 For netbook users, slow browsers can kill battery life -- one of several compelling arguments FutureMark's president gives about why users should care about speed and potentially ditch slower browsers like Internet Explorer 8. (Source: Flickr)
Futuremark's president answers a compelling question -- why should we care how fast our browser is
DailyTech's interview with
Oliver Baltuch introduced readers to Futuremark's
new web benchmarking suite. The suite promises to bring the
benchmarking goodness of 3DMark to the web and truly lay to rest the
question of who is fastest in a market where every browser maker
claims to be the speed king. The first part of the interview
touched on many controversial conclusions -- Windows 7 browsing
faster than Vista, OS X browsing faster than Windows, and the speed
title being jointly held by Apple's Safari and Google's Chrome.
In
the reader responses to the last segment, a number of good points
were raised. One reader noted that no benchmark is 100 percent
conclusive -- every benchmark has its biases. This is certainly
true. Still other readers pointed out that just because Chrome
and Safari may be faster in pure speed, but that speed alone doesn't
necessarily equate to a better browsing experience. Security
and an optimal interface are arguably equally or more valuable to the
customer than speed. Even Mr. Baltuch, acknowledged this,
informally, in his admission that he uses Opera 10.0 beta 2 -- not
the very fastest browser, but a very user friendly one -- for his
daily browsing.
However, that returns to the key question
which a large number of the readers asked in one form or another --
"Why should I care about browser speed?" Mr. Baltuch
offers a very compelling argument as to just why home and business
users should care.
For businesses Mr. Baltuch states,
"Using a slower browser could cause your employees to lose up to
15 minutes per day due to page lag. In a company with 5,000
people, that's what -- 1,250 hours?"
He goes on to point
out that the cost of hiring 3 or 4 extra IT people (72-96 hours of
effort) to support the extra security and management needed for a
faster, but less manageable browser like Firefox or Opera, by far
outweighs the losses of inaction in terms of employee compensation
and power use. He says there's simply no justification for
businesses sticking to slower browsers like Internet Explorer 6,
Internet Explorer 7, or even Internet Explorer 8 -- just because they
are easier to manage.
He points out that at a large
organization like the U.S. State Department, with over 50,000
employees (which recently rejected
Firefox) could be saving 12,500 hours a day. He states,
"The average state department employee is making, around $50 an
hour -- that's $625,000 a day lost."
For home users he
says the argument for speed is particularly compelling on laptops,
netbooks, and older computers. Faster loads means less power
consumed, typically. On a
netbook or older computer, both of which typically have slower
processors, slower browsers perform particularly badly he says. They
waste time and, in the netbook's case, battery life. On faster
computers, speed is certainly less of a real issue -- but many
enthusiasts prefer the idea of having all their software be as
optimized as possible.
At the end of the day the conclusion
seems to be this -- while it's intriguing to see who has the fastest
browser, users should base their decision on a combination of four
key factors -- speed, security, user interface, and compatibility.
Taking these additional factors into account both helps and hurts
some browsers. For example, Internet Explorer 8 is already hurting
from being declared the slowest of the leading browsers and falls
behind on compatibility, but it gains on security and it arguably
breaks even on interface. For others browsers -- Firefox and
Opera, chiefly -- these additional factors lead to the conclusion
that while they may not be the fastest browser, their combination of
speed and other assets make them possibly the best browsers.
"Death Is Very Likely The Single Best Invention Of Life" -- Steve Jobs
|
Most Popular ArticlesReport: Apple to Debut iPad 3 During First Week of March February 10, 2012, 9:36 AM Nikon Announces 36.3MP D800, D800E D-SLRs February 7, 2012, 10:11 AM Quick Note: Acura Unveils Production Version of ILX Hybrid Sedan February 8, 2012, 9:10 AM Google's Motorola Mobility Purchase Approval Expected Next Week February 9, 2012, 3:02 PM AMD Concedes Die-Shrink Race to Intel, Considers ARM Cores February 6, 2012, 11:45 AM
|