New study may be a violation of ethics principles
Cell phone location tracking is no longer just the domain of
emergency services and shadowy government investigations. New research from a
group of scientists at Northeastern University in Boston say they've practically struck gold with cell phones, using their
location-tracking features to draw conclusions about 100,000 subscribers to an
undisclosed European cell provider.
The study, titled "Understanding Individual Human Mobility Patterns"
and published in the latest edition of the journal Nature, sought to figure out where people go throughout their
day. Scientists have previously struggled with the task, as tracking something
as "ephemeral" as peoples' movements in a reliable, non-intrusive
method proves to be highly difficult. Cell phones and the location-tracking
data that telcos collect on them as people move near different towers, seems to
have bridged this gap. People are generally never far from their phones, and
their location-tracking traits are completely passive so much that many people
aren't even aware they are being tracked.
"Slices of our behavior are preserved in these electronic data sets,"
said project director Albert-László Barabási. "This is creating huge
opportunities for science."
Privacy groups are not sitting easy with the study's methods,
however. Marc Rotenberg, president and founder of the Electronic Privacy
Information Center in Washington D.C., called the study "troubling,"
noting that it "raises questions about the protection of privacy in
physical spaces, when devices make possible the capture of locational data."
Ethically, the study exists in a gray area as well. The study's
"participants" -- the 100,000 subscribers of the undisclosed European
country -- were not informed of their participation. While scientists are
generally allowed to observe people in public areas, examining
location-tracking data is a new development in the research world and has yet
to be classified one way or another.
The researchers say that they received dataset with personal information
scrambled out, from a telephone company that was obligated to collect
location-tracking information for other reasons. Further, they say their data
is only as precise as the nearest cell tower -- and that it only shows
information from when someone uses cell service, like sending a text message or
receiving a phone call.
Despite their privacy precautions, however, the researchers acknowledge that
most people's movements are so predictable that they can reasonably forecast
the likelihood of someone being in a particular spot, regardless of how obfuscated
their phone number is.
"Individuals display significant regularity, because they return to a few
highly frequented locations, such as home or work," reads the paper.
While peoples' propensity for going to and from the same locations seems like
an obvious conclusion, similar research has been confined to methods far less
accurate. A previous paper, written by a physics professor Dirk Brockmann at
Northwestern University, tracked people using data from dollar-tracking site
wheresgeorge.com. It too reached a similar conclusion regarding people's lack
of variation, but Brockmann's research was limited because, unlike cell phones,
currency is rapidly passed around.
"Dollar bills diffuse, but humans do not," noted the Northeastern
study.
The article in Nature notes that good data on human movements
is useful to a number of fields. Urban planners can better allocate projects
and resources to where people actually go, and epidemiologists can better track
the spread of viruses and other threats.
"This is a new step for science," said Barabási. "For the first
time we have a chance to really objectively follow certain aspects of human
behavior."
"Game reviewers fought each other to write the most glowing coverage possible for the powerhouse Sony, MS systems. Reviewers flipped coins to see who would review the Nintendo Wii. The losers got stuck with the job." -- Andy Marken
|
Most Popular ArticlesReport: Apple to Debut iPad 3 During First Week of March February 10, 2012, 9:36 AM Nikon Announces 36.3MP D800, D800E D-SLRs February 7, 2012, 10:11 AM Quick Note: Acura Unveils Production Version of ILX Hybrid Sedan February 8, 2012, 9:10 AM Google's Motorola Mobility Purchase Approval Expected Next Week February 9, 2012, 3:02 PM AMD Concedes Die-Shrink Race to Intel, Considers ARM Cores February 6, 2012, 11:45 AM
|