 RIAA-partner, PRS threatened to sue Sandra Burk, a British woman, for singing on the job. They eventually back down after a torrent of negative publicity. (Source: BBC News)
Yet another example of irresponsible copyright enforcement rears its ugly head
From suing dead people, to attacking CD-burning
of legally-owned content for personal use, to seeking damages against
people who don't own a computer, it doesn't seem like there's many
lows to which copyright protection organizations like the RIAA
won't stoop. However, a recent case involving the Performing
Right Society (PRS) -- a British RIAA affiliate -- shows that even
the most curmudgeonly copyright organization can occasionally come
around, when faced with overwhelming public scorn.
The
humorous tale involves the organization catching wind of a “heinous”
offense -- an
employee singing in public. Sandra Burt, 56, who works at
A&T Food store (a British supermarket) in Clackmannanshire, UK
was told by organization representatives that she would likely face
fines for lost royalties for her "performance".
The
debacle began earlier in the year when the PRS threatened the grocery
store she worked at, telling them to ditch the radio that played in
earshot of customers or pay royalty fees. Missing the music,
Ms. Burt decided to start singing some of her favorite tunes.
She describes, "I would start to sing to myself when I was
stacking the shelves just to keep me happy because it was very quiet
without the radio."
Then came new threats from the PRS.
Ms. Burt describes, "When I heard that the PRS said I would be
prosecuted for not having a performance license, I thought it was a
joke and started laughing. I was then told I could be fined
thousands of pounds. But I couldn't stop myself singing. They would
need to put a plaster over my mouth to get me to stop, I can't help
it."
Indeed, the woman, who describes herself as a
Rolling Stones fan and classic rocker, refused to stop singing.
BBC News caught wind of the story and published a piece on
it.
The reaction was instant, with many writing furious
letters to the PRS. Facing an overwhelming outpouring of public
vehemence, the PRS backed down, as the RIAA occasionally has.
They sent her a bouquet of flowers as an apology and said she had
their permission to keep singing. The note read, "We're
very sorry we made a big mistake. We hear you have a lovely
singing voice and we wish you good luck."
"Spreading the rumors, it's very easy because the people who write about Apple want that story, and you can claim its credible because you spoke to someone at Apple." -- Investment guru Jim Cramer
|
Most Popular ArticlesEasy Fix to Prevent Microsoft From Bricking Xbox 360s HDDs Arrives November 18, 2009, 6:41 AM Anti-Evolution Actor Modifies Darwin's Work With Questionable Intro November 22, 2009, 12:12 PM Built Around the Browser, Google's Chrome OS Launches, Reinvents the Operating System November 19, 2009, 2:40 PM Climategate: Stunning Deception and Misconduct at UK Warming Research Center Revealed November 20, 2009, 4:00 PM Update: OCZ Technology Announces 3.5" 1TB Colossus SSDs November 23, 2009, 9:58 AM
|