backtop


Print E-mail del.icio.us 84 comment(s) - last by Totally.. on Oct 17 at 1:54 AM


  (Source: Red Light Tickets)
Is the new cell phone blocking technology a lifesaver or a gross invasion of privacy

Automobile accidents are one of the leading causes of injury and death in America.  Last year 41,059 people died in traffic accidents.  This has led to extreme measures, such as keys that limit the capabilities of vehicles for teenage drivers, as recently debuted by Ford. 

Meanwhile, cell phones are essential functions in our lives, yet they have been under heavy criticism of late.  From being banned on planes for interfering with transmissions to being blamed for cancer, they've gotten their fair share of bad publicity. 

Perhaps the most salient of the criticism of cell phones is that they are distracting to drivers and have led to an increase in the number of car accidents.  Studies have shown that drivers texting on cell phones are more impaired than those drinking or abusing other drugs.  Also, a recent National Highway Traffic Safety Administration in 2006 found that merely dialing or talking on the phone caused 7 percent of accidents and near-crashes were directly caused by cell phones.  While it is clear that this is a problem, many have wondered about a solution to the problem.

One company, Aegis Mobility, a Canadian software company, thinks it has the solution.  The company has invented a new technology called DriveAssistT.  The new system operates in-car and detects when the car is in motion.  It then sends a signal to the wireless carrier telling them to hold incoming calls and text messages.

Callers who call the phone will be presented with a message that the person appears to be driving.  They can press a key to go into an "emergency" mode to directly connect, if necessary.  Otherwise they can just leave a message.

The new tech may see a strong push from many states' lawmakers.  Lawmakers in New York and California have already passed through tough penalties on talking without a hands-free headset -- though as the NHTSA study showed, the physical act of talking causes crashes as well.  Lawmakers in California have also terminated drivers' text-and-drive privileges.

One obstacle to adoption is compatibility.  Aegis Mobility software is currently supported by the industry leading OS, Symbian OS, available on Nokia and Sony Ericsson phones.  It is also supported by Windows Mobile, typically found on smart-phones.  However, there's no current support for OS X (found on the iPhone) or Google's new Android OS.

For phones that support it, the devices operation is deceptively simple, says Dave Hattey, Aegis' CEO.  The device uses the onboard GPS chip found in a large number of modern phones to track the user’s movements.  Past a certain speed the signal is sent.  The phone attempts to use any existing Wi-Fi networks, and in their absence will connect over-the-air.

Aegis is currently working on cutting a deal with a major carrier.  It plans to charge users approximately $10 to $20 a month for its services.  The software will be initially aimed primarily at parents with teen drivers.  They also anticipate corporate customers to add the software to their corporate cell phones.

The driver will have the option to override the new system if they indicate they are a passenger in the car that's driving.  The override will be sent to the company's website, where it can be tracked by parents or employers to make sure their steeds are not lying.

Aegis does have one big deal already -- a partnership with Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.  The insurance company will offer its customers 3 percent to 10 percent family plan discounts if they adopt the technology.



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

Or instead of paying Aegis $10-$20 every month...
By Creig on 10/15/2008 11:50:35 AM , Rating: 5
just buy an electronic cellphone blocker device for $63 http://www.dealextreme.com/details.dx/sku.11510 and have your local remote starter/car stereo shop wire it to be active only when your car is running. The remote control that comes with it can either stay in the car in case the system needs to be deactivated for a passenger to use their cellphone or a parent can take the remote with them so their teenagers have no choice but to pull over and shut the car off to make a call.

Problem solved. And much cheaper than Aegis is offering.




By FITCamaro on 10/15/2008 12:13:18 PM , Rating: 2
Except then you're blocking everyone else's cell phone calls within a 100 foot radius. Which I believe is illegal.


By FITCamaro on 10/15/2008 12:16:13 PM , Rating: 4
I wouldn't mind several of those being on the ceilings of movie theaters though. With a sign in the window saying cell phone reception is blocked inside.


By inighthawki on 10/15/2008 12:55:21 PM , Rating: 5
So buy one and take it in the theater with u. You think the stupid group of 15 year old girls are going to know u have one? let alone what it is or that it exists?


RE: Or instead of paying Aegis $10-$20 every month...
By Yames on 10/15/08, Rating: -1
By FITCamaro on 10/15/2008 5:17:57 PM , Rating: 5
Or she could leave the theater and tell someone at the concession stand or box office? I mean I know that involves getting up and stuff but I'm just spouting random ideas here...

And are you seriously worried about your daughter being stalked by some child predator at the movie theater? They rarely try to do anything in such a crowded place. Perhaps the parking lot but not in the theater which is what we were talking about.


By othercents on 10/15/2008 6:12:36 PM , Rating: 5
quote:
Perhaps the parking lot but not in the theater which is what we were talking about.

Confession?


By ggordonliddy on 10/15/2008 6:13:10 PM , Rating: 2
I think he's talking about the phone being blocked while driving.


By feraltoad on 10/15/2008 5:19:50 PM , Rating: 2
The range of a personal blocker is quite limited. However, passive cell blocking tech is available, copper filaments "plastered" on the walls, that can be installed in single rooms, a theater for example, to block those pesky calls for help while the movie plays. Welcome to the deadzone.

