Microsoft has settled its long-running antitrust case in
Iowa. The lawsuit, which was initially filed in 2000, claimed that Microsoft
was involved in anticompetitive business practices which in turn resulted in
higher prices for consumers.
The lead plaintiffs in the case, Des Moines lawyer Roxanne
Conlin and Minneapolis lawyer Richard Hagstrom will receive
$75 million in legal fee and expenses as a result of the settlement -- a
record for the state of Iowa.
The $75 million in fees represent a bill rate of $575 an
hour for each of the 150 lawyers, clerks and paralegals involved in the case.
Over a seven year period, 117,000 hours were logged in relation to the case.
The individual rate for Conlin and Hagstrom works out to $1,072 dollars per
hour. The payout for the two lawyers also includes a 43 percent risk premium
which was approved by a Polk County district judge.
While the lawyers will receive $75 million, Iowans will
receive $179.95 million -- $330 million was originally requested. Microsoft
will dish out $10, $16, $25 and $29 respectively for Word/Works/Home Essential,
Windows/DOS, Excel and Office. Individual consumers can claim up to $200
without a proof of purchase, however, any amount exceeding $200 must be backed
with supporting documentation.
Iowa consumers will receive their settlements in checks from
Microsoft while businesses and government bodies will receive pay vouchers.
Some Iowans aren't happy with the settlements they are
receiving in relation to the payout reserved for lawyer fees. "How in the
name of all that is sacred can you even imagine that to be equitable?" inquired
Parkersburg resident Betty Klingenbord. "I also do not like how this
makes Iowa look. Where will these lawsuits end?"
The settlement covers Iowans who purchased Microsoft
software between May 18, 1994 and June 30, 2006. Customers who wish to receive
their reimbursements from Microsoft must do so before the December 14 deadline.
quote: Then let's just dissolve MS.
quote: Fact is, the only thing keeping their monopoly alive is that the public perceives it in their best interests to do so.
quote: If these other OS were viable alternatives for the public at large, MS would no longer exist today as the OS figurehead they are.
quote: Opinions about Microsoft not included
quote: I do think that Microsoft is fairly pricing what they sell.
quote: I think we all agree (maybe except for a few) that Windows XP right now is still better than Windows Vista. The issue with Vista is it's compatibility.
quote: And please stop with the computers aren't essenstial crap. You know it as well as I do that computers today are entirely essential.
quote: And please stop with the computers aren't essenstial crap.
quote: 1. exclusive control of a commodity or service in a particular market, or a control that makes possible the manipulation of prices.
quote: There really aren't many alternatives. A majority of hardware and software is for windows. It will be hard to find things for mac, and forget finding linux software at your local CC.
quote: Microsoft fuels this by making it hard for people to open Word Documents with alternative Office Suites
quote: also by making it hard for people running different OSes to run DirectX games
quote: In the end, I'm sure more people will be more open to Microsoft once it decides, if it ever does, to open up.