Samsung and Nokia Sign 5 Year Licensing Deal, Despite Leaks Controversy
November 4, 2013 1:41 PM
Deal avoids more painful suits regarding software patents, but comes at the cost of profitability
a newly minted deal
the world's top smartphone maker
-- South Korea's Samsung Electronics Comp., Ltd. (
) and Nokia Oyj. (
)), Samsung agrees to pay Nokia royalties on its Android smartphones, beginning in January 2014.
I. Nokia Scores Licensing Payments From World's Largest Smartphone Maker
The deal is another crucial coup for the Finland-based Nokia, who recently opted to sell its recovering devices division to ally Microsoft Corp. (
focus its efforts on the telecommunications equipment market
. Nokia already owns a major licensing deal with Apple, Inc. (
). Apple -- widely known in the smartphone "patent wars" as an aggressor -- ironically enough was on the
receiving end of Nokia litigation back in 2009
, which culminated in
an agreement from Apple to pay licensing fees
Apple's licensing rates (i.e. how much Apple pays Nokia per iPhone to "borrow" its "innovations" -- intellectual property) interestingly may have played a key role in the Nokia-Samsung negotiations and are also the subject of a growing controversy.
Both Samsung (Galaxy S4, left) and Apple (iPhone 5S, right) are saddled with licensing fees to Nokia.
Apple and Samsung are currently
locked in a second round of suits-countersuits
, which will be tried in March 2014 in the
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California
Judge Paul S. Grewal
presiding over the trial. Ironically, that case only involves the
Galaxy Note 2
-- aging Androids which Samsung will likely have largely have stopped making by the time the case wraps up. Apple
tried to tack on
Samsung's current flagship smartphone,
the Galaxy S4
, but Judge Grewal denied that motion, forcing Apple to have to likely wait for a third trial in mid-to-late 2015 on that, and possibly other devices.
Overseas Samsung has
faced some minor losses
brief bans of its "Galaxy Tab" product line
has been successful in
convincing foreign regulators
that its workarounds eliminate
Apple's infringement claims. Notably in the UK
Samsung actually was found completely innocent
-- illustrating the diverse range of opinions regarding software patents and their scope.
The Galaxy Note II is among the devices targeted by Apple's latest ban request.
In the U.S., Samsung lost the first round of the battle, with a hometown Californian jury -- who
included jurors who had family members who were Apple shareholders
-- deciding that Apple was innocent of infringement, but Samsung was guilty. A jury ordered
roughly $1B USD in damages
$450M USD of that was awarded under improper instructions
; so it's being recalculated (likely lower) at a special damages trial in November -- also in the USDC for Northern California, under the trial judge for the first case,
Judge Lucy Koh
II. Did Leaks Help Samsung Illicitly Score a Deal? Apple, Nokia Claim So
The controversy regarding the Apple-Nokia licensing stems from the fact that Apple
handed over confidential documents
to Samsung's lawyers -- which were only allowed to prepare a defense for the case. Those documents admittedly were not stamped with the appropriate confidential steal ("Attorney Eyes' Only"), due to what Samsung's lawyers claim is a "mistake". They were also uploaded to an FTP, which Apple's law team contends was access by 223 unauthorized individuals -- including Samsung lawyers and executives involved in the Nokia investigation.
Apple cites a deposition from Nokia's chief intellectual property officer, Paul Melin who at a June 4 settlement talk with Samsung was reportedly surprised when Samsung executive
Dr. Seungho Ahn
knew of the secret terms of the Apple license, and reportedly use that for leverage, telling Mr. Melin "all information leaks".
Apple and Nokia claim Samsung abused confidential information to gain an upper hand in its dealings. [Image Source: Gizmodo]
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP
-- the outside counsel representing Samsung admits that it made "missteps" in the case, which they "deeply regret". But they deny that Dr. Ahn knew of the agreement, arguing that Mr. Melin misunderstood Dr. Ahn due to a language barrier (English is a second language for Dr. Ahn).
If Apple is able to nail the lawyers at Quinn Emanuel with sanctions it would be a major blow and set a difficult initial hurdle for Samsung to overcome image-wise in the second trial. It could also seriously impact Dr. Ahn, who happens to have J.D. legal credentials from the State Bar of California.
Fortunately for the Samsung team, Judge Grewal so far has remained unconvinced of Apple's argument for lack of complete information. He
in a recent hearing, "I am not yet satisfied that sanctions are warranted in this matter."
It's pretty clear based on Quinn Emanuel's defense testimony from the hearing, that Samsung did something at least mildly illegal, in failing to stamp the documents appropriately and uploading them to a potentially shared FTP. How serious a breach this was may be difficult for Apple and Nokia to definitively prove -- as most of the critical details happened behind the veil of Samsung's servers. In terms of image, the account is mildly damaging to Samsung although at this point the battlelines are drawn; its detractors will largely view this as another instance of "Samsung stealing", while its proponents will view it as a merry rogue, perhaps flexing the bounds of legality to battle the patent aggression of Apple and Nokia.
II. Samsung -- Profitable, but Not Safe as the Vultures Circle
With that in mind, at the end of the day Nokia
-- whether it was due to knowing what Samsung (illicitly) knew with respect to its Apple arrangement, or something else -- to four months later accept Samsung's licensing settlement offer. The pair are still have a bit of negotiating to do, though as the "damages" for the bind arbitration (i.e. per unit licensing fees) will be decided sometime in 2015 (and retroactively applied to 2014 sales).
Nokia was a pioneer in the smartphone space with devices like the Nokia N770 (2005).
