backtop


Print E-mail del.icio.us 180 comment(s) - last by rdeegvainl.. on Feb 22 at 10:35 AM

16 countries recommended for U.S. government watchdogs against digital piracy

The International Intellectual Property Alliance (IIPA), a coalition representing copyright-based industries such as the MPAA, RIAA, BSA and the ESA, submitted its recommendations to the Bush administration in its “Special 301” review of copyright piracy and market access problems around the world.

As they have in past years, China and Russia remain key problem countries, but most surprising to some are the new additions the coalition is targeting for 2007. IIPA recommends that an additional 14 countries be placed on the “Priority Watch List,” joining China and Russia for a total of 16 countries.

“Many of the key markets around the world that are infected with high levels of copyright piracy or deny effective market access to copyright industries,” said Eric H. Smith of the IIPA. “The unwillingness of the countries identified in our submission to curb high rates of piracy – in most countries, through more effective and deterrent enforcement – saps the U.S. economy of the high-paying jobs and strong growth rates that make this sector critical to the health of the U.S. economy.”

Canada is targeted as one of the biggest offenders out of all developed nations. “Canada’s long tenure on the USTR Watch List seems to have had no discernible effect on its copyright policy. Almost alone among developed economies in the OECD, Canada has taken no steps toward modernizing its copyright law to meet the new global minimum standards of the WIPO Internet Treaties,” the IIPA wrote in its filing to U.S. Trade Representative Susan Schwab. “Its enforcement record also falls far short of what should be expected of our neighbor and largest trading partner … Canada lacks effective border controls on pirated products, and most of its other enforcement efforts suffer from insufficient resources and a lack of deterrent impact.”

The report states that pirates have taken advantage of the gaps in Canadian law to make it a “leading exporter” of camcorder bootleg movies and modchips for video game consoles. Officials at Industry Canada did not comment directly on the report, but spokesman David Dummer did say to the Globe and Mail, “The government of Canada is working actively on the copyright file and will take the time necessary to ensure that revisions to this important framework legislation have been fully thought through.”

The IIPA indicated that the new Canadian Conservative government that took office in March 2006 has expressed greater commitment to modernization of Canada’s copyright laws than did the previous Liberal rule, but to date it has not released a draft of legislation.

Steering its attentions from north to south of the U.S., the IIPA also lists Mexico as the other sore spot in North America. Out of all estimated total trade losses due to piracy, Mexico ranked only behind China and Russia, making it the third highest on the priority watch list. Mexico’s estimated $1 billion lost is less than half of the losses from China and Russia, but is almost double of Canada’s fourth place $551 million.

“The sheer dimension of the piracy problem in the Mexican market remains severe. Piracy involving hard goods, optical discs, Internet piracy, street piracy, and unauthorized photocopying at universities continued at high levels,” the IIPA wrote.

The IIPA suggests that Mexico must focus efforts to fight piracy in well-know street markets (San Juan de Dios in Guadalajara) and distribution centers (such as like Tepito in the Federal District) where vast quantities of pirated goods are sold in broad daylight. Other recommendations include: increased resources for enforcement agencies and improved public awareness of the nature and repercussions of rampant piracy; intensified judicial training; stronger border measures; and stopping illegal photocopying by copy shops on or near major university campuses.

The IIPA is not only targeting countries that are inducing massive trade losses, the coalition is also putting priority on governments who do not have appropriate copyright laws in place. For example, Israel ranks near the bottom in terms of total losses at $98 million, but is on the priority list because of the IIPA’s dissatisfaction with a copyright bill passed by the Knesset, the Israeli government’s legislative body.

“The bill, if passed in its current language, would discriminate against foreign producers of sound recordings specifically, and potentially violate Israel’s bilateral obligations to the United States. The government of Israel should refrain from taking any steps that would weaken copyright protection, particularly for foreign sound recordings, at a time when copyright protection is increasingly fragile in Israel,” filed the IIPA.

The IIPA finds that the bill draft does not include provisions to protect against circumvention of technological protection measures used to protect digital artistic works and should be rejected by the Knesset. The IIPA also complains that the Israeli police “are not actively pursuing Internet piracy cases and are not willing to assist in the raiding of Internet pirates.”

Argentina, Chile, Costa Rica, the Dominican Republic, Egypt, India, Saudi Arabia, Thailand, Turkey, Ukraine and Venezuela are the other countries named in the IIPA’s Priority Watch List.



Comments     Threshold


This article is over a month old, voting and posting comments is disabled

i probem with how international pricing works
By Papa Lorenzo on 2/16/2007 3:12:15 AM , Rating: 5
i live in israel and yes, there is a piracy problem here.
however, there is no way to solve this problem until the big firms understand that they must charge different in some places.
the minimum wage in israel is less then $1000US a month.
the average wage is less then $2000 a month.
software and other products are priced in israel as if we are earning like western europians or americans. to most israelis it just doesn't make any economical sense to splash out the high prices on office, windows, other utilities and especially games.
games new game can cost here between 55-75 dollars. maybe that is the same as you americans pay but for us it's a lot more money.
office can cost here more then a quarter of a minimum wage.
it's ridiculous.
if they want piracy to stop then they must figure out a new international pricing scheme which would set prices according to the countries average income/minimum wage/GDP/currency power...




By Papa Lorenzo on 2/16/2007 3:54:58 AM , Rating: 3
1st i=a


By crystal clear on 2/16/2007 4:33:38 AM , Rating: 2
"there is a piracy problem here"

Yes it exist all over the world incl the USA-whats so great about ISRAEL?-Israel is not any special case.

"to most israelis it just doesn't make any economical sense to splash out the high prices on office, windows, other "

You have the highest taxation rate in the world-sometimes
200% custom duty-"THAT DOESNT MAKE ANY ECONOMIC SENSE"
Your Income tax is one of the highest in the world-Now dont quote statistics.Add to this the VAT.

The problem is on your side (in your case)

"which would set prices according to the countries average income/minimum wage/GDP/currency power... "

Only to have cheap priced products as per your scheme-

RE-EXPORTED BACK TO THE USA & other countries for a fat profit.(on the grey/black market)

Countries should cut their taxes to make these products
affordable.










RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By Tsuwamono on 2/18/2007 11:48:29 AM , Rating: 2
maybe you should take a look at Denmark's tax rate.


By GNStudios on 2/18/2007 1:19:50 PM , Rating: 2
or Swedens. My dads incometax is 56%.


RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By Belegost on 2/16/2007 5:04:16 AM , Rating: 3
I live in the US, and I'm rather against this sort of pricing structure. So I'm going to make two points here: 1) Why many companies don't price by region 2) Why I'm against the idea.

1) Under current US copyright law, if an item is legally purchased in a foreign country, and then subsequently imported to the US, it can be resold without any restrictions from the copyright holder. There are in fact markets (the most well-known being university textbooks) that market at different price points in different regions. Taking the textbooks example, I'm a grad student at UCSD, this quarter I had to buy 2 engineering textbooks. One of the books cost $150US here in the states, however I bought the identical book from an exporter in the UK, I paid $70US after international shipping costs. Had I chose to, I could have bought a cheaper version from India (paperback, low quality printing) for $25US after shipping costs. And, under US law this is legal, and I hold full rights to the book. Of course the textbook companies do not at all appreciate this.

However, this brings me to point 2) Why should I subsidize your materials? A company has to price products so that it makes money on the sales, and if it prices it significantly lower in one region then the regions paying the higher prices are in effect paying extra to allow this. Somehow I highly doubt the book publishers could recoup the costs on a book if they sold it globally for the $8 they sell it for in India.

I call BS. Why should I pay for other people to get things for less than the true cost? Especially things like textbooks, and software which help people who I am in competition with for jobs.

Piracy has the same effect, but at least then the people doing the pirating are legally wrong.

Oh, and as for the minimum wage - here in the US the federal minimum wage is currently around $8/hour. Working a standard 40 hour week, that produces $1280/month gross income, which is then subject to federal, state, and local taxes and withholdings. It isn't as though things are so much richer here.


RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By Sunbird on 2/16/2007 8:16:00 AM , Rating: 2
Well, the rest of the world pays more for hardware than the US. To buy a 8800GTX graphics card here (South Africa,not a typical down in the dumops african country)) costs at minimum $850 if converted to US currency. And thats the cheapest one I could find locally.

Seems it all just balances out in the end...


By Chillin1248 (blog) on 2/16/2007 9:52:23 AM , Rating: 2
To buy a 7600 GT in Israel would cost me roughly $250 after taxes, I purchased mine from the U.S. and had a friend bring it over for only $128; a big disparity. Good luck getting a 8800 GTX.

And for further amusement, Windows Vista was first launched in Israel; however ironically it did not come with Hebrew supported.

Cars here in Israel carry a roughly 89% or more tax rate, that without the import costs and custom taxes. So a car that costs maybe $12,000 in America would cost here roughly $36,000. Gas here is also double the U.S. So directly comparing wages is not the same as comparing living costs. Also the wages are taxed :)

-------
Chillin


RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By Tsuwamono on 2/18/2007 11:52:09 AM , Rating: 2
where do your taxes go anyway? In canada our sales tax is 15% for most provinces but go as low as 7 in Alberta. However we have social programs like public health care, VASTLY reduced tuition costs and things like welfare, get back to work programs, government retirement plans etc.


RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By Russell on 2/19/2007 5:06:28 AM , Rating: 2
Their taxes go to the same place US taxes go: towards weapons.


By masher2 (blog) on 2/19/2007 8:20:44 AM , Rating: 3
> "Their taxes go to the same place US taxes go: towards weapons..."

Do people really misunderstand their own government budget this badly? The largest component by far of both the US and Canadian budgets is entitlement and wealth redistribution programs-- not the military.


RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By Some1ne on 2/16/2007 6:57:56 PM , Rating: 2
quote:
Piracy has the same effect, but at least then the people doing the pirating are legally wrong.


Which is exactly why the laws need to be changed. The IIPA is the true plague, and piracy is just part of the cure.


RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By Tyler 86 on 2/16/2007 8:32:35 PM , Rating: 2
The IIPA may be a plague, but piracy will never be part of a cure.

Piracy problems or not, they are making a tidy profit.
People who won't buy for any reason, won't buy; the IIPA will sink.


By Tsuwamono on 2/18/2007 11:53:47 AM , Rating: 2
*Singing* Ding dong the witch is dead *End singing*


By masher2 (blog) on 2/16/2007 8:33:34 AM , Rating: 2
> "the minimum wage in israel is less then $1000US a month...

In the US, the minimum wage is $1030 a month. I'm not seeing a big difference here.

> "if they want piracy to stop then they must figure out a new international pricing scheme which would set prices according to the countries average income/minimum wage/GDP/currency power..."

They should do the same thing for sports cars also. That way you could buy a Ferrari in China for $99.

Seriously, the logic that "we have a right to steal because we can't afford to buy" has got to go. Especially when you're using it to justify pirating a $50 game.


RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By wien on 2/16/2007 9:08:13 AM , Rating: 2
quote:
They should do the same thing for sports cars also. That way you could buy a Ferrari in China for $99.
Until someone invents an automated Ferrari replicator, please, for the sake of my sanity, drop that argument. It's not even close to being the same thing.


By masher2 (blog) on 2/16/2007 9:23:09 AM , Rating: 3
> "It's not even close to being the same thing..."

Until someone invents intellectual property that invents itself, promotes itself, and distributes itself, its exactly the same thing.

As a holder of numerous patents, I make a great deal of money off intellectual property. A person can easily replicate my work for zero cost. But doing so robs me, and ignores not only the time I spent to develop that patent, but the decades of schooling and training I needed in preparation for it.

So when new patents, songs, and videos start appearing out of thin air, you can call it an invalid argument. Until then, its perfectly on the mark.


RE: i probem with how international pricing works
By wien on 2/16/2007 9:52:53 AM , Rating: 2
No. You lost nothing. You may have failed to earn something. If you can't see the difference there, I just don't know what to tell you.