backtop


Print 10 comment(s) - last by TomZ.. on Mar 24 at 5:44 PM


  (Source: Engadget)
Project may be floundering amongst corporate-style reorganization

Citing irreconcilable ethical differences with One Laptop Per Child’s management, Ivan Krstic announced that he resigned his post as OLPC’s Director of Security Architecture, as of three weeks ago.

“Not long ago, OLPC undertook a drastic internal restructuring coupled with what, despite official claims to the contrary, is a radical change in its goals and vision,” wrote Krstic. “I cannot subscribe to the organization’s new aims or structure in good faith, nor can I reconcile them with my personal ethic. Having exhausted other options, three weeks ago I resigned my post at OLPC.”

Writing in his personal blog, Krstic said that he considered the OLPC project a “second home,” and his coworkers “another family.”

“I learned what it meant to believe in a mission so much that nights and days blur together, and the prospect of success keeps you going even when your brain begins to defocus and your body craves sleep with desperation.”

Krstic said he was responsible for “everything from advising firmware development to debugging … I designed OLPC’s entire back-end server infrastructure, created its staggered software build process, came up with Bitfrost … and had the incredible pleasure of personally deploying our very first laptops and bootstrapping the second deployment.”

The security chief’s last straw came with OLPC president Walter Bender’s forced demotion:  “adding insult to injury, I was asked to stop working with [Bender], without a doubt one of the most stunningly thoughtful and competent people I’ve ever worked with.” wrote Krstic. Instead, he reported to a manager “with no technical or engineering background,” who the project “put in charge of all OLPC technology.”

Krstic’s departure is just the latest in a string of misfortunes for Nicholas Negroponte’s OLPC project, which in the past year has been beset with supply and relationship issues: the project’s November 2007 “Give 1 Get 1” initiative, which sold 83,500 laptops commercially at a price of $400 – one laptop for a buyer and one for a poor child – fell flat when the project encountered fulfillment and shipping issues.

At around the same time, the partnership between OLPC and Intel – which has always been a stormy affairdissolved once again with the company deciding to pursue its competing “Classmate PC” instead.

With domestic buyers outraged, business relationships crumbling, key staff leaving, and bulk laptop sales that most describe as “sluggish,” many wonder if OLPC’s floundering is a temporary growing pain, or something more permanent.

To that end, Negroponte says he is working hard at turning OLPC around – earlier this month, Negroponte announced to BusinessWeek that he was looking for a new CEO to take the helm: “I am not a CEO … management, administration, and details are my weaknesses. I'm much better at the vision, big-picture side of the house,” said Negroponte. He expects his headhunters to find someone by April or May, but he is having a hard time finding candidates who would “view the world as a mission, not a market.” Many potential candidates, he said, come from the PC industry – and Negroponte would much rather have someone who has a leadership profile similar to former UN secretary-general Koffi Annan.

The restructuring that Krstic left OLPC for refers to Negroponte’s initiative to transform the project into a company that would conduct itself “more like Microsoft,” as OLPC’s current form runs itself “almost like a terrorist group, doing almost impossible things.” He would like OLPC to offload its development and support operations to specialized companies better equipped for OLPC’s challenges, like Red Hat or Microsoft.

“In the end, we should not be in the hardware or software business. We should be in the learning business,” said Negroponte.

Krstic writes that he still believes in the idea behind OLPC, even though he objects to the company’s new direction:  “My belief in the mission is in no way compromised … It’s been an outstanding experience, and I truly wish OLPC the best in its future endeavors.”



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

No Good Deed Goes Unpunished
By TomZ on 3/21/2008 6:03:03 PM , Rating: 2
So seems to be the fate of the OLPC initiative.




RE: No Good Deed Goes Unpunished
By Master Kenobi (blog) on 3/21/2008 6:23:03 PM , Rating: 3
quote:
Negroponte would much rather have someone who has a leadership profile similar to former UN secretary-general Koffi Annan.

Well, it's no wonder the OLPC project has so many problems if you want someone like that behind the wheel.

What they need is someone who knows how to run a business, not a charity.


RE: No Good Deed Goes Unpunished
By crystal clear on 3/22/2008 4:54:50 AM , Rating: 2
Now even charity is run like business....

From marketing to Public Relations to anything else with Bloated salaries & perks......


RE: No Good Deed Goes Unpunished
By Master Kenobi (blog) on 3/22/2008 1:26:49 PM , Rating: 4
Well to be perfectly honest, this is a business. They are building a product, marketing it to other countries and people, they are selling it (granted at little or no profit). This is a business. It's about time they started acting like one.

Charity is the "goal" but it doesn't handle the administrative and strategy. That's all on the business side. So yes, even charity is run like a business.


RE: No Good Deed Goes Unpunished
By Ringold on 3/23/2008 7:11:16 PM , Rating: 2
Exactly. Even in the realms of charity where things arent sold but merely given or services are provided, there been a strong trend for years to begin incorporating practices and methods used by business to try to measure how much or how little success they are having for each dollar spent, with the aim of providing more benefit at less cost. If that sounds exactly like what a business tries to do, profit maximization, sell the most product at the least cost (to self), then that's because it is.

But of course reality has never been one of this guys strong suits. It's almost satisfying to see the house of cards starting to crumble.


Sad. but needed to be done
By ultimatebob on 3/21/2008 6:26:43 PM , Rating: 3
The OLPC guys are bunch of smart people who built an innovative product, but were never able to mass produce that product quickly or cheaply enough to meet demand. Remember... they were supposed to have built over a million laptops at $100 a piece by now, and they're nowhere near their original volume targets or price goals.

Sadly, the kind of mass production techniques and cost conscious management that they need to make OLPC work are the same that allow large bureaucratic companies like Dell or Lenovo to be successful. "Linux hippie" developers and wild eyed MIT processors aren't going to like working in an environment like that, but they're going to need a culture shock like this in order to make this project work.




RE: Sad. but needed to be done
By TomZ on 3/24/2008 5:44:28 PM , Rating: 2
OLPC was working with an outside vendor to handle the mass manufacturing, so I don't think that was their problem.

I think the problem is that it's really just a neat sounding idea that makes people feel good, but that it just doesn't make much sense when you really think about it.


Another straw...
By dsuse on 3/21/2008 11:33:44 PM , Rating: 2
Another big straw that probably helped break the Security Chief's ability to stay in the job.

Security <> Windows OS installation on the previously-secure OLPC.

Negroponte seems to have started a bit of a domino effect.




To be or not to be
By crystal clear on 3/22/2008 5:07:32 AM , Rating: 2
quote:
In the end, we should not be in the hardware or software business. We should be in the learning business,” said Negroponte.


I think he should be in the fund raising business.....
to raise funds from countries to support his grandoise projects/programs.

Take a trip to Dubai to get a slice of the Soverign funds just sitting there waiting to be spent.

Hector from AMD did just that.....

He should be a Lobbyist in Washinton D.C. if nothing works.




Well...
By aegis maelstrom on 3/22/2008 9:08:56 PM , Rating: 2
quote:
β€œIn the end, we should not be in the hardware or software business. We should be in the learning business,” said Negroponte.


So much for the geek story.




"Folks that want porn can buy an Android phone." -- Steve Jobs














botimage
Copyright 2012 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki