NYT: President Obama Authorized Stuxnet Attack on Iran
June 1, 2012 1:54 PM
Was attack by U.S. and Israel an act of war? Some think so
It was not a happy meeting for Barack Obama, President of the United States. At a secret White House meeting with Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. and the director of the Central Intelligence Agency at the time, Leon E. Panetta, and other top officials, his advisors laid out that
the Stuxnet worm
had spiralled out of control. According to members of the President's national security team interviewed by
The New York Times
he asked, "Should we shut this thing down?"
I. Mission Success? Stuxnet Set Back Iran, Despite Code Leak
But the U.S. didn't shut Stuxnet down. The worm and its successors would go on to succeed in the core objective programmed into it by the U.S. and Israel -- to sabotage centrifruges originally produced by German equipment maker Siemens AG (
) by causing them to spin too fast and break.
But Iran eventually detected the worm, which had
broken 1,000 of its 5,000 nuclear centrifuges
at the Nanantz Plant, and quickly rooted it out, minimizing damage. It also publicly
called out the U.S. and Israel
for the alleged sabotage attempt, though it reportedly lied, denying that its plants had been damaged.
The U.S. denied knowledge of the worm. But privately, Obama administration and intelligence officials must have been panicking as the worm infected other Siemens equipment and spread, out of control, worldwide. Ultimately the source code leaked, offering more implication of the U.S. and Israel, while putting a potentially dangerous cyber superweapon into that hands of rival nation states, terrorist, and malicious for-profit hackers.
President Obama reportedly secretly authorized and planned the use of several worms to attack Iran's nuclear facilities. [Image Source: Associated Press]
But the allegation of U.S. involvement remained largely unproven. But
a new piece
by David E. Sanger of
The New York Times
has startling vivid accounts of the U.S. true involvement and cites numerous confirmations from government officials that cyber saboteur was indeed crafted by U.S. intelligence and its Israeli counterparts.
II. "Olympic Games" Attacks Began With Bush
According to the articles, the Bush administration began the cyber-attacks on Iraq, code-naming them "Olympic Games". When President Obama took over he opted to step up the attacks, specifically authorizing the virulent worm that would become known as Stuxnet.
Stuxnet worked remarkably well, but a programming error caused it to spread far outside the narrow trajectory its authors intended. According to the article when asked whether the worm should be remotely terminated, President Obama decided against pulling plug as his advisors told him it might still be doing damage and that the Iranians might not know that much about it.
Instead they stepped up the program, with two new worm variants, targeting the uranium enrichment centrifuges. While Iranian enrichment is reportedly ongoing after the worm was removed from the Nanantz Plant's system, the U.S. government is reportedly still targeting Iran with new cyberattacks.
This account of the American and Israeli effort to undermine the Iranian nuclear program is based on interviews over the past 18 months with current and former American, European and Israeli officials involved in the program, as well as a range of outside experts. None would allow their names to be used because the effort remains highly classified, and parts of it
continue to this day
Despite the embarassment of having their secret sabotage effort exposed, Obama administration officials reportedly expressed optimism about the results, saying it set the Iranian nuclear program back 18 months to 2 years. Independent experts were less optimistic, stating the setback windows would likely be smaller.
Stuxnet source code has been decompiled by Symantec and other researchers. Versions of the source have even publicly leaked, making them available to hackers. [Image Source: Wired]
Symantec Corp. (SYMC) officials say it was no secret that Stuxnet was created by a nation state actor. The worm was 50 times the size of a standard worm and equipped with unusual capabilities, like remote deletion.
III. Probing Iran's Dark Net
The U.S. had never before -- to anyone's knowledge -- carried out such a massive cyber-attack against a specific nation-state, which did damage that previously could only have been done by covert agents with bombs or chemical warfare devices.
So why did the Obama administration authorize this unprecedented measure, a measure some will likely say was an unauthorized act of war? The President felt the nation had no other choice when it came to stopping Iran. And he felt the effort must be kept secret from Congress and the public to avoid
terrorist organizations from using it
justify digital counterattacks
-- or that's what he told his staff, at least.
Former President George W. Bush reportedly had similar reasons for launching the program in the first place and keeping it secret. He was reportedly well aware that his credibility was shot after falsely accusing Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein of developing nuclear weapons. And his allies were opposed to steep sanctions against Iran, which could hurt their economies.
Iran recognized his vulnerability. Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad led reporters on tours of his nuclear plant and enrichment facilities, trying to publicly claim he had nothing to hide. But to the Bush administration it appeared that Iran's enrichment capacity was greatly outpacing its fuel needs, so the claims of peaceful infringement seemed highly dubious. To them Iran was clearly using the publicity stunt as a means of obfuscating the fact that it was stockpiling enriched weapons game uranium for warheads, warheads that could be used to demolish Israel and potentially even be trained at U.S. cities.
The attack on the centrifuges was preceded by a worm that mapped Iran's networks. President Bush authorized these early attacks. [Image Source: CBS]
U.S. Central Intelligence Agency efforts to sabotage parts for the plant, including designing generators that would blow up had little effect. And with Vice President Dick Cheney pushing the President for yet another decision, President Bush made the decision to explore cyberattacks, a program that would be completed by his successor.
The Bush administration effort start with the planting of a preliminary "beacon" worm that mapped networks and analyzed various devices and circuits, returning the data to the U.S. National Security Agency. In order to convince Dick Cheney and Israel to lay off plans to physically attack Iran in a pre-emptive strike, President Bush authorized a next generation design dubbed "the bug", whose objective was serious sabotage.
IV. Crossing "the Rubicon"
That worm was developed in secret by the CIA, NSA and Israel’s Unit 8200. Israel's hackers were reportedly criticals as they were more skilled than their U.S. counterparts and were armed with their nation's deep intelligence of the Nanantz facility.
The U.S. had already bought some of the aging centrifuges that Iran was using -- P-1s from former Libyan dictator Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi. Iran had purchased llarge number of identical models on the black market from Abdul Qadeer Khan, the Pakistani nuclear chief.
Using their small number of identical centrifuges, they carried out a successful test attack on the centrifuges, with systems set up to resemble those mapped by the "beacon". Armed with the success, President Bush authorized a real attack on Iranian systems.
Michael V. Hayden, the former chief of the C.I.A., remarked, "Previous cyberattacks had effects limited to other computers. This is the first attack of a major nature in which a cyberattack was used to effect physical destruction. Somebody crossed the Rubicon."
The C.I.A.'s former chief said the attack authorized by President Bush "crossed the Rubicon", opening a new era of warfare. [Image Source: Saul Loeb / AFP / Getty]
It took a while though for covert agents in Iran to spread "the bug" with USB drives. Comments an official, "It turns out there is always an idiot around who doesn’t think much about the thumb drive in their hand."
But in 2008 the first reports of success were reported. A handful of centrifuges began to blank. Mystified the Iranians believed they were "cursed" or possibly the result of parts sabotage. Comment an official based on intercepted communications, "The thinking was that the Iranians would blame bad parts, or bad engineering, or just incompetence."
While the program had not succeeded in large scale destruction of Iranian enrichment when President Bush left office, he urged his successor to preserve the program. President Obama listened to his advice and did.
The new president was reportedly deeply involved receiving weekly updates and authorizing new attacks. States one official, "From his first days in office, he was deep into every step in slowing the Iranian program — the diplomacy, the sanctions, every major decision. And it’s safe to say that whatever other activity might have been under way was no exception to that rule."
The first major setback to the program
occurred in 2010
when a portion of code design to make the worm detect its new environment and prevent replication outside the Iranian target vectors failed. Quickly the worm began to spread worldwide, and receive media attention. Vice President Biden reportedly fumed blaming the Israelis for the bad code. He is quoted by an unnamed official as saying, "It’s got to be the Israelis. They went too far."
V. More Attacks Coming?
While the Obama efforts were almost solely "focused on one country", many administration officials have since called for attacks on other regions like North Korea and possibly China, pending the semi-success of "the bug" and its successors. States one official, "We’ve considered a lot more attacks than we have gone ahead with."
The real question is whether such attacks could lead to real-world retaliation and loss of life. The U.S. government only
recently admitted to developing cyber-weapons
, but it also recently said that cyberattacks that caused physical destruction could be
construed as acts of war
and retaliated with "equivalent" real-world physical force. The question is whether the U.S. might soon find itself on the flip side of the equation.
Officials say attacks against North Korea are being considered. [Image Source: TechTear]
Iran, with enrichment continuing despite the setbacks, has created its own military cyberunit, headed by Brig. Gen. Gholamreza Jalali. Gen. Jalali
promised to fight Iran's enemies
"cyberspace and Internet warfare". But the unit, humorously dubbed the Passive Defense Organization has thus far not appeared to have committed any successful attacks on U.S. infrastructure.
Stuxnet is the first of two major embarassments for the Obama administration with regard to Iran. In December of last year the Iranians succesfully
downed a U.S. RQ-170 drone
a C.I.A. mission
. The Iranians have pledged to
crack the minimally damaged drone's secrets
, rejecting President Obama's
demands to return the flier
A new era in warfare has begun. [Image Source: Interplay (cover art for
In his seminal 1984 cyberpunk novel
William Gibson envisioned a world at war, in which internet offensives were used as preludes to physical attack. Today, more than ever, as the U.S.'s secret attack of Iran is exposed that prediction appears remarkably prescient.
The New York Times
"Game reviewers fought each other to write the most glowing coverage possible for the powerhouse Sony, MS systems. Reviewers flipped coins to see who would review the Nintendo Wii. The losers got stuck with the job." -- Andy Marken
Iranian Oil Industry Hit with Cyber Attack
April 24, 2012, 10:31 AM
Iran Brags It's Cracking U.S. Spy Drone, Sen. Lieberman Calls Claim "Bluster"
April 23, 2012, 2:25 PM
FBI: Beware of Terrorist Cyber Attacks
March 16, 2012, 10:11 AM
CBS: U.S., Israel Opened up Cyberwarfare "Pandora's Box" with Stuxnet
March 5, 2012, 5:37 PM
Iran Claims Its Nuclear Facilities Cannot Be Compromised
February 15, 2012, 7:03 AM
PIQ ROBOTTM reveals its new artificial intelligence software
November 29, 2016, 12:59 AM
One more time - Happy Thanksgiving to Everyone Around the World
November 24, 2016, 4:00 AM
Google’s Smart Contact Lens Project gets halted for 2016
November 20, 2016, 7:00 AM
Cell Research Study shows African Americans have greater immune response to infection
November 10, 2016, 1:00 AM
UTHealth Clinical Trial Shows Progress Using Stem Cells to Treat Traumatic Brain Injury
November 8, 2016, 1:00 AM
Uber Partners with Circulation to Pilot Program Connecting Transportation and Digital Health Care
November 6, 2016, 5:00 AM
Most Popular Articles
Super Hi- Vision Will Amaze the World
January 16, 2017, 9:53 AM
Samsung Chromebook Plus – Coming in February 2017
January 17, 2017, 12:01 AM
Samsung 2017 Handset’s Updates
January 17, 2017, 12:01 AM
Comparison – Surface Pro VS Tbook X5 Pro
January 21, 2017, 7:00 AM
Comparison – iPad Mini Vs Huawei MediaPad M3
January 19, 2017, 2:08 AM
Latest Blog Posts
Some new News
Jan 23, 2017, 8:59 AM
What is new?
Jan 22, 2017, 7:00 AM
Nintendo signals end for Wii U
Jan 21, 2017, 7:00 AM
Jan 20, 2017, 7:00 AM
News of the World
Jan 19, 2017, 7:00 AM
News of the Day Wednesday 1/18/2017
Jan 18, 2017, 12:01 AM
Jan 17, 2017, 12:16 AM
News of the Day
Jan 16, 2017, 12:10 PM
News and Technology Advancement
Jan 16, 2017, 7:58 AM
Jan 15, 2017, 12:32 AM
Here is Some News
Jan 14, 2017, 12:39 AM
News: Improved and New products
Jan 13, 2017, 12:01 AM
News around the world
Jan 12, 2017, 12:01 AM
Rumors and Announcements
Jan 11, 2017, 12:01 AM
This year CES and ridiculous gadgets
Jan 10, 2017, 12:01 AM
Nokia Android phone spurns the west.
Jan 9, 2017, 12:08 AM
New at CES 2017 - Changhong 8K Super Slim TV 65ZHQ3R
Jan 8, 2017, 1:07 AM
Debuted at CES 2017 - Vuzix Blade 3000 Smart Sunglasses
Jan 8, 2017, 12:39 AM
Some news of Day
Jan 7, 2017, 12:01 AM
News 2017 CES
Jan 6, 2017, 12:01 AM
Here is the Latest News in Tech
Jan 5, 2017, 1:47 AM
More Blog Posts
Copyright 2017 DailyTech LLC. -
Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information