It is unclear whether Nokia will offer any special exemptions for
Samsung's Windows Phone handsets
did not spare the Radar 4G Windows Phone from HTC
) in the pair's recent ongoing legal strife. However, Microsoft has since received
a confidential licensing agreement for Windows Phone as part of the Nokia Devices deal
-- leaving it unclear whether or not Windows Phone (as a platform) has received licensing from Nokia (meaning all Windows Phones released from Q3 2013 on would likely be protected), or if the licensing only applies to Nokia Devices' Windows Phones. The licensing pact, like the deal between Apple and Nokia, is sealed, so we may never know (given that Samsung has already settled with Nokia and HTC is likely to settle).
Nokia says it currently receives patent licensing fees from a whopping 50 OEMs. It quite possibly may have the strongest smartphone patent portfolio in that its pioneering work in smartphones allowed it to describe in patents the basic software setup of the modern smartphone, with sufficient ambiguity in the language to broadly cover most current devices. Better still, most of these patents weren't part of any standard, and thus aren't bound by any sort of obligatory licensing.
[Image Source: Reuters]
Samsung now is safe from Nokia, but it's still reeling from being sued by Rockstar Consortium -- a group of tech firms that includes Apple and Microsoft -- and even fellow Android OEM Sony Corp. (
). The suit is controversial as Apple and Microsoft had promised to the use these patents -- which
come from a 6,000 patent portfolio
bankrupt telecommunications firm Nortel
-- in a peaceful manner, at the time of their
$4.4B USD purchase approval in Feb. 2012
The suit is also controversial as Samsung has a licensing agreeement with Microsoft for Android, and is rumored to pay one of the highest rates of any OEM (
nearly $15 USD per device
). Samsung may have paid Microsoft over $3B USD in 2012 in licensing fees on the 215 million smartphones it sold, most of which ran Android. Given that Samsung is already paying Microsoft, it seems rather unethical that Microsoft would turn around and try to troll this cash cow for even more via shell company.
About the only good news for Samsung is that even with the new "Nokia tax", Samsung will likely remain the most profitable Android OEM in the industry, given its current
large quarterly smartphone profits.
Nokia [press release]
The Verge [documents leak]
"I'm an Internet expert too. It's all right to wire the industrial zone only, but there are many problems if other regions of the North are wired." -- North Korean Supreme Commander Kim Jong-il
Nokia Sells 8.8 Million Windows Phones in Q3, Transitions to Telecom Sales
October 29, 2013, 8:11 PM
Samsung's Smartphone Growth Defies Critics, But Signs of Weakness Also Show
October 25, 2013, 5:44 PM
Nokia Looks to Ban HTC Androids From U.S.
October 2, 2013, 5:26 PM
Microsoft Purchases Nokia's Devices and Services Division for $7.2B
September 3, 2013, 12:00 AM
Apples Tries to Use Decade-Old Patents to Ban Samsung Galaxy S IV
May 22, 2013, 3:00 PM
Are You in the Market for Earphones?
March 24, 2017, 7:35 AM
Samsung Galaxy S8, Rumored Launch Date!
March 18, 2017, 6:45 AM
How about Leica Cameras
March 13, 2017, 6:30 AM
Nokia has ditched this camera technology in its new smartphones
March 7, 2017, 8:45 AM
A Baseball Cap With Camera
March 3, 2017, 7:00 AM
Nokia 3310 with longer battery life
February 28, 2017, 7:05 AM
Most Popular Articles
Apple iPad – New Faster Processor and More Fun
March 22, 2017, 7:25 AM
OnePlus 3T – 5.5” Optic AMOLED and Dash Charging Technology
March 23, 2017, 8:45 AM
Comparison – Samsung Galaxy TabPro S Vs Microsoft Surface Pro 4
March 21, 2017, 7:40 AM
Huawei P8 Lite 2017 – Android 7 Nougat Smartphone with Octa-Core Processor
March 8, 2017, 7:03 AM
Gigabyte GA-Z170X-Gaming G1 – Intel Thunderbolt 3 Certified Motherboard
March 9, 2017, 6:25 AM
Latest Blog Posts
More Apps From Google
Mar 28, 2017, 7:15 AM
Are you thinking of performance and speed? Intel claims:
Mar 25, 2017, 7:45 AM
Apple buys an automation app called Workflow. The deal was completed today and brings the app along with its developers.
Mar 23, 2017, 7:35 AM
Apple Announces new color for iPhones and iPads
Mar 22, 2017, 7:45 AM
Instagram: You Can Now Save Live Videos For Later
Mar 21, 2017, 7:49 AM
Samsung Galaxy S8 to Get New Color Scheme
Mar 20, 2017, 7:45 AM
What else to worry about?
Mar 17, 2017, 6:45 AM
Icon of the Day: Intel/ NVIDIA or Mobileye
Mar 16, 2017, 6:15 AM
JUST IN - Twitter Hijacked : High-Profile Account Accesses
Mar 15, 2017, 7:07 AM
Mar 14, 2017, 7:30 AM
News and Tips
Mar 13, 2017, 6:30 AM
iPhone 8 – May Not Get Curved Screen
Mar 11, 2017, 8:00 AM
California paves way to self-driving car tests without humans
Mar 11, 2017, 7:18 AM
Smart Machines V hackers
Mar 10, 2017, 7:00 AM
Uber Can Resume Autonomous Car Testing in California
Mar 9, 2017, 6:50 AM
Mar 8, 2017, 7:09 AM
Mar 7, 2017, 8:45 AM
World news 3-6
Mar 6, 2017, 5:40 AM
Mar 4, 2017, 7:40 AM
Mixed News of the Day
Mar 4, 2017, 6:32 AM
Jaguar Land Rover invests in ride-sharing
Mar 3, 2017, 7:00 AM
Mixed News of The World:
Mar 2, 2017, 7:02 AM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2017 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information