People often say, "What about an emergency if I'm in the movies and my calls are blocked?". I usually think that someone with such a precarious life should probably not be taking in movies, and the lives of horrible apprehension and fear those before cell phones must have lived. Movie theaters could have a screen on the back of the headrest, like airlines, that could offer an option to alert you to an emergency call if you forward your messages to the theater number. Then we could pay $40 a ticket, won't that be nice! Plus, I don't think you could make it tough enough so those little POS punks that hang out at places like theaters & malls couldn't destroy it.


By othercents on 10/15/2008 6:16:52 PM , Rating: 2
quote:
People often say, "What about an emergency if I'm in the movies and my calls are blocked?".

I wonder what we ever did in theaters without cell phones. Did more people just die because they couldn't call someone? What ever happened to 911? Do we not teach people how to dial that number? Really, is your parents going to be able to fix every problem you might deem as an emergency?

If you are not dead or dieing, don't call me. If you are dead or dieing call 911 for quicker assistance.

Other


By inighthawki on 10/15/2008 8:41:09 PM , Rating: 4
first and foremost, im not sure who's going to try to assault someone during the middle of a movie. Secondly, u are wayyyy to overprotective from the sounds of it. Its not like there's a sex predator around every corner. And like mentioned, there are such things as phones that aren't cell phones. Every movie theater will have some sort of land line, pay phone, and if its really an emergency, you can ask the person at the counter to do something. Problem solved.


RE: Or instead of paying Aegis $10-$20 every month...
By techone on 10/15/08, Rating: -1
By inighthawki on 10/15/2008 9:20:19 PM , Rating: 4
You are just a worrysome ignorant person who things around every corner is someone with bad intentions. Stop worrying about everything and everyone and you'll find that your life will be much happier and with less stress. If you want to protect your son/daughter/wife, make sure they are responsible and do the right things.

"WE HAVE TO TRACK THEM..."
We track them because it is something that is important to do, not because there are a lot of them.

"You think that each theatre of each movie that is playing is packed with people?"

No i don't, but what are the chances of your intended scenario happening. Firstly, your daughter has to want to go see the movie. Secondly, someone else does. Thirdly, that other person, out of every possible person, has to be a sex offender. Oh and btw, you don't get to check how packed a theater is until AFTER you buy the ticket AND wait for the movie to start. Also, if there's more than those two people in there, guess what won't happen? If the sex offender is stupid enough to do this kind of thing in a situation with someone else around, we're talking about a whole other teeny tiny subsection of people out of the larger group of sex offenders.

Yes, it CAN happen. WILL it? The chances are overwhelmingly against it happening specifically to your daughter. If something has happened in your lifetime to someone you care about, I'm sorry to hear that, but you have to look at the facts, that it was an extremely rare occurrence to begin with, it almost certainly won't happen again.


By Generic Guy on 10/16/2008 8:37:41 AM , Rating: 3
quote:
there are more sex offenders amongst us each day.


The problem is that many (perhaps most) of these "sex" offenders are really just bar drunks who got picked up for whizzing in the alley beside the building. Or people who are convicted of any crime involving any minor -- automatic "sex" offender in some states. Or teenage school couples where one or the other is nearing so-called age of consent (in past ages this was about 14-15, as define by God's design or mother nature or what have you). They're not the type to stalk your kids behind the school, but once on one of these lists it can ruin their lives.

Many people are being painted with a wide brush which should be reserved for only the worst of the worst. And paranoid idiots like yourself only feed into this nonsense.

Getting way off topic from cell phones, sorry. Um... Cell phones are a behavioral, etiquette problem, not a legislative problem.


By Kary on 10/16/2008 4:53:04 PM , Rating: 2
...ok, in a real emergency like that there is a much better alternative to cell phones (he could just knock it out of her hand) or driving somewhere else (if he isn't going to stop her from leaving is he really that much of a threat?)

HAVE HER YELL!!!

As others have stated, I do feel bad if something along these lines has happened to someone in your life.

On the other hand, please think through the situations instead of worrying about them or depending on technology to save you. Sometimes the simplest and lowest tech solutions are also the best solution.

Besides, people who use cell phones in theaters are rude and, although I have to admit I have considered using my solution for that problem, yelling during a movie would just be that much worse.


By Hare on 10/16/2008 1:37:16 AM , Rating: 2
People need to put their phones to silent mode. There may be fresh parents going to the movies and want to be informed if they are needed back home so blocking all calls is not a good idea. Just put the phone to silent or vibration and it won't bother anyone.

Of course there are idiots who just don't understand so maybe there should be a ticketing system. A ringing phone should cost maybe 50$. That should teach them...

I think this is also a cultural thing. I have never ever heard a telephone ringing/beeping in the movies.


RE: Or instead of paying Aegis $10-$20 every month...
By walk2k on 10/15/2008 2:50:05 PM , Rating: 2
They do this in Europe actually, but interfering with communiction is illegal in the US.


By omnicronx on 10/15/2008 3:10:44 PM , Rating: 2
Its illegal, but you can still get past it. It is also illegal in Canada, but my school opted to put an extra layer of lead in