backtop


Print 11 comment(s) - last by jharper12.. on Nov 12 at 11:01 PM


Portable GPS unit

Aftermarket in-dash GPS unit

Factory GPS in a 2011 Hyundai Sonata
Picking a new GPS unit isn't always easy

It used to be that when you were driving along in unfamiliar territory that you'd call on the carbon-based lifeform occupying the passenger's seat to call out directions from a paper map, or just drive around aimlessly for hours trying to reach your final destination (that is if you were too “above it all” to stop and ask for directions).

Today, we have GPS units that give visual turn-by-turn directions, speak street names, and provide real-time traffic information to always give you the fastest route to your destination. For those that don't require all of the visual stimulation of a “traditional” GPS unit, there's always GM's OnStar service.

These days, I lump GPS units into three distinct categories: portable GPS units that you can mount on your dash or windshield, aftermarket GPS units that replace the head unit in your dashboard, and factory units that are nicely integrated into your vehicle's dashboard.

For those that have older vehicles or dashboard designs that don't lend themselves to aftermarket units, the portable GPS unit makes a perfect choice. These units can be had for as low as about $70 and quickly escalate from there depending on what features you want (spoken street names, real-time traffic, Bluetooth capabilities, MP3 support, etc.). Another plus is that they are by design portable, so if you have more than one directionally challenged driver in your household, you can share the unit between vehicles.

The downside, however, is that you have unsightly cords running down your dash for power, and you have to remember to take the GPS down when your park your vehicle in public (lest you trust the unsavory individuals that would love the chance to “smash and grab” for a GPS unit or portable media player left out in the open).

Another option is the aftermarket in-dash “multimedia” GPS unit which also replaces the factory audio system in your vehicle. These units are quite the step up from portable GPS units and offer just about every feature that you could possibly want. In addition to the traditional CD/DVD, terrestrial radio, and satellite radio features, all of the usual GPS functionality that you would expect can be found with these systems.

When it comes to pricing, these systems are usually priced squarely between portable and factory GPS systems. They also require some basic knowledge of car electronics to install, but you can always call on a friend or have it installed by a professional.

The downside to these aftermarket systems, however, is that they don't always seem to “fit in” with the design aesthetic of the vehicle's interior. Your 1995 Honda Civic interior might just look a tad bit out of place with a 2010-era multimedia GPS unit in your dash. On the flip-side, some may find the futuristic looks of such a unit a fresh upgrade to an otherwise dowdy interior.

The final solution is the factory GPS system when purchasing a new car. For many people, this may be the best option because you get a GPS unit that was specifically designed for your vehicle and is neatly integrated into the dashboard. Factory GPS systems also often integrate multiple vehicle functions into the touch screen and can spread those controls to the steering wheel for quick access or to center console-mounted controls (think BMW's i-Drive or Audi's MMI).

The downside, however, is that factory GPS units can be extremely pricey and can often cost thousands of dollars. This is especially problematic for cost-conscious buyers that are simply looking for the GPS upgrade, but are forced to buy more expensive factory packages which might include GPS, leather seats, and a moonroof for example.

When it comes down to it, all often comes down to personal preference and your budget. Is portability a factor for you? Do you want to add a more integrated experience into an older vehicle? Or do you want a GPS system that perfectly integrates with your vehicle's interior design and control system? There's no right or wrong answer, but be sure to do your research before jumping in feet first.



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

Option 4: Smart Phone
By AmbroseAthan on 11/3/2010 2:51:03 PM , Rating: 2
I can not speak for all the carriers/phones, but I know most of Sprint's lineup includes GPS Navigation included in the service price already (being we have unlimited data).

On my phone I can use Google Navigation or Sprint Navigation, and both work perfectly fine: voice navigation, check & re-route around traffic, and easily provide any destination information I need.

I even recently downloaded GPS Navigation Charts of the entire East Coast for when sailing, for $10, and that works amazingly well!




RE: Option 4: Smart Phone
By JasonMick (blog) on 11/3/2010 3:28:20 PM , Rating: 2
quote:
On my phone I can use Google Navigation or Sprint Navigation, and both work perfectly fine: voice navigation, check & re-route around traffic, and easily provide any destination information I need.


I second that. Google Navigation Beta on my EVO smart phone works amazingly. It's VERY accurate when it comes to location and picks very fast/unobstructed routes -- faster than traditional Google Maps/Mapquest, or even other GPS devices I've used, in my experience.

The fact that it comes free with most Android phones (such as my EVO) is a strong selling point for them, IMO.


RE: Option 4: Smart Phone
By cfaalm on 11/12/2010 1:00:12 PM , Rating: 2
While I use Google Navigation on my HTC Legend and enjoy the feature, it has one important weakness: the voice. The level is low and the timbre unpleasant. How in the world of voices they dedided to pick this one is beyond me.

While otherwise adequate, it is useless abroad, unless you want to pay for data abroad on your cellphone. That is way too expensive to justify.

Luckily we also bought a TomTom Europe in 2009.


RE: Option 4: Smart Phone
By jharper12 on 11/12/2010 11:01:27 PM , Rating: 2
This is a comment on requiring data service and poor signal areas. First: Ovi maps for the Nokia is a great option for traveling abroad. I always just brought a cheap sim phone and bought a pay-as-you-go sim while abroad... it's the cheapest method. Now I have a Nuron 5230, and with Ovi maps I have all the local maps stored on the device itself... no data connection required. Great for travel in any country. While at home I just use my Evo... doesn't matter where I go, because I use a Wilson signal booster. Prior to the signal booster I would lose signal in the middle of nowhere, but now it just hasn't been an issue. The booster was cheap, I paid less than $100. Definitely worth while if you spend a lot of time traveling in your car.


RE: Option 4: Smart Phone
By abhaxus on 11/3/2010 3:47:54 PM , Rating: 1
The downside to cell phone GPS services is that they require data service to use. I usually turn to Sprint Nav when I'm driving somewhere I don't know, but I was recently burned on a drive way out to a country town in TN. Sprint Nav worked great getting me there... just when I left the wedding, I didn't have data service to get me back. When you're in the middle of nowhere, about a dozen turns and 25-30 miles off the interstate, it's hard to remember which way you turned when. I ended up turning the wrong way only once, realized it was the wrong way, and only ended up losing about 5 minutes. But it was an uncomfortable feeling for sure. This was with a Pre.

I hate portable GPS devices in the windshield myself. I think some people think they are status symbols or something. Laughable. I'll be getting a Kenwood in-dash around christmas time.


RE: Option 4: Smart Phone
By corduroygt on 11/3/2010 8:35:19 PM , Rating: 2
That's not true, there are many GPS apps that come with maps. They're large, more than a gigabyte at times, but they're there.
As early as 2006, I was using garmin on my S60 Nokia N95.


RE: Option 4: Smart Phone
By aebiv on 11/4/2010 11:25:38 AM , Rating: 2
The problem with Google Maps (on the Android it is quite stellar) and the rest of those which use your data connection to download your maps, is that if you're out in a low/no signal area, you're kind of screwed. Just like how if you are in a GPRS or EDGE only area, you can't be talking on the phone and using it as a GPS, which can be a major PITA. Even here in San Francisco there are many areas where you'll have no signal, or bad signal, and the cloud based GPS apps just downright fail.

I've had TomTom and iGO 8 on my smartphone for years, and they perform much better than any cloud based apps. However, they aren't free, and that turns a lot of people off.


RE: Option 4: Smart Phone
By bug77 on 11/4/2010 12:03:07 PM , Rating: 2
Neah, the new Desire HD and Z (and I think some Nokias too) can store maps for offline access. So this limitation will be a thing of the past shortly.


I think you left something out
By bug77 on 11/4/2010 10:23:33 AM , Rating: 2
The price of new and/or updated maps. Afaik, those can make a big difference too.




RE: I think you left something out
By marvdmartian on 11/5/2010 11:43:48 AM , Rating: 1
Currently, you can purchase lifetime updates for Garmin GPS units for <$80 on Amazon.com. Versus about $30/year.

Personally, I can recommend the Garmin 855 unit. Voice recognition allows me to perform most functions without my hands ever leaving the steering wheel. They're currently found online for <$150. Good deal!


RE: I think you left something out
By Aikouka on 11/8/2010 6:45:06 PM , Rating: 2
It can get expensive for my Nissan factory GPS. I believe it's around $150 per year :(.


"The whole principle [of censorship] is wrong. It's like demanding that grown men live on skim milk because the baby can't have steak." -- Robert Heinlein














botimage
Copyright 2014 DailyTech LLC. - RSS Feed | Advertise | About Us | Ethics | FAQ | Terms, Conditions & Privacy Information | Kristopher Kubicki