backtop


Print E-mail del.icio.us 14 comment(s) - last by WillieEvercome.. on Jul 23 at 1:22 PM


Charging dock, charger, remote control earphones

Top half of W51S without alert symbols

W51S main screen

W51S keypad

Open W51S clamshell

Bottom half of closed clamshell

Earphone plug in, photo mode button, display light, pro duo memory housing

USB plug in

W51S with alert symbols visible
Sony Ericsson W51S cell phone review

Living in Japan, the need for a cell phone quickly becomes apparent. During the job search process, the inability to quickly communicate with recruiters and employers is an enormous handicap. As a stopgap measure, I temporarily used Skype as my primary method of communication; but that was a poor substitute for an actual cell phone. I then decided to sign up for a cell phone with AU by KDD, one of Japan’s primary cell phone service providers.

A lack of knowledge with regards to the features and services offered by cell phones in Japan made the availability of English language menus my primary criteria in choosing hardware. Out of the few cell phones that offered this feature, the Sony Ericsson W51S fit the bill.

The W51S has a very simple and slim design that allows for easy use of its various features. The black version of this phone has a metallic finish that is very resistant to fingerprints and scratches (unlike my iPod). On the outside top half of the closed clamshell, there is a mesh-like finish that covers the entire top. Unlike other cell phones there is no digital display or screen on the top half.

When receiving a call, an email, or setting the alarm an otherwise invisible phone, mail, or alarm symbol appears on the outer casing. The bottom edge of the closed clamshell also flashes white. On the outside bottom half of the closed clamshell there is a small digital display that shows information such as the time, date, battery life and caller id.

The lens for the 2 Megapixel CMOS camera is also found on the bottom half along with the housing for the Lithium ion battery. On one side of the closed clamshell are the plug in for the remote control earphones, the camera mode button, the display light button, and the housing for the Memory Stick Pro Duo Card. The phone comes with 120 megabytes of on-board memory.

Being a Sony product the phone uses Pro Duo memory sticks as opposed to the more popular SD memory. I picked up a 2 gigabyte card in Akihabara for roughly 5000 yen ($40) at the same time I saw a 2 gigabyte SD memory card for about 3000 yen ($25).

Also found on the side of the phone is an “EZ FeliCa” button which allows for the purchase of goods and service using the phone. On the other side of the closed clam shell is the USB plug in for connecting the device to the PC.

The phone comes with a large 2.7-inch screen with a 16:9 widescreen display. It measures 105 × 48 × 19.3 mm and has an official talk time of 210 minutes and standby time of 270 hours (the phone lasts about 6 to 7 days on standby, but if used as a music player all day battery life shrinks to a day). Typical of most cell phones today, the W51S has a small notch on the top corner that allows you to attach cute Hello Kitty-like accessories on your phone. (I see many Japanese do this and in  some cases the accessories are larger  than the phone.)

This phone comes with a battery charging dock and earphones with remote control. Interestingly though, with AU by KDDI, the actual AC Adapter charger does not come with the phone – you are forced to purchase it separately for 1000 yen ($8). This may be an example of the “nickel and dimeing” that can happen in Japan.

I’ve found the service plans offered by AU by KDDI are more complex and more expensive than my previous phone contract in Canada. By signing on for a two-year contract, I did receive the phone for free, and similar to Canada, there is a penalty for cancelling the contract prematurely. Monthly prices vary depending on whether you are a first time customer or if you’ve been a customer for 11 months or longer.

The usage of minutes and the usage of packets (Internet based services) is separated clearly. For 3000 yen ($25) per month, I receive only 60 minutes of free talk time – but thankfully, the minutes that were not used in the last month are added on to this month’s total.

The high cost of calling appears to be a factor that forces most Japanese to text message or email as opposed to actually calling. To use email and other Internet based services there is a 300 yen ($2.45) default charge and most users sign on to a packet cost reduction service that costs 1050 yen ($8.59). With this service, the first 12,500 packets are free and additional packets used are at a reduced cost. If all you use is email, then 12,500 should be enough; but it is very easy to use up tens of thousands of packets instantly. I downloaded Final Fantasy II for my cell phone and visited a few websites, and these activities shot my packet use into the 40000 range instantly contributing to my 7000 yen cell phone bill.

I’ve used this phone as a music player, to send emails, to take pictures and to play a little Final Fantasy II (as a side note, I later discovered that FF II requires a monthly 525 yen ($4.29) fee, which I recently cancelled).  I also visited a few websites to look at maps of places I wanted to go to. Websites look distorted on the phone but not completely unusable. As a music player, this phone performs very well combined with the remote control earphone accessory. Loading music on to the phone is done using an iTunes-like software called au MusicPort. Sadly, the software is not as user friendly as iTunes and is quite cumbersome to use. The biggest negative I’ve found is MusicPort only allows the use of m4a, wma, and wav files. MP3 files cannot be used, forcing you to convert your existing MP3 music collection. As a music player, the phone performs like a typical MP3 player with a standard set of features.

Sending emails can be done in English or Japanese. but the features for Japanese are naturally far more developed. In Japanese, by just typing a few letters, words and phrases you are likely to use instantly pop up. No such feature exists for English.

For photos, the camera allows you to take pictures with a resolution from 240x320 all the way up to 1600x1200. There is a loud shutter sound that goes off when taking a picture that it appears I cannot turn off (which I’ve been told is a feature to discourage men from taking ‘secret shots’ of unsuspecting women).

Getting a cell phone was a unique experience in my first couple months of officially living in Japan. Compared to cell phones in North America, the products and services available to the Japanese are far superior. I suppose that is one advantage of having a massive population on a small landmass – it is easier for cell carriers to rapidly implement infrastructure improvements and new technologies.



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

blah
By Andrevas on 7/20/2007 2:26:15 PM , Rating: 2
honestly, besides the slick design of that phone, I have NOOOO reason to want it over my W810i, which has the exact same features (including camera, and hey, mine can disable the shutter noise, it's called put the phone on silent mode!)

Also, that's a bust you have to use Sony's software to upload music and in limited format support, my Sony phone supports MP3s and just requires installing the driver disc, it acts like an external drive or can be used with the included software, which still lets me put MP3s on it.




RE: blah
By aos007 on 7/20/2007 6:05:55 PM , Rating: 2
You can only disable shutter sound on W810 if you have an unlocked phone, which in Canada can only be obtained from Sony directly. It costs WAY more than from Rogers - last year you were able to get it for $200 on a 3 year contract, but it was $550 plus tax from Sony. Rogers phone not only won't disable shutter sound when it's on silent but also won't let you use mp3 ringtones (!!) in the later shipments.


RE: blah
By Marcus Yam on 7/20/2007 6:17:07 PM , Rating: 2
It's also pretty stupid how Flash themes were disabled until you unlocked the phone.

For that very reason, I've been refraining from updating to newer firmware even though I'm always compelled to be running the newest stuff.

Any idea what I've been missing out from the latest firmware as compared to the launch release?


RE: blah
By Andrevas on 7/21/2007 5:55:06 AM , Rating: 2
I have a locked Cingular W810i

I got it for $50 after rebate with a 2 year contract last December from a corporate store

sounds like depending on the carrier, the phone sucks or rocks, I have had no complaints with mine, the tones I download from Cingular are obviously not MP3 format, but I can upload my own ringtones and message tones to the phone in MP3 format


RE: blah
By otispunkmeyer on 7/23/2007 3:50:13 AM , Rating: 2
i have a sony K800i on orange. £30 a month contract.

turn on silent, shutter noise goes away. infact there are a choice of several different shutter noises, apart from the one that actually sounds like a SLR going off the rest are pretty obscure! lol

k800i is in the cybershot range though so its camera is pretty awesome and its got a proper flash instead of a white LED.

my previous samsung however... did have a shutter noise that you couldnt turn off locked or unlocked.

personally i think that is a great idea, anything that try's to limit peados and perv's is good in my book.


Sony software
By oTAL (blog) on 7/20/2007 10:53:36 AM , Rating: 1
quote:
Sadly, the software is not as user friendly as iTunes and is quite cumbersome to use.


If that is your major complaint, then Sony must have improved their software quality tremendously. As a former user of a net mini-disc I can tell you that Sony's SonicStage was one of the worst applications I have ever used (and I've been working with computers for a LONG time).
That piece of shit converted MP3s with such a poor quality that you had to work around it using nero and daemon tools, to record CD images with your mp3 and convert them back to ATTRAC. So, *when* it worked (huge amount of crashes), it forced you to take a lengthy path just to get some decent quality music on your player.
That's not the only horrible Sony software I've used, but it was the one that caused me the most grief as it turned a great product which costed me over $300, into a painful experience. Deep hatred for Sony here....... for MANY reasons (I didn't even mention the driver issues for their products...).




RE: Sony software
By AlexWade on 7/20/2007 2:06:53 PM , Rating: 2
The software is probably from Ericsson, not Sony. Ericsson's software is, to me, one of the best out there. Actually, Ericsson make some of the best phones in the world.


RE: Sony software
By Belard on 7/23/2007 7:40:33 AM , Rating: 2
Agreed, the software on SONY phone is quite good. I've had Nokia, LG and Samsung... LG was okay, Samsung drove me nuts - so limited... but about the worst I ever used was a friend's Razar Family of phones (krazer/Slvers included) which are bugggy, slow and require so many button presses to do simple things.

AT&T is not selling many SONY phones anymore, just 1 model rather than the usual 4-6 to choose from.


Designed not a mistake
By feelingshorter on 7/20/2007 5:48:17 PM , Rating: 2
quote:
appears I cannot turn off (which I’ve been told is a feature to discourage men from taking ‘secret shots’ of unsuspecting women)


Thats hilarious. My Samsung also has a loud noise when you take a picture and it cannot be turned off, although you can change it to different sounds. I always thought it was a design mistake. Makes sense now.




RE: Designed not a mistake
By killerroach on 7/22/2007 12:54:00 PM , Rating: 2
If I recall, such a provision is actually law in Japan, that camera phones have to make a clearly audible sound when taking a picture... specifically to try to discourage voyeurs.


Sleek Looking handset
By indianpunk on 7/20/2007 10:08:27 AM , Rating: 3
Looks Sleek
Features set does not bring much to the plate but i guess it does the job nicely any chances of this seing the international lime light

By the way i was considering getting myself a samsung u600 or d900 after my Nokia 6600 crawled up to its death bed
Any warning / suggestions u would like give to me before i take the plunge
Ps - i live in India so we automatically get unlocked handsets and can use our old sim with any handsets we want :-)




By darkpaw on 7/20/2007 4:29:48 PM , Rating: 2
Wow, 60 minutes and charged per packet thats pretty insane.

Last time I had so few minutes I was using an ancient Motorola bag phone. I'd probably blow the packet limit in a day too considering how much web browsing I do on my phone.




By skyyspam on 7/23/2007 11:34:12 AM , Rating: 2
I agree whole-heartedly with the OP. I just got back from a 6-month tour in Japan, and one of the cultural/national differences I was impressed with most was the quality and affordability of cell phones and plans.

I used a Vodafone 805SS (Samsung) and SoftBank for the provider. The cost of my phone plan was only 900 Yen, or roughly $8.50 USD a month. And no kidding--on months where I didn't place international calls to the States (which is only $0.50 a minute on weekends, without any extra calling cards/plans), the bill was exactly as planned--no hidden fees or rate hikes, etc.

The only negative was that occasionally, the cell phone provider would send a spam text message--but it seriously happened once evert two weeks.

Now that I'm back in the states, I've had to dust off my old RAZR and start up a $40/mo plan with T-Mobile again. I do like my phone, and I do like T-Mobile, but the network and the cost just can't compare.

Come on, America, why hasn't competition lowered our rates yet?




3g
By WillieEvercome on 7/23/2007 1:22:28 PM , Rating: 2
The reason why we dont have these types of phone is because wireless phone companies collude to sandbag us. They try everything they can to keep their oligopoly on us and keep us paying $50 a month. Cool services like full 3g and 4g have been held back from us for fear of loss of profit.




"Intel is investing heavily (think gazillions of dollars and bazillions of engineering man hours) in resources to create an Intel host controllers spec in order to speed time to market of the USB 3.0 technology." -- Intel blogger Nick Knupffer
Latest By Stephen Kamizuru
Robot Shopping a Reality in Japan
July 22, 2008, 8:03 AM
iPhone Launches in Japan
July 12, 2008, 1:07 PM
Blu-ray Domination in Japan
February 15, 2008, 12:48 PM
Getting Fit with the Wii in Japan
December 5, 2007, 12:34 PM
Driving LED Emoticon
July 26, 2007, 2:05 PM













botimage
Copyright 2008 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki