Print 9 comment(s) - last by excrucio.. on Jul 20 at 11:35 PM

Being a leecher -- usually a badge of shame -- may be one man's savior

An unnamed German eDonkey2000 user found himself in the crosshairs of one of Germany’s anti-P2P watchdogs, and was presented with copyright notice that demanded he pay 700 euros for making music available for download. But there’s a catch: his ED2K client was tweaked to block all attempts at uploading back to the network, using a so-called “leecher” or “zero-upload” mod.

According to TorrentFreak via German publication Heise Online (English), the unnamed user’s client reported an uninterrupted uptime of 924 days – over two and a half years – while maintaining a total upload count of 0 bytes. Despite this, German anti-P2P firm Media Protector is demanding €700, based off of evidence gathered in October 2007 that claims the man uploaded movies and pornography.

Media Protector asserts that its claims are accurate, and that the evidence it holds was approved by “sworn computer experts.”

The unknown German’s plight adds yet another entry to the long list of stories containing users who feel they are unfairly targeted by the content industry’s enforcement machine. In the United States, cases of supposedly mistaken identity can go both ways: disabled mother Tanya Anderson won almost $110,000 in attorney’s fees from the RIAA last May after it falsely accused her of downloading gangster rap under a username she'd never heard of. Minnesota-based single mom Jammie Thomas, however, was ordered to pay the content industry $222,000 after fighting claims that she let 24 songs, out of a total of 1,700, be “available” for download to other users over the KaZaA P2P network – but lucky for her, the judge of that case is considering a retrial due to a flawed jury instruction.

While anti-P2P companies such as Media Protector or U.S.-based MediaDefender are generally tightlipped about their tactics – a sticking point that has many calling for increased transparency – the internet gained deeper insight into the minds behind MediaDefender after hackers leaked a crippling amount of internal data to the internet lasty year, including complete e-mail archives and the source code to nearly all of the company’s antipiracy technologies. While MediaDefender’s role is not exactly analogous to that of Media Protector – the U.S. equivalent would likely be SafeNet/MediaSentry – one could easily argue that the zeal reflected in MediaDefender’s e-mail leaks is applicable of the entire anti-P2P industry, given current evidence.

Unfortunately, the Heise Online article is sketchy with details, so it’s hard to know who’s really right. A lot hangs in the balance of cases like this, however: France will soon kick file-sharers off the internet if they’re caught pirating three times, and the content industry throughout the world seems to be sparing no expense in its quest to expedite the process against those deemed as pirates. I predict a future where a handful of truly innocent, internet-less users start fighting back, dragging the content industry and its loose trigger fingers even deeper through the legal mud – and bringing a swift judicial end to its antics.

In a world where one’s internet can be disconnected due to legal accusations that defendants have little chance to contest – the RIAA thinks it shouldn’t even have to prove infringement, due to the difficulty of collecting evidence in a system relying on mass lawsuits – users are quickly finding themselves on the business end of a legal cannon that carries little regard for who’s right. Regardless of whether or not the target-of-the-day is an unwitting innocent, or guilty as sin; are you sure that’s where we want to be?

Comments     Threshold

This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

By robinthakur on 7/17/2008 12:14:33 PM , Rating: 3
I think he means Sworn at computer experts.

Things of the past...
By excrucio on 7/20/2008 11:35:49 PM , Rating: 1
P2P and torrents are old school methods.

They'll never catch the new methods unless internet becomes government property, and they make the internet into Chinese internet... a super which at that point you'll see rebellions and no one wants that..

By porkpie on 7/16/08, Rating: -1
RE: Hrmm
By AlmostExAMD on 7/17/2008 6:22:29 AM , Rating: 3
I get your point but prosecuting with little or no evidence, Where does it end, Shall they book you for speeding in advance just because you own a car capable of breaking the limit?

RE: Hrmm
By rdeegvainl on 7/17/2008 9:02:24 AM , Rating: 4
Nobody asked you to believe he's not guilty of anything. No one asked for your pity, or to feel sorry.

He is trying to prove that he is not guilty of uploading. And the way I see it is, if you didn't UPLOAD, you shouldn't be charged for UPLOADING. They just know that if this guy gets charged for DOWNLOADING, they won't see much money.

Laws and punishments exist for a reason, and to blatantly charge someone with a different crime than they committed is wrong.

You don't charge some with Gran Theft Auto, if they stole a VCR.

RE: Hrmm
By CascadingDarkness on 7/17/2008 11:19:13 AM , Rating: 2
if they stole a VCR.

In this day and age, would anyone even bother if they stole a VCR ?

RE: Hrmm
By DASQ on 7/17/2008 11:42:38 AM , Rating: 5
It's a crime of passion, really.

RE: Hrmm
By 4play on 7/17/2008 1:23:10 PM , Rating: 2
you never know some day they might be worth something!

RE: Hrmm
By marvdmartian on 7/17/2008 3:25:08 PM , Rating: 2
Only if they were watching stolen porn with it! ;)

The point being made isn't whether he committed a crime or not, it's whether he committed the crime he's being accused of doing. If they're going after uploaders, and have accused him of sharing by uploading to others, and he has not done so, then they're WRONG .

"Let's face it, we're not changing the world. We're building a product that helps people buy more crap - and watch porn." -- Seagate CEO Bill Watkins

Copyright 2016 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki