It appears that Microsoft’s decision to close MSN Music has
rankled more than just customers: a
new statement and letter (PDF)
from the Electronic Frontier Foundation accuses Microsoft of betraying its
music customers by abandoning its store’s DRM servers.
“This decision means that every customer that bought an mp3
from you—with the good faith expectation that despite the irritating DRM she
would be able to continue to play the song on a variety of devices—faces losing
music if she upgrades her PCs or her hard drive crashes after August 31, 2008,”
wrote EFF Executive Director Shari Steel, in an open letter to Microsoft dated
April 29.
Previously, Microsoft’s Rob Bennet suggested that customers
who wanted to keep their music beyond the blackout’s August 31 date had to either
preserve their computer’s functionality or export their purchased music to a CD
and then re-rip the music back to mp3 files. This solution, as
previously discussed, forces Microsoft customers to “invest more time,
labor and money in order to continue to enjoy the music for which they have
already paid.”
The EFF’s statement announcing the letter further
elaborates: “The odd thing about this suggestion is that the more music you
bought from Microsoft -- the more of a loyal customer you were -- the more time
you are expected to spend sitting in front of your computer, burning discs and
then re-importing them (degrading the sound quality in the process).”
In a previous interview with CNET, Bennett said that “no one ever foresaw being in this
situation,” and expressed that the best long-term solution for people “who want
to buy music from Microsoft” is to switch to Microsoft’s Zune platform.
Steele’s letter to Microsoft closes with a series of
instructions that Microsoft “should immediately and publicly” follow if it
wants to rectify the situation:
- Issue a “full public apology” to MSN Music
customers.
- Offer its customers refunds, or, copies of their
music in a DRM-free format.
- Ensure that MSN Music customers have adequate access
to purchase receipts.
Additionally, Steele wants the company to work with its
industry partners to remove DRM in the future, and to make sure that MSN Music
customers are made aware of the above steps by, at minimum, “advertising in
major music magazines and newspapers in every major U.S. city, as well as targeted
keyword advertising.”