiter and Saturn (though the planetary alignment at the time meant that it had to cross back across the entire solar system to get to Saturn). The Voyagers were much more capable and (more importantly in the public's eye) had better cameras. But Pioneer set the stage and gave researchers an inkling of what questions to ask Voyager to answer.

The Russians mostly concentrated on Venus. It's a bit counterintuitive, but visiting the inner planets takes energy too. There's nothing to grab onto and slow yourself down in space, so "falling" towards the sun takes energy just like pulling away from it. It's the reason there have only been two missions to Mercury - too much delta-v required for what's considered a rather uninteresting planet.

It wasn't their fault Venus turned out to be completely covered with thick clouds making it uninteresting to the public. You can't take a vista-like photo on Venus like you can on Mars. Prior to the space program, popular opinion was that Venus was Earth's sister planet and most likely to harbor life. In the old sci-fi stories, the aliens are almost always from Venus. So it was natural for the Russians to pick it as their first choice.

The heat and high pressure on Venus (850 F, over 90 atmospheres) actually makes it much more difficult to build a Venus lander than a Mars (or Titan) lander. They needed to mount the camera behind a window made of diamond. (OTOH the high pressure meant they only needed a drogue chute for early re-entry. For the landing stage, there was no parachute. The thick atmosphere generated enough air resistance to slow the spacecraft down for a soft landing.)

RE: On a side note...
By marvdmartian on 8/20/2013 8:41:49 AM , Rating: 2
Now we just need to have Kirk & Company, along with a bald headed hotty, ready for V'ger's return!

Just another plot to take over the world
By bug77 on 8/19/2013 11:22:33 AM , Rating: 2
In reality, NASA knows Voyager has stopped for a looong break to sip a nicely chilled bottle of Coke on Neptune. That's why it hasn't left the Solar system, but "they" don't want us to know that.

By SublimeSimplicity on 8/19/2013 11:38:47 AM , Rating: 2
I disagree. I think this is the scene from the Truman Show where he is reaching the edge of the set. The aliens that use us for entertainment are furiously trying to turn us around at the moment.

The most popular show in the Glaupunk Quadrant roughly translates to "Anal Probe hour". True story.

RE: Just another plot to take over the world
By Solandri on 8/20/2013 1:48:04 PM , Rating: 2
Naw, God set up a script that runs every few months and checks Voyager's location. If it's left the simulated reality, the script extends that local region of simulation to include it again. That's why we keep thinking Voyager has left the solar system, then has not, then has, has not, etc.

By Skywalker123 on 8/23/2013 1:51:42 PM , Rating: 1
All these space missions are a waste of time and money, if you really want to know about the universe just read your Bible and ask Jesus.

By ewhite06 on 8/19/2013 3:52:13 PM , Rating: 2
Its probably bonked into our Dyson sphere and smudged a couple 'galaxies' painted on the inside. NASA is working to send a repair crew to touch it up.

Hiding in the shadows.
By drycrust3 on 8/19/2013 3:53:43 PM , Rating: 2
and at one point, solar particle counts disappeared while galactic particles remained, which would indicate an exit of our solar system -- but the lack of directional change in the magnetic field makes NASA scientists skeptical of whether Voyager 1 has truly entered interstellar space.

One of the interesting things about interstellar space is will the permeability and permittivity of there be different from what we measure inside the heliosphere. If it is the same, then one would expect the speed of light to be the same also, but if it is different, then one would expect the speed of light to change too.
In regards to the presence and absence of solar particles, my thinking is this is the result of either Jupiter or Saturn passing between Voyager 1 and the sun some time ago, e.g. 6 months ago, and creating a "wash" or null region of sun particles that slowly spirals outwards from that planet's orbit towards the edge of the heliosphere.
As such, I think that NASA is right to be cautious to think Voyager 1 is still within the heliosphere ... I think we will have to wait a bit longer ... like another few years.

Nice work
By amypaige654 on 8/21/2013 4:58:43 PM , Rating: 2

Im really thankful to Ricky Casanoir that commented last week in this site and suggested me this site to earn money online. By just following simple 3 steps you get on the verge of making easy amount at home. ...

By shannaemoon on 8/19/13, Rating: -1
"People Don't Respect Confidentiality in This Industry" -- Sony Computer Entertainment of America President and CEO Jack Tretton

Